Development & Aid, Headlines, North America

FOOD: Consumer Groups Want Labels for Genetically-Engineered Food

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, May 6 1997 (IPS) - Consumer groups have welcomed the decision by the international agency responsible for food standards to redraft plans for labelling genetically-engineered food.

The secretariat of the Rome-based Codex Alimentarius proposed at a recent meeting here that special-labelling be required for genetically-altered food – if scientists felt the new product was not “substantially equivalent to the corresponding existing food or food ingredient.”

The proposal would have placed restrictions on the marketing of new food found to be dangerous or to contain proteins that cause allergic reactions.

But critics say it is not enough to restrict the labelling to food thought to be “substantially” altered. They argue that the lack of an overall labelling requirement would limit the public’s ability to make informed decisions on the food they buy.

“Consumers have a fundamental right to know what’s happened to the food they’ll be consuming – although the Codex thinks that only applies in the case where they see a substantial change,” says Diane McCrea of Consumers’ International, a coalition of 200 national consumer groups with observer status at Codex.

“We fundamentally disagree with that, because consumers have not been involved in setting the definition of ‘substantial equivalence’. If you ask them if the new food is the same as the old, they will likely say it’s not,” McCrea told IPS.

With several national delegations supporting that position, the committee was told to incorporate the criticisms into new proposals to be debated next year among the members of Codex, an inter- governmental commission established by the World Health Organisation (WHO) and the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations.

The order to rewrite the proposals is a setback for the biotechnology industry which had wanted new labelling laws to consider only the trade ramifications and current scientific opinions surrounding genetically altered products.

Although the European Commission and individual countries, including Norway, argue that consumers need labelling of genetically modified products so they can make choices based on environmental, ethical, and personal health reasons, the Biotechnology Industry Organisation says the Codex standards should be restricted to measures intended to “ensure food safety, harmonise and eliminate potential trade barriers.”

“Labels based on socio-economic or political grounds lack a scientific basis and should not be endorsed by Codex,” the organisation says in a brief.

For many observers, the ethical and environmental issues surrounding biotechnology are paramount. On the ethical question, people who adhere to vegetarian, kosher, or halal diets might violate their own principles by buying unlabelled vegetables or fruits that had been altered with genes from fish or animals.

Michael Sligh, director of sustainable agriculture programmes for the Rural Advancement Foundation International (RAFI), a Canada- based body that works with partner organisations around the world, notes that the new “biotech revolution” may bring many of the same environmental and economic problems associated with the Green Revolution promoted in the 1960s by petro-chemical companies with an interest in expanding the use of fertilisers.

“Recently, we’ve seen BGH being promoted as able to feed the hungry of the south,” he says, referring to the controversial bovine growth hormone that is injected into dairy cows. “But the reality is that this is a very expensive technology that requires very large, sophisticated, computerised rationing systems which are not accessible to farmers in the south.”

In addition to concentrating power over farming in the hands of a few large corporations with patents on genetically altered lifeforms and farming inputs, Sligh says the environmental impact of some biotech products may be the opposite of what is intended.

He cites the example of bacillus theringiensis (BT), a naturally occurring, low-toxicity bacterium which has been genetically introduced into strains of cotton, corn, and potatoes. While the measure promises to kill crop pests without harming people, Sligh says scientists acknowledge that it is only a matter of time before the pests develop a resistance to BT.

“With BT engineered right into the plant, resistances build up very fast, because the insects are always tasting it,” Sligh says. “It’s not like when you spray it, because that only leaves a short window for resistance to build up.”

“When the pests becomes resistant, we will have lost this benign substance as a stand-alone tool, and then we’ll probably have to go back to using more toxic pesticides.”

McCrae of Consumers’ International says consumer groups in the South are beginning to recognise the vast impact that these issues may have on their countries, but many have been financially unable to attend Codex conferences.

She urges nations that are concerned about genetic engineering to attend future meetings, since the “one nation, one vote” rule at Codex means that their views could have as much impact as those of such powerful nations as Canada and the United States that promote biotechnology.

Margaret Kenny, associate director of the biotechnology strategies and co-ordination office at Agriculture Canada, says Canada believes that labelling novel foods is impractical, given that there are no distinct transport and marketing systems to keep genetically altered and conventional products separate.

An earlier effort to transport genetically altered canola separately added 13 percent to the price of that crop, she says. Kenny adds that a requirement to label genetically engineered foods at a time when they are mixed in with conventional products could lead to “may contain” labels being affixed to virtually every food product, rendering such labels practically useless.

The Codex meeting took a more pro-active approach to new foods that contain the genes of plants known to cause allergic reactions.

This is because of the apparent increase in the number of people who experience potentially fatal allergic reactions to small traces of such common foods as peanuts, seafood, and dairy products. Allergic components can be transferred from one plant to another through genetic engineering.

The New England Journal of Medicine published a report last year, showing that soybeans modified with genes from the Brazil nut can cause allergic reactions in people with Brazil nut allergies. Allowing such products onto the market unlabelled would mean that people with potentially fatal allergies have no way of knowing whether outwardly dissimilar foods would pose the same danger.

Canada’s Kenny argues that existing safeguards would keep unsafe products out of the marketplace and would lead new products containing known, common allergens to be separated and identified as allergenic. But others maintain that people who react to less common allergens should also be protected, and that new, unknown allergies may arise as genetic engineering becomes more common.

The European Commission has expressed concern that potential allergens could be introduced into novel products.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags