Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

COLOMBIA-INDIGENOUS: Battle Continues Against Oil Exploration

Yadira Ferrer

BOGOTA, Mar 7 1997 (IPS) - An indigenous community in northeast Columbia have vowed to fight to the death to keep the California-based oil giant Occidental Petroleum from drilling on their land.

The U’wa indigenous group sees the drilling operations as the “bleeding of our sacred Mother Earth” and has threatened mass suicide if Occidental goes ahead with its plans.

A Council of State decision has authorised Occidental to continue its exploration work in the ‘Samore block’, an area in the foothills of the Andes near the Venezuelan border that is home to the 5,000 members of the U’wa community.

The Council of State, which rules on the legality of the government’s administrative actions, denied a demand presented by the “People’s Defender” that the exploration license granted the transnational by the Ministry of the Environment be annulled.

Lawyers argued that it violated the constitution as well as laws on the environment, which stipulate that local communities must participate in decision-making processes on the exploitation of natural resources.

The U’wa say they were not consulted by the Ministry of the Environment prior to the issuing of the license. That allegation was supported by the constitutional court, which ruled that the meetings held could not be considered consultations because the indigenous group’s traditional authorities were not present.

But the Council of State accepted the assertions of the Ministry of the Environment which reported that the indigenous group was consulted more than 30 times before the license was granted.

Indigenous Senator Lorenzo Muelas said the constitutional court and Council of State decisions were not contradictory because the court decision was only transitory. But he argued that there was “ambiguity in the jurists’ interpretation of the concept of ‘consultation’.”

“Consultation is a dialogue with the communities, a process of concertation” based on which decisions are made, said Muelas. “And that Occidental did not do,” he underlined.

For the U’was, decision-making involves the participation of all the adults of the community, whose opinions are reported to the ‘Werhayas’, the group’s spiritual leaders, who then communicate with the gods and indicate the correct path to take.

Muelas, who participated in the legislative process that led to the promulgation of the constitution in 1991, said the recognition of the communities’ right to participate in such decisions was the product of the most heated debates on the new constitution.

A representative of Colombia’s minorities, Muelas said it “made no sense” to call the communities to a consultation without taking their opinions into account.

After the Council of State decision was announced, Occidental said it would not begin to search for oil on the indigenous group’s land until an accord was reached with both the community and the government. But according to the company, the ruling demonstrated that from a legal point of view all the requirements with respect to consultations with the indigenous people had been fulfilled.

While Minister of Mines Rodrigo Villamizar said “the dialogue with the indigenous people should be renewed anyway,” he expressed his confidence that exploration of the first well would begin this year, because six of the 28 years of the contract signed with Occidental had already passed.

The company has so far invested 12 million dollars in its operations in the area.

Roberto Afanador, president of the U’wa Council, said the dialogue proposed by the government and Occidental was an attempt to find a way to drill for oil on the group’s lands “without the collapse of our culture, our world – which we consider impossible.”

The indigenous group will not abandon its struggle, said Afanador. If necessary, it will resort to the international courts with support from the People’s Defender in order to defend its right “to live according to our customs and culture.”

Occidental has drawn fire from U.S. and British environmental groups, which have denounced activities “that run counter to the stated policies of the company to ‘protect the environment, health and safety…of the communities in which it operates,” not only in Colombia but also Peru and Ecuador, in the words of a representative of the San Francisco-based Rainforest Action Network.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags