Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

CARIBBEAN-US: Immigrant Bashing Raises Concern

Patrick Smikle

BASSETERRE, ST. KITTS, Apr 29 1997 (IPS) - Defeated Republican Vice- Presidential candidate, Jack Kemp, recently advised his party of the need to soften its image. If the GOP was to be seen as a “party of inclusion” he warned, it would have to, among other things, abandon its penchant for immigrant bashing.

Recent statements by GOP officials such as Senate Majority Leader, Trent Lott and beleaguered Speaker of the House of Representatives, Newt Gingrich, indicate that they share Kemp’s view about softening the party’s image.

Actions and utterances by Ralph Reed, the usually strident Executive Director of the ultra-conservative Christian Coalition, would indicate that some pro-Republican groups also seem to have gotten the message.

Others apparently have not, among them the anti-immigrant organisations which routinely support the Republican Party. And the possibility that they could represent a majority sentiment in the country, is engendering concern and fear.

Groups such as FAIR (Federation for American Immigration Reform), American Immigration Control, and US English, which operate across the country, as well as state-based organisations such as Arizonians for Official English and Citizens of Dade United in Florida are riding, some say fomenting, a wave of anti- immigration feeling.

These groups were strengthened last year by the immigration and welfare reform bills designed by the Republican controlled 104th Congress and signed into law (reluctantly, Democratic commentators say) by President Bill Clinton.

While the focus of the immigration reform law is supposed to be prevention of illegal immigration to the U.S., its effects are being felt throughout the community of legal immigrants — naturalised US citizens and ‘green card’ holders.

Many of the provisions of the new law will forcibly separate families, says Cheryl Little, Executive Director of the Immigrant Advocacy Centre in Florida.

Others agree. “I have a friend who said that she is not taking any chances. She claims that she has much more to lose than gain in staying here (Jamaica). So she resigned her job and left by April 1, leaving her family behind,” says one woman who requested anonymity.

Little says a typical family represented by the Centre includes people who have become naturalised citizens, people who are legal immigrants (‘green card’ holders) and “people who are on the road to legalising their status.”

Many of these people have lived in the US for years and consider the country home. They have children who have recently graduated from high school and are looking forward to entering college.

Little makes particular mention of a Florida community of some 30,000 Nicaraguans whom the new law makes ineligible for legal status. They had been extended special protection by the Justice Department and had been given work permits. Many had started businesses and had children born in the United States.

The Centre is also concerned about a group of Colombians whose cases for asylum, a Federal judge has ruled, had been incorrectly handled by the INS. Unless the necessary corrections can be made before the Sep. 27 deadline set by the new law, they face deportation.

Groups such as Citizens of Dade United (CDU) say they should be deported. Says CDU Vice-President, Enos Schera: “These people must stay back home in their own countries. Solve the problems there because coming here does not solve the problems there. It creates two problems.

“It creates a problem over here. Plus it makes it absolutely sure that you’re never going to have a democratic stable government in the countries that they’re fleeing.”

The CDU is calling for a 10-year moratorium on all forms of immigration into the U.S., including the granting of political asylum to refugees. “The taxpayers are tired of paying for this rampant immigration,” says Schera. Migration into Florida has overburdened the social services he says, and has “reduced the quality of life in Dade County to a detrimental point.”

The CDU emerged out of a 1980 campaign to prevent the Dade County administration spending one million dollars a year to translate government documents to Spanish. The campaign was successful but that decision was reversed in 1993 when six Hispanics were elected to the county government.

It was then that the CDU broadened its work beyond the language conflict in Miami into a more general anti-immigrant campaign dealing with the volume of legal and illegal immigration and the non-assimilation of immigrants coming into Dade County, which Schera says is “smothering our English culture here.”

It has links with national organisations such as FAIR which continues to campaign for even stricter immigration controls. FAIR’s Deputy Director, K.C.McAlpin, describes the new law as “a weak step in the right direction.”

FAIR rejects the INS calculation of five million’undocumented aliens’ in the US as being much too conservative. The organisation says the problem of illegal immigration will not be solved until the law is framed in a way to send a clear message to the would-be illegal immigrant that getting through a port of entry will be only the first in an ongoing series of difficulties.

It is also calling for a moratorium on legal immigration. This call is based on what Schera says is “chain migration” resulting from a I986 INS programme in which some three million illegal immigrants “had their status adjusted.” These new immigrants have since filed for their relatives to enter the United States.

FAIR has also joined Republican members of Congress in calling for hearings into ‘Citizenship USA’ a programme operated by the INS between mid-1995 and September 1996.

The INS says this was a programme to clear a backlog of citizenship applications. The anti-immigrant groups allege it was an effort directed by Vice-President Al Gore’s office to secure a windfall of votes for the Clinton administration. The White House has denied the allegation.

Surveys have consistently shown that with the exception of Florida and New Jersey-based Cubans, immigrants vote overwhelmingly — up to 86 percent — for candidates of the Democratic Party.

“America is unique in that it has this immigration and immigrant tradition,” says Marcus Stern, an Immigration Reporter, with the Copely News Service.

“It’s something most Americans really pride themselves on, in that we have a fairly open and generous immigration system here.” But he says that for years the system has been dysfunctional for both legal and illegal immigrants. It is mainly these problems which have fed the anti-immigrant feeling. “This has been a very emotional issue. It probably always will be,” Stern says.

Jimmy Morales, a Hispanic member of the Dade County government, agrees that the immigration issue has historically been a divisive and emotional one. “It seems that throughout American history people have been nervous about immigrants. For some reason in this country through its history we’ve feared immigration. We’ve feared diversity.” Morales says he hopes this is just another wave and that it will pass.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags