Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

JAMAICA: Whither the Wheels of Justice

Sam Pragg

KINGSTON, Mar 25 1997 (IPS) - Controversial rulings by judges here in recent times have sparked intense debate about the direction in which the wheels of justice are turning in this northern Caribbean island.

First there was the matter of a mere 156-dollar fine for a man convicted of carnal abuse of a disabled three-year old girl.

Then there was the well-publicised conflict between the Chief Justice and a lawyer over the judge’s scrutiny of notes of conversation between the lawyer and his client. The notes were even shown to the prosecutors. This case threw confusion on the whole issue of lawyer-client privileged relationship.

Then following on the heels of these incidents came the news that a judge had ordered an alleged rape victim to spend a night in jail for speaking too softly while giving her testimony in court.

These incidents have led to widespread comments that Jamaican judges are becoming drunk in their own power.

While the second incident led to the exchange of remarks between the Jamaica Bar Association (JBA) and the Chief Justice, Lensley Wolfe, the third led to a flurry of condemnation of the judicial system and the judge in question by members of the public.

The talk shows were inundated with calls, with each irate person giving his or her opinion as to what punishment should be meted out to the judge who ordered the complainant to be taken to jail until she would speak louder.

“The judge should be shot,” said one man. “That is the problem with our legal system, it doesn’t serve any purpose, as the wrong- doers get off the hook, as the victims are punished.”

“These high-and-mighty judges have no idea what it is like to be raped, and they obviously live in a world of their own,” said Jasmine Robinson, as she demonstrated outside the court room following the ruling. “They are not fit to sit in judgment in our courts.”

Lawyer, Portia Nicholson agreed that it was impossible to justify the action of the judge, Basil Reid, in that particular case.

“It tends to confirm the public suspicion that our judges have no sympathy to the victims of sexual offences and no regard for the human rights of ordinary Jamaicans. When the judge’s jailing of this rape victim is contrasted to the obvious reticence of some of his brother judges to impose custodial sentences on convicted rapists, the egregiousness of the court’s action is even more clearly exposed,” says Nicholson.

Nicholson is also the legal affairs spokesperson for the Association of Women’s Organisations of Jamaica (AWOJA), a non- governmental grouping.

Meanwhile, all these events have left the ordinary person in a state of confusion. Street vendor, Rose Williams is one such person.

“I’m scared by all that has happened. If something should happen to me, I don’t know where I would turn for assistance,” she says.

Nicholson has warned that if the courts cannot, or will not protect Jamaican women and young girls from violation of their persons, then these victims will begin to look to vigilante-type justice to punish the guilty.

“There are other issues of a fundamental nature,” says Headley Cunningham a Council member of the JBA. “There is a profound concern that there are fundamental deficiencies in the justice system.”

Cunningham also believes that a code of conduct should be established for members of the judiciary.

Nicholson agrees. “The efficacy of justice depends after all not so much on lawyers and judges but on the faith of ordinary people in its integrity and its ability to adequately protect the innocent and punish the guilty,” she says.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags