Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

ASIA-PACIFIC/TRADE: Canada Plans For Various APEC ‘Summits’

Paul Baylis

VANCOUVER, Mar 19 1997 (IPS) - As Canada gears up to host the annual Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Vancouver, labour, environmental, human rights, and other groups critical of the APEC process are preparing their own events to try to influence the official process.

At least two parallel conferences are in the works to be held simultaneously with the official leaders’ meeting Nov. 23-24.

Critics of APEC, which has established the goal of free trade among its 18 members by the year 2020 (2010 for the “industrialised” countries), charge that decisions are made behind closed doors without any public consultation and are therefore not democratic. Although APEC has a “business advisory council,” neither labour nor non-governmental organisations (NGOs) have been invited to the table, they say.

“There has been a lot talk about transparency, but in fact there is very little access to information or the policy process,” says John Price, a research associate at the Institute of Asian Research at the University of British Columbia, who has been active in organising a parallel ‘People’s Summit’.

The organisers of the People’s Summit say they want to take full advantage of the fact that this year’s official summit will be held in a relatively free and democratic country which has placed a strong emphasis on human rights in its foreign policy.

In a speech to the United Nations in February, Canada’s Minister of Foreign Affairs Lloyd Axworthy said, “A commitment to human rights is fundamental to Canadian values and identity…In our international relations, human rights could be considered a threshold issue.”

The Canadian government has, however, made it clear it has no intention of trying to get human rights or labour standards on the agenda for the official APEC meeting.

“Some issues like human rights and social development might impede the progress on economic and trade issues,” says Raymond Chan, Canada’s secretary of state for Asia-Pacific affairs.

John Klassen, a senior official in Canada’s Department of Foreign Affairs, adds that a discussion of human rights in the APEC region “is certainly not going to happen.”

NGOs and representatives of labour have told the Canadian government that this position is unacceptable and are proceeding with the People’s Summit to discuss these issues. Organisers of this event say they plan to build on past APEC parallel summits in the Philippines, Japan, Indonesia, and the United States.

“APEC, as it currently exists will not help development and will only reinforce the problems that exist and make them worse,” says Price of UBC. “This is an opportunity for Canadian NGOs and community organisations abroad to say that Asia-Pacific cooperation cannot be reduced merely to a commercial transaction.”

According to a pamphlet released by the People’s Summit, APEC “separates economic issues from their national and social context…Without a strong commitment to the effective enforcement of international standards, APEC may bring working and living standards to their lowest common denominator.”

Some of the issues on the agenda of the People’s Summit so far are worker’s rights, sustainable development, women’s rights, and the environment.

At previous APEC summits, there has been no shortage of controversy surrounding human rights. Last year in Manila, several thousand slum dwellers were forced to leave their homes so the city could be “cleaned up” for the visiting delegations. In Indonesia in 1994, a number of activists were arrested in preparation for the APEC leaders’. And in 1998, the summit will be held in Malaysia, where Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad has been an outspoken opponent of linking trade with human rights.

Meanwhile, in Vancouver, a split seems to be emerging among social groups on how to respond to APEC. In addition to the People’s Summit, another group called ‘No to APEC’ is planning its own “counter conference” which will take an even tougher, confrontational stand on APEC. Literature released by ‘No to APEC’ cites such perceived effects of free trade in the region as massive job loss, environmental degradation, dispossession of indigenous peoples and increased concentration of wealth.

“We don’t see any possibility of engagement with APEC,” says Suzanne Baustad, a member of the ‘No to APEC’ coalition. “Rather than trying to get a seat at the table, it’s time to start building broad-based resistance at the grassroots. We saw how ridiculous the process of negotiating sidebar agreements was with NAFTA.” Critics say labour and environmental accords attached to the North American Free Trade Agreement have been ineffective.

Divisions among social groups on how to respond to APEC are not unique to Vancouver. At last year’s summit in the Philippines, there were no less than four parallel conferences, with names ranging from ‘Slam APEC’, to the ‘People’s Conference Against Imperialist Globalisation’.

This year’s APEC summit will be the culmination of a year-long programme by the Canadian government known as ‘Canada’s Year of the Asia Pacific’, meant to raise Canada’s awareness of, and profile in the Asia-Pacific region. The Canadian government estimates that 10,000 delegates, journalists, and business people will descend on Vancouver for APEC.

The pursuit of greater economic ties in the region has already generated considerable controversy among Canadians. During several high-profile trade missions to the region led by Prime Minister Jean Chretien, critics have accused the government of ignoring human rights and labour standards while chasing after lucrative trade deals in such places as Pakistan, China, and Indonesia.

The 18 APEC territories account for more than half the world’s economic output and about 40 percent of its population. They include: Australia, Brunei, Canada, Chile, China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, the Philippines, Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, Thailand and the United States. Eleven other countries have applied for membership, including Russia, Vietnam, and Peru.

Unlike other international trade bodies, APEC functions solely on the basis of consensus and mutual agreement.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags