Saturday, November 21, 2026
Payal Padmanabhan
- For the first time ever in India, 14,000 workers in state-owned textile mills in Gujarat have been shown the door with the aid of a 70 million dollar compensation package.
The move, which had the backing of the powerful Ahmedabad- based textile union, Majoor Mahajan, and tacit approval of all the political parties in the state is being perceived as a trend setter and is to be emulated in other sick and non-viable units.
The mass-retirement in 14 textile mills in Ahmedabad was paid out of a 250-million dollar reforms package for the public sector from the Asian Development Bank (AsDB) to Gujarat.
Under the terms of the loan, the Gujarat government is to create an ideal infrastructure “climate” in the state for catalysing private sector investment in ports, roads and power. The privatisation programme includes the complete withdrawal of the state government from some sectors and also the strategic sale of majority stakes to private promoters.
Taking the cue as it were, the central government too is now toying with a similar package with respect to the ailing units of the National Textile Corporation (NTC).
The proposal under consideration envisages the termination of employment of over 100,000 workers and closure of 107 of the 120 mills under the NTC umbrella. The compensation envisaged amounts to a staggering 3 billion dollars.
Unlike Gujarat where there was no opposition, New Delhi is a house divided with the left parties which form part of the ruling coalition stalling any move seeking closure of the sick units under the purview of NTC. Already, three proposals to revamp NTC have been shelved in the face of political opposition and the perception is that the latest package too may meet the same fate.
Notwithstanding this, the emerging trend is that unions, facing dwindling membership, prefer to accept the seemingly inevitable and are pressuring their members to opt for voluntary retirement schemes. A decade ago, the attitude was more aggressive with workers preferring instead to strike work to meet their demand for industrial revival.
“We are aware that our membership is dwindling. Golden handshakes is a healthy way out given that in most cases the mill owners just shut down the mill and don’t pay the workers. Majoor Mahajan will have to diversify into other areas like powerlooms,” says the union president N. M. Barot.
The union president points out that 25 privately owned mills have gone into liquidation and the matter has been dragging in the Gujarat High Court for the last 10 years. “During this period, the workers received no wages,” Barot added.
Majoor Mahajan’s membership has dwindled sharply in the period after liberalisation, initiated in 1991. Unable to cope with the competition and influx of technology, several mills went into the red. Its membership, over 100,000 a decade ago, is now down to around 20,000 and would stand further reduced after the closure of GSTC.
“We had the political backing. And with Majoor Mahajan too supporting the package the deal was clinched. The government coughed up the entire sum of Rs 250 crore in one go and the process was wound up in 20 days,” says GSTC chief Vijay Ranchan.
Each worker has on an average stood to receive between 5,700 and 7,000 dollars, say government officials. The package, was based on what was offered by the profit-making, private Arvind Mills earlier, and entails the standard payment of 15 days salary for every year of service as gratuity. In addition, a worker is paid 35 days for every year of service and 25 days for every year left in service. Further, the latter is payable for a minimum of 10 years, regardless of the number of years left.
According to Majoor Mahajan representatives, the deal found favour with the workers for two reasons. For one, the workers had little or no option with the salary payments every month accruing after acrimonious exchanges with the government, which was finding it hard to sustain the annual loss of Rs 65 crore.
Secondly, unlike the previous VRS packages offered in the case of say NTC units, this was not biased against the younger work force. Especially, since it allowed for compensation for every year of service left.
However not everyone has taken kindly to the Gujarat experiment. “VRS is a bad policy,” says Arun Daur, a trade unionist. “It is particularly harsh on female workers. For one they have no control over the financial compensation unlike in the case of monthly wages. Secondly, they have to be accepted once again in the social fold of the family.”
Daur goes on to argue that most of the employees who opt for VRS are unable to find alternative employment and are eventually forced to join the unorganised sector. “Vast numbers are unable to accept this change and eventually take to anti-social activities. The foot soldiers of the mafia in Bombay are former textile workers. The same trend is emerging in Kanpur where large number of textile employees are being laid off,” he adds.
However, in the final analysis it is apparent that the GSTC experiment has kicked off a new trend in the textile sector. The output from the mill sector will decline further and that from the unorganised sector — powerloom and handloom — will pick up proportionately. This also implies that industrial relations as traditionally defined in the radical textile sector will stand to be completely altered.