Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE: Palestinian Authority’s Grip On ‘Free’ Trade Tightens

Deborah Horan

GAZA CITY, Jan 31 1997 (IPS) - The guests at the beachfront penthouse of one of Gaza’s leading businessmen were happy to discuss how Israeli ‘security’ measures have slowed local trade to a crawl. Yet there was no talk of the Palestinian authorities in the problem.

The issue of the influence that the Palestinian government and myriad security forces may — or may not — have over the business affairs of their host was simply not open for debate.

No wonder: across the table sat four members of the secretive Palestinian Preventive Security force, automatic weapons slung over their shoulders.

Even after the meal, as sweet coffee was passed around and the armed security men briefly departed, the host, a trader in tiles, would not be drawn. He flatly denied that top members of the security forces have forced him to accept them as business partners.

But word on the street, and from two reliable sources at an international aid agency, and a former Palestinian international negotiator, say otherwise. Some sources have withdrawn their allegations after a brief stint in a Gaza prison. Others will carefully say nothing at all about the alleged slow infiltration of the Palestinian government into lucrative sectors of the economy.

As the Israelis withdrew and the new Palestinian Authority confronted the massive problems facing the deprived and devastated former occupied zone, the Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO) took the lead in the battle to improve the plight of Gaza.

Chief instrument of this fight is a government-owned company called Palestinian Commercial Services, which imports cement and petrol to Palestinian-ruled areas in the West Bank and Gaza.

Set up shortly after the Palestinian Authority came to Gaza, it signed deals with the Israeli cement giant, Neshur, a Jordanian cement company and the Israeli oil company Dor, opening the way to meeting the huge demand for these commodities as Palestinians began to rebuild Gaza after decades of Israeli occupation.

Yet the activities of the company have since spread much further afield and for those who seek fair and free trade in Gaza and the West Bank, details of the company’s business have been frustratingly hard to pin down.

Palestinian government ministers, members of parliament, and businessmen at trade promotion organisations all cite a series of grumbles from Palestinians concerned that Commercial Services and other government owned may be using its privileged status to corner a variety of import-export trades: among them, tiles, flour, paint, gravel, sugar, cigarettes, frozen meat, steel, farm equipment, and even live sheep.

One name repeatedly pops up: Mohammed Rashid. An Iraqi Kurd, Rashid ran the PLO magazine al-Bilad out of Beirut in the 1980s and was close to Abu Jihad, Palestinian president Yasser Arafat’s then- right- hand man who was slain in Tunis by Israel’s Mossad secret service in 1988.

His name is affiliated to several lucrative ventures, including the Palestine Telecommunications Co., a multi-million dollar company contracted to bring telephone service to Palestinian areas, and several investment banks that have large real estate holdings and construction interests.

Rashid defends the government’s role in the economy as a temporary measure necessary as long as repeated Israeli “security” closures lock Palestinian goods and people in the West Bank and Gaza. The Palestinian areas have been under some degree of ‘security closure’ since March 1993. Palestinians estimate they lose between three and six million dollars daily, depending on the severity of the closures applied by the Israeli forces.

“It’s like a war economy with these closures, an embargo,” Rashid told IPS. “This is a very unique situation. With the government involved, we can make sure that basic commodities are always available.”

Rashid cites a company project to build grain storages in Jericho as an example of the government having the best interests of Palestinians in mind. He says that after the deal with Dor, the government collected ten times more in gasoline revenues than before because it was able to streamline receipts.

And he maintains that the agreement with Neshur not only brings in a constant supply of cement, even during the closures, it also keeps the price low and constant because it is fixed.

His explanations, however, do not impress Palestinian businessmen or Legislative Council members, who have taken the offensive in their effort to rid the economy of government influence. The Council scored a limited success four months ago when it forced the government to allow in some non-government imports of gravel.

Israeli business reporters say Rashid has also set up deals with Israeli businessman Yossi Ginosar, a former Mossad operative who nevertheless reportedly has strong contacts with the Arab world.

These deals, again according to the Israeli media, have set up Israeli companies as the suppliers and the Palestinian government as the sole buyer — or at least one of short and select list of buyers — in several deals along the lines of the original oil and concrete deal struck by Palestinian Commercial Services.

As with the tile importer’s story, most business dealings like these are wrapped in rumour and innuendo. Almost no one is willing to go on record and fewer still are willing to publicly challenge the government’s policy and the alleged lack of transparency in business dealings by the Palestinian government.

World donors and private investors raise eyebrows but stay silent on the record to IPS. Only the Palestinian Legislative Council, the state’s putative parliament has spoken out on the issue as to where – exactly – the profits from this trade go. Another source at the Palestinian Ministry of Finance insists that the profits are accounted for in the budget, and a member of the Legislative Council says the accounts are “blacked out” so that the parliamentary body has no ability to oversee them.

“We don’t have any idea where this money goes,” said Hikmat Zeid, a West Bank Council member who as head of the Council’s economic committee has prepared a report on government-owned companies. “It is not correct to say that it is part of the regular budget.”

That means the profits are also outside the sight of world donors, who pledged 2.1 billion dollars to the Palestinian Authority in 1993 and have been funding both aid projects and the recurring costs of the Palestinian government ever since, basing their donations to the recurring costs on need.

While the International Monetary Fund has reportedly been trying to keep tabs on so-called ‘black’ accounts, donor countries seem reluctant to bring up an issue that may undercut peace efforts.

Palestinian Minister of Economy and Trade Maher al-Masri and two Palestinian economists estimate that profits pouring into ‘black’ accounts reach as high as 1.5 million dollars daily, mostly from cement and petrol importing and distribution.

Legislative Council members continue their effort to free trade and unshackle the economy from government influence. The Council scored a limited success four months ago when it forced the government to allow some non-government companies to import gravel.

But Palestinians say rumours of government interference has scared off potential investors, both local and international. “Two years ago, hundreds of investors were here to check out the investment climate,” said a Palestinian who words for an organisation promoting free trade. Today, he says, that number has dwindled to a trickle, mostly because of the closures, but in part, he says, due to the government’s practices.

Unattributed innuendo it all may be, but a very real perception on the street remains. Many simply believe the ordinary trader is being elbowed out of the market by powerful state forces and that those who dispute the emerging status quo will get short shrift from the Palestinian powers-that-be. Meanwhile huge villas under construction in Gaza’s relatively wealthy Rimal neighbourhood still abut crowded slums festering with garbage on roads that are nothing more than tracks in the sand.

Near one of those mansions, a Palestinian, recently arrested for several hours for talking to the media voiced the fears of many: “I’ve learned to keep my mouth shut,” he told IPS. “I don’t want to know what is happening anymore.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags