Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

BARBADOS-POPULATION: MP Wants Prostitution Decriminalised

Trevor Allen

BRIDGETOWN, Apr 2 1997 (IPS) - It is a subject which seems to have stirred up all kinds of emotions in different people in this eastern Caribbean island in the past, and now it is pitting politicians against at least one women’s group.

It all started when opposition Parliamentarian, Branford Taitt made a call in the lower Chamber, the House of Assembly for prostitution to be decriminalised and voiced his disgust with those who are trying to discriminate against sex workers.

Taitt, a prominent member of the Anglican Church, took issue with the wording of the new legislation which referred to “common prostitutes” and “nightwalkers”. He says these are “residual philosophies” of the 19th century Vagrancy Act which the Minor Offences Bill seeks to replace.

“In the real world, they are referred to as sex workers,” he says, arguing very strongly that every woman should have the right to choose the profession from which she could make a living. The activities of sex workers are no different from any other business venture, he argues.

The proposed legislation also provides for the arrest of “common prostitutes” but not the people who solicit their services. This, Taitt sees as discrimination.

But Taitt has not found support for his position from the National Organisation of Women (NOW). The group has lashed out at him proclaiming that by whatever name it is called, the naked truth is that it is still prostitution.

“The aim of all our programmes is to promote high moral living and Christian ethics, to help persons lift themselves out of degrading circumstances and to promote enriching self-employment and to stem the tide of violence and other forms of abuse to women,” says NOW President Jackie Banfield.

But Taitt, a former Minister of Health, says his concern for women is behind his call for the activity to be decriminalised.

“There is hardly any individual who would choose prostitution as a preferred line of work. People do things out of need,” he explains.

Taitt says in countries where prostitution has been decriminalised sex workers are required to get regular health checks which minimise the risk of spreading sexually-transmitted diseases.

In other countries, he says, sex workers are registered and must undergo training for other work as it becomes available.

But not all women are against Taitt’s position. In the upper chamber of Parliament, the Senate, two female independent members have criticised the Bill.

Senator Viola Davis says she regards prostitution as legitimate work and has vowed never to vote for legislation which seeks to penalise those in the profession.

She says laws which seek to punish sex workers and not the persons serviced by them are sexist.

“I am not giving any support to any hypocrisy,” she says.

“If government can’t give decent hard-working people decent wages, who is to say they should not look elsewhere? Prostitution is a valuable enterprise. It is sex for profit. The day must come for government to decide that they are going to take women’s work seriously.”

Senator Peggy Rickenson, a former President of the Barbados Registered Nurses Association, says since prostitution is an economic activity it is necessary for the practitioners to be in good health in order to ply their trade.

She is calling for government to look into the possibility of operating clinics for both male and female prostitutes and she wants prostitution, as a crime, to be removed from the laws.

“By having that term ‘prostitute’ on our statute books it narrows it down to the women you see on the street corners at night but not to the men who either walk around and solicit their services or drive around in their very, very large cars and then return to the heights and terraces,” she said.

Thirty one-year old Katie says she knows about those persons. She says her clients have included lawyers, doctors and politicians.

Katie is a high school graduate and have been working the streets for the past 10 years. She says despite having passed nine subjects in the General Council Examination (GCE) at Ordinary Level she was unable to find a job and for her prostitution became a means of economic survival.

“I decided now that is my only alternative in getting support for my three children and it is hard having two children to send to school and bills to pay, school fees to pay, so this is the only alternative.”

Vicar General of the Roman Catholic Church, Father Clement Paul is also opposed to the legislation in its present form. He says prostitution is a societal problem and must be resolved.

“We need to address these issues by ensuring they have jobs, by ensuring that women appreciate themselves. I think women have become sexual objects and we have to remove that from the understanding of our society and though they have been abused they can still live normal and healthy lives,” he says.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags