Friday, November 20, 2026
Teena Amrit Gill
- For hundreds of thousands of foreign workers in Malaysia, the ongoing crackdown by the Kuala Lumpur government on undocumented labour is a bitter spill to swallow.
“Malaysians have in the past openly welcomed foreign workers and that is why they have gone there,” said a Bangladeshi living in Bangkok who did not wish to be named. “This sudden distaste for foreign workers, especially Bangladeshis, after all they have contributed to the economy, smacks of xenophobia.”
Migrants to Malaysia come from around 28 countries around the world, including Nigeria, Sri Lanka and India. Most are from neighbouring Indonesia, followed by Bangladeshis, although exact figures are difficult to come by.
The narrow Straits of Malacca between the Malaysian peninsula and the Indonesian island of Sumatra allows many Indonesians to easily enter Malaysia by boat, while the common land borders with both Indonesia and Thailand, further makes control over illegal crossings all the more difficult.
The Bangladeshis feel particularly aggrieved as they have become the main targets of a government crackdown that began when an amnesty allowing illegal workers to hand themselves in to the authorities, ended last month.
Migrants are officially estimated to account for 10 per cent of the country’s 20 million strong population, and are concentrated in the plantation sector.
Since the beginning of the year, more than 3,000 security personnel, including 1,000 soldiers, have been patrolling the streets conducting door-to-door searches to track down the estimated 1.2 million foreign workers.
Jails have been emptied to make space for them and responsible offices prepared for the ensuing paperwork.
While the illegal workers — those overstaying or without work permits and valid visas — will be deported, their employers have been threatened with stiff punishments, including heavy fines of up to 12,000 dollars, five year jail sentences, and caning!
The impact of such action on an economy struggling to overcome labour shortages, and with plans to overtake the other Asian tigers such as Singapore and Thailand in the next few years, is seen by observers to be quite significant.
Growth rates in Malaysia have been above eight per cent every year for the last eight years — an economic performance that is unlikely to have been achieved in the absence of cheap foreign labour.
In Thailand, similar anti-immigrant feelings also came to the fore last year, following the Bangkok government’s call for the legalisation of illegal foreign workers.
Approximately two million migrants were at this time already working in Thailand, and have been critical to providing the agricultural, fishing and industrial sectors with cheap, and pliable labour without any social security benefits.
The call, which came under pressure from Thai business lobbies which want cheap labour, has thus angered trade unions that warn of possible anti-immigrant violence in the future.
However, in Thailand as in Malaysia, these migrant workers — far from threatening the livelihood of local workers as they are often accused of doing — have filled in a critical gap in industries which locals see as entailing dirty or low paid jobs.
Further, both Thailand and Malaysia with expanding industrial and agricultural sectors and small populations are also labour deficit economies, which have not only attracted but quietly welcomed and tolerated workers from poorer and more densely populated neighbouring South and South-east Asian countries.
Wages in Malaysia are higher — even for illegals — with construction workers, for example, receiving between 20 to 30 dollars a day, depending on their skills.
The advantage for businesses is that not only are illegal workers easy to fire, but more importantly, employers do not have to pay the annual 150 dollars levy per worker demanded by the government if they were officially brought in.
In labour-short Malaysia, the government largely turned a blind eye to the arrangement. But in a country where there are already strong ethnic divisions, the bitter ending of the relationship is not really that surprising.
The Bumiputra or pro ‘sons of the soil’ policy, led by Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, has since the 1970s, favoured Malays in all spheres of society to the detriment of Indian, Chinese and other ethnic groups.
Rather, what has come as somewhat of a surprise, is the selective targetting of Bangladeshi workers.
Reports of complaints by Malaysians that migrants are rowdy and pick fights, overstay, but more than anything else have the ‘audacity’ to marry local women, have Bangladeshi and other South Asians working in the region, up in arms.
The fact that the ethnic Indian political party in Malaysia, the Malaysian Indian Congress, has been party to this propaganda by distributing pamphlets warning Malaysian Indian girls about the dangers of marrying foreign workers, especially if they happen to be Bangladeshi, has not helped matters.
“All this talk about cultural conflict between Bangladeshi workers and Malaysians,” said an editorial in ‘The Nation’, a Bangkok daily, “is sheer nonsense, fuelled by racial prejudice.”
Says an official from the Bangladeshi embassy: “If they mean what they say (about deporting illegal foreign workers), they cannot only target Bangladeshis. This crackdown must include all workers, whether from India, Thailand, Pakistan or anywhere else.”
Another reason seen for targetting Bangladeshis is also the fact that they are primarily unskilled workers, unlike those from other countries.
The arrest this year of more than 60 Bangladeshis at Bangkok’s Don Muang airport suspected of seeking to cross the Thai-Malay border to work in Malaysia, and of 1,000 illegal migrants, including Bangladeshis, in Songkla in southern Thailand, is seen to have further instigated the anti-Bangladeshi backlash.
“We will do our best to protect our people and help them return to Bangladesh if they are deported. We will also make it clear that if anyone wants to build their economy on the sweat of Bangladeshis they muct first give them protection and grant them basic economic and human rights.”