Friday, November 20, 2026
Mario Osava
- Undercover video recordings by amateur filmmakers have recently burst on the scene as one of the key allies of human rights in Braziland the number one enemy of police violence.
Rio de Janeiro’s secretary of Public Security, Nilton Cerqueira, under fire from human rights organisations for bonuses given to soldiers who deal harshly with suspects, accused organised crime, especially drug traffickers, of fuelling an “industry of film recordings” to demoralise the police.
His allegation was based on a police investigation that discovered an unusual upsurge in sales – more than 100 video cameras – over the past few weeks in Bangu, a poor neighbourhood on the westside of Rio de Janeiro.
It was near that area that military police were filmed torturing a group of young men, images that were broadcast earlier this month by the country’s leading TV network, Globo.
The scenes, captured by an amateur filmmaker, were similar to others aired a week earlier by Globo, which sparked a national and international outcry against police brutality and impunity in Brazil. The earlier recording showed young men being gratuitously humiliated, beaten and shot at – one was killed – by police in Diadema, a working class neighbourhood on the outskirts of Sao Paulo.
The man who taped the first recording, who went by the pseudonym Francisco to avoid reprisals, received 10,000 reals (9,400 dollars) from Globo for the tape that cost him three sleepless nights and the fear of being discovered.
His work led to the jailing of 10 Sao Paulo military police, sped up the final approval of a law that specifies torture as a crime, and gave a boost to other legislation designed to curb the impunity enjoyed by police.
Prospects of easy money have led to a rise in sales, analysts say. Eletros, the electronic industry association, reported a nearly 500 percent boom in retail purchases of video recorders in March, in comparison with the same month in 1996.
In Sao Paulo, sales climbed from just over 8,100 units in January-February 1996 to nearly 21,000 in the same period this year – a close to 160 percent rise. Rio de Janeiro’s largest home appliances chain, Ponto Frio, hopes to sell 42,000 video cameras this year, three times the total sold in 1996, projections based on the boom in sales seen in the past few months.
The lower income sector of the population, previously unable to afford video cameras, has now begun to purchase them thanks to increased buying power, lower prices and credit facilities, results of the stabilisation of the local currency that began in 1994, business sources report.
A recording with a few spectacular seconds or minutes can bring more than 1,000 dollars, according to editors such as Globo’s Laerte Rimoli, or Marco Antonio Siqueira with the Brazilian Television System (SBT), the country’s second leading network.
Sensationalist programmes on crime, like SBT’s “Here and Now”, are the biggest clients.
Some individuals have taken to accompanying firefighters or police. Trailing police with hidden cameras is another option, which brings its own risks. One amateur filmmaker narrowly escaped with his life after being shot at by police who discovered his hideout, images aired on TV this week graphically showed.
Another semi-professional filmmaker, Romildo Menezes, discovered a mine of hard-hitting images on Brazil’s most heavily transited highway, the Via Dutra, which connects Sao Paulo and Rio de Janeiro. Six months ago he began to follow the “Asphalt Angels”, an organisation that provides assistance to accident victims, an activity that has given a welcome boost to his income as an employee in a clothing store.