Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines | Analysis

TRADE-LABOUR: On Standards Issue, North-South Divide Remains Wide

Analysis - Johanna Son

SINGAPORE, Dec 9 1996 (IPS) - Deep divisions among governments on whether to link trade with labour standards will make it very difficult for the World Trade Organisation (WTO) to pronounce itself on the issue at its ministerial meeting here this week.

Some Western governments, led by the United States, would like to see the WTO’s ministerial declaration mention the need to work toward ‘core labour standards’, such as non-use of child labour and recognition of collective bargaining rights that they say may suffer as liberalised trade opens up markets all over the world.

But the gulf of differences that persist among both Northern and Southern governments remains wide, making the forging of a consensus an uphill climb for ministers from the WTO’s 128 member countries meeting for the first time since the new world trade body began functioning in 1995.

Nearly all the represented governments addressing the plenary sessions, which started Monday, are touching on trade’s linkage with labour. But clearly, linking trade with labour standards has become a political minefield.

Indeed, the differences on the matter are not falling exclusively on North-South lines. Similar fault lines run through the non- governmental organisation (NGO) community, which is holding meetings on the sidelines of the WTO meeting.

“We believe strongly that increased trade and the economic growth that it brings should also engender greater respect for the basic human rights which are the focus of our core ‘labour standards’ proposal,” U.S. Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky told Monday’s session.

But most developing countries said that while they support labour protection, the use of trade sanctions to enforce standards runs the risk of being used as a new form of protectionism by industrialised nations keen on keeping out exports from countries that have a competitive labour cost edge.

Indian Commerce Minister B.B. Ramaiah said: “We are of the opinion that trade measures should not be used to address non- trade objectives.

And Pakistan said linking trade with labour only “encourages protectionist lobbies” to whittle away at the legitimate competitive advantage of developing countries”.

Also, Thai Finance Minister Amnuay Viravan sees no rush to link trade with labour, “unless there is an ulterior motive to bring in the issue as disguised protectionism”.

British head of the trade and industry department, parliamentarian Ian Lang, took a similar stand, saying trade measures to enforce social standards would weaken poorer countries and “make them less able to remedy social problems”.

There is as yet no consensus on whether there will be any mention of labour rights or the social clause in the WTO’s final document, WTO officials say. “For some governments, the only agreement they will accept is a blank paper (on this),” said Richard Eglin, an official with the WTO secretariat.

“Even if we get agreement to go back to Geneva to do anything, it will take a long, long time,” he told IPS. “Because governments are so divided, and even (with some agreement) this week, we won’t see this positions really changing.”

The debate on labour standards and whether they should at all be linked to trade action is similar in many ways to the discussion on trade and environment, a subject that has gone farther down the WTO’s agenda.

When governments agreed on new trade rules in 1994 and created the WTO — the successor body of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) — they also formed a committee on trade and environment to study how multilateral trade rules are tied with ‘green’ standards. The panel issued its first report in November.

The creation of a committee to tackle what is called a ‘work programme’ in WTO language, as what was carried for environment issues, is one option available to WTO ministers that would start off a discussion to run into several years.

Links between environment and trade have been discussed since 1990, but it took four years before ministers formed a trade and environment panel. But this brings little comfort to NGOs that oppose any discussion of labour within a trade context. Said Uruguayan activist Roberto Bissio: “Once a discussion starts, it becomes negotiations.”

Leon Brittan, European Union (EU) trade commissioner, says a ‘work programme’ does not bind countries to negotiations since “there can be no coercion in the WTO”.

Some activists say the world trade body’s setting of minimum labour standards will help ensure that as cut-throat competition ensues over trade and investment in coming years, wage rates and labour protection will not be sacrificed.

Said the Brussels-based International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU): “If the WTO is to strengthen its authority as the world’s promoter of free and fair trade, it must ensure that basic and trade union rights are not repressed in pursuit of competitive advantage.”

It wants the WTO to put up a special working group that will, together with the International Labour Organisation (ILO), examine how world trade rules can protect workers’ rights in a non- protectionist way. The ILO has set core labour standards in different labour conventions, but has little enforcement power.

This, says British-based NGO Oxfam International, is why the WTO must attach a social clause in all its trade agreements that would bind governments to respect workers’ rights on pain of losing trade benefits and facing trade sanctions, and which would allow workers to lobby for rightful wages.

But a group of 34 NGOs from Africa, Asia and the Caribbean, convened by the Malaysia-based Third World Network (TWN), said a social clause has no place in the WTO and that forcing it in this year’s meeting can become a “pretext or an excuse for Northern protectionism against Southern exports”.

Bissio says a WTO social clause is not good for upholding labour rights because they would be concerned only when they involve exported goods. He argued: “What would happen to products for the domestic market? Violations don’t count there? “That’s not the way to enforce human or labour rights.”

Proponents of a social clause say trade sanctions may be the most effective way of disciplining rights violators, but Bissio says the WTO would not give sanctions but just allow a member country to take unilateral action against another for violating core labour standards.

The U.S. proposal, floated last month, would have WTO countries “renew” their commitment to core labour standards, support for the ILO to study these standards and state that protectionist measures must not be used to enforce labour standards or to “put into question” the competitive advantage of low-wage countries.

Some NGOs in fact say they suspect some industrialised countries are harping on labour standards even though they know a consensus is unlikely, so that they can use it as a bargaining chip for their other goals here — like an accord on freeing trade in information technology, or starting discussion toward global rules for investment.

Despite the controversy generated in linking trade and labour issue, Brittan says he thinks “we have the makings of an understanding on that issue”.

Assuming the WTO manages to forge some consensual language in the next few days, the debate surrounding the place of labour standards in the world’s trade policing body will not end in Singapore, and will brew on for years to come.

Gunter Rexrodt, the German minister of economics, cautions against direct confrontation on the issue. “We must not bring into the WTO a confrontation about cultural and social values. This would destroy the credibility of the system.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags