Friday, November 20, 2026
Peter Zirnite
- Outgoing CIA director John Deutch has refused to restore the top security clearance of a senior State Department official who helped expose the agency’s link to the deaths of a U.S. resident and guerrilla leader in Guatemala.
And while CIA officials downplayed the decision to censure Richard Nuccio as a routine matter, analysts here declared the ruling a major scandal that could undermine intelligence reform in the United States and democratisation in Latin America.
Nuccio, whose government career was effectively ended by the decision, lost his highest security clearance after he told a member of Congress that a paid CIA informant — Col. Julio Roberto Alpirez — was involved in the 1990 murder of innkeeper Michael DeVine and the 1992 slaying of Efrain Bamaca, a captured guerrilla leader married to a U.S. lawyer.
At the time that he provided the information to Rep. Robert Torricelli, who then made it public, Nuccio was a senior policy adviser at the State Department trying to broker a peace accord between the Guatemalan military and guerrilla forces.
Public release of this information by Torricelli in early 1994 led to pressure from rightwing Republicans late last year to make sure that Nuccio, 49, was disciplined. In April, the CIA moved to strip him of clearances that allow him to see classified information.
Last month, Nuccio told a television journalist that he was “being hounded out of government service by the CIA for telling Congress what it had a right to know.” The interview on CBS’s ’60 Minutes’ was part of his public campaign to keep his security clearance.
Nuccio’s efforts failed, as Deutch upheld the decision to strip him of clearance that gave him access to “specially compartmented information (SCI),” material more classified than “top secret.”
“His clearances have not been revoked. His access to SCI has been suspended,” explained a CIA official who spoke to IPS on the condition of anonymity. It is not unusual,” he added. “People lose clearances and access frequently.”
The official, who pointed out that Nuccio could reapply for SCI access within a year, argued that the only “unusual aspect” of the case was the decision by Deutch to establish a three-member panel to review the agency’s initial decision. This move, he said, was made “in the interest of equity.”
At the White House, President Bill Clinton’s spokesman, Mike McCurry, said the decision to uphold the sanction was “painful.” But he insisted that “everyone — whether it’s a member of Congress (or) a government employee (has) obligations with respect to the protection of material that’s classified.”
“I can only say that we at the White House who know him respect him (and) hope that after the one-year period in which he does not have access to this information he will see his own career advance,” McCurry added.
Peter Kornbluh, senior analyst of the National Security Archives, a private organisation that specialises in the publication of declassified government documents, dismissed the CIA’s assessment of this case as “preposterous.”
“This is not a routine case. This is a scandal of major proportions,” said Kornbluh, who pointed out that Nuccio provided Torricelli with information that he was entitled to as a member of Congress under the U.S. Constitution.
Deutch’s decision, he added, is “simply an effort to facilitate the cover-up of the egregious and illegal behaviour that took place in this case.”
Kornbluh predicted the ruling would have a “chilling effect” on those seeking to reform the U.S. intelligence community. “Congress is a principal target and victim of this decision,” he said.
“They want to punish Torricelli, but they couldn’t,” agreed Hugh Byrne, a fellow at the Washington Office on Latin America.
“It sends entirely the wrong message to both people in the United States and other countries,” Byrne said. “It says that secrecy and cover-up are more important than human rights.”
Byrne said he is particularly concerned about the impact of Deutch’s decision on burgeoning democracies in Latin America. Many military and political leaders in the region, he explained, still “feel comfortable with this approach of punishing people for telling the truth.”
Robert White, former U.S. ambassador to El Salvador, concurred that the ruling by Deutch, who is set to be replaced by Nuccio’s former boss, National Security Adviser Anthony Lake, is indefensible. “Only in a city that has totally lost touch with reality can this be looked upon as a rational a decision,” he said.
It is “simply outrageous” to punish Nuccio for revealing information about “an operation that violated the CIA’s own standards,” according to White, currently director of the Centre for International Policy.
While the CIA may justify is decision as part of its need to “protect sources and methods,” White argued that the agency should not be involved in operations that require secret resources.
“I don’t think there should be any covert action in Latin America,” he said. “I believe you can get all the information you need openly and publicly.”