Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

TRADE: Swiss Call for Transparency and Participation in WTO

Gustavo Capdevila

GENEVA, Dec 3 1996 (IPS) - More than a hundred members of both chambers of the Federal Swiss Parliament criticised the World Trade Organisation (WTO) for its lack of democracy, calling for greater transparency and more independent sector participation.

The Swiss legislators told WTO director-general, Italy’s Renato Ruggiero, that “transparency and participation are the essential elements both in the WTO and the national spheres.”

The WTO currently carries out all its activities in strict confidentiality in meetings closed to the public, including the press and the non governmental organisations (NGOs).

This declaration signed by 129 members of the Senate and National Council, stressed that access to information is the only way of setting foundations for the formation of independent judgement on the WTO.

The WTO, which took over from the disbanded General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), is defined as the “legal and institutional basis of the multilateral trade system.”

The Swiss members of parliament said the document presented to Ruggiero is a contribution to the preparation of the WTO Ministerial Conference which will take place from Dec. 9 to 13 in Singapore.

The Singapore meeting will evaluate the WTO action and the progress made in the application of the Agreements from the Uruguay Round of GATT, signed two years ago in Marrakesh, Morocco

The legislators told Ruggiero the consultative participation of the interested NGOs, along with the public and the business sector, would make trade policies better known and increase confidence.

In a document distributed Tuesday, the WTO itself said other NGOs had demanded greater institutional transparency and public responsibility from the entity.

A meeting of environmental NGOs called by the WTO said they were annoyed by the WTO policy of barring independent entities from their meetings.

As a result of the criticisms, the WTO decided to allow some NGOs to participate in the public sessions of the Singapore conference.

Ruggiero’s interview with the parliamentary delegation Monday was coordinated by the Swiss Coalition of Development Organisations, which included representatives from Swissaid, the Catholic Lenten Fund, Bread for All, Helvetas and Caritas.

The legislators told Ruggiero the recent creation of the International Centre on Trade and Sustainable Development in Switzerland, an independent group which will monitor the impact of trade policies on other social areas, was a great step forward.

“There is still a lot to be done to assure the private organisations can participate with greater facility in the WTO activities and for them to have free access to the information,” said the legislators.

The declaration introduced an innovatory element by proposing the establishment of new forms of parliamentary participation in the WTO processes.

The legislators updated a proposal by the Swiss secretary of state, Franz Blankart, who suggested the constitution a WTO parliament formed by individual members of the member states.

“This idea could help make up for the lack of democracy in the WTO,” they said.

The WTO has 128 member states. Another 28 states, including China, Russia, the Ukraine and Saudi Arabia are awaiting approval of their membership requests.

The members of parliament asked for the WTO to contribute to the application of the basic labour rights in cooperation with the International Labour Organisation (ILO).

This observation resurrected one of the most conflictive points awaiting discussion in Singapore: that of the “social clause.”

Many of the industrialised countries, especially the United States and Norway, are demanding the multilateral trade agreements be related to the fulfillment of labour norms and that the WTO intervene in monitoring this.

Meanwhile, the developing countries, fearful of losing the competitive advantage of their lower labour costs, have rejected linking trade to the social question and have asked for the issue to remain solely in the hands of the ILO.

The Swiss legislators said one of the toughest challenges for the WTO and its members is to avoid the marginalisation of many countries, regions and ethnic groups, both within each country and on the international scene in this accelerated process.

Finally, if a situation occurs whereby the rich countries benefit from the new trade norms of the WTO while the other less developed ones are jeopardised, the legitimacy of the WTO mandate will deteriorate, they said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags