Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

HONG KONG: Handover Opens Uncertain Future for Asylum Seekers

Yojana Sharma

HONG KONG, May 30 1997 (IPS) - Despite last ditch efforts by Hong Kong, the United Nations and the international community, some 1,000 Vietnamese asylum seekers will be left behind to face an uncertain future when Hong Kong is handed over to China in a month’s time.

Britain had promised China that Hong Kong’s camps would, by the June 30 handover at the latest, be emptied of Vietnamese ‘boat people’ who began arriving here in large numbers in the 1980s. Arrivals in later years, however, were mainly economic migrants, not people fleeing political persecution.

Beijing, which fought a bloody war with Vietnam, has made it clear the asylum seekers are “undesirables” who have to be removed as China refused to take responsibility for them, not least as many come from farming or fishing backgrounds.

A report this year by the New York-based Human Rights Watch Asia drew a link between a general degradation in camp conditions and pressure put on the Hong Kong and British governments by China to be rid of the boat people by the June 30 handover.

Members of the Hong Kong-based group Refugee Concern also say deteriorating camp conditions was part of a strategy to force boat people to volunteer to return to Vietnam.

Pressure from China is thought to be behind U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) Sadako Ogata’s visit to Hong Kong in March despite more pressing problems elsewhere in the world, not least in Central Africa.

Analysts here say China has no wish for its bargaining position with Vietnam, with whom ties have been improving, to be weakened by the need to get rid of the remaining asylum seekers, which it sees as a burden on Hong Kong’s economy.

Several hundred asylum seekers returned to Vietnam this week on four voluntary flights, in a final push this week to clear the camps before the May 31 “deadline” agreed in Geneva by British, Vietnamese and UNHCR officials in March.

Two more such flights left Hong Kong Friday. UNHCR said those were the last voluntary flights from Hong Kong since such trips started in 1989, as a way to encourage asylum seekers, mostly adjudged economic migrants, to return to Vietnam.

Yet more than 800 of those that remain were not been given refugee status, but deemed illegal immigrants. Half of them came via China and are not viewed by Hanoi as being of Vietnamese nationality.

These individuals would become technically stateless if China refuses to accept their presence in Hong Kong after the handover, a U.N. official here said.

Vietnam is understood to fear that taking “non-nationals” may lead to an attempt by Beijing to repatriate some 260,000 ethnically Chinese Vietnamese who settled in China fearing persecution in Vietnam after the 1979 war.

The British government is pushing for this group to be given Hong Kong residency status.

Another 1,300 asylum seekers granted refugee status also languish in Hong Kong, with few prospects of leaving before the handover date. Officials cite problems with finding a host country because the head of family has a criminal record, history of drug addiction or other health problems.

“Even though the parent may have done something unacceptable, they (host countries) should not allow the children to be penalised,” refugee lawyer Pam Baker said in an appeal to the West to take the remaining boat people granted refugee status.

But other refugee officials admitted that the chances of resettling most of these people are dim.

A meeting in Geneva this week led to more than 30 families being accepted by the US, Sweden, Britain and France.

But Australia’s regional migration director, John Williams, voiced the sentiments of many receiving nations when he said: “There are progressively less and less people who meet our criteria”. These criteria include good health and good character, he said.

Some ‘boat people’ were not on the repatriation flights this week because of health or legal problems. Some 700 asylum seekers arrived here this year in a worrying influx, and are still to be screened or their appeals for refugee status heard.

A number have escaped from the squalid prison-like detention camps in Hong Kong and cannot be accounted for, though they are on official lists and in theory must be repatriated.

What will happen to those remaining behind after Sunday is far from clear.

Vietnam, though careful not to appear to be closing the door on asylum seekers whose cases are cleared after the May 31 cutoff date, has indicated unofficially that it would allow as many Vietnamese as possible to go back before the handover.

Hanoi officials have made it clear that they wanted to “avoid problems with the new rulers of Hong Kong”. But Trieu Van The, a senior Vietnamese immigration official said in Hanoi Wednesday that any boat people left behind after the handover would be “the responsibility of Hong Kong and Britain”.

Britain itself has been one of the slowest to take up its quota of Vietnamese boat people, says Baker.

Said a U.N. source: “We will have to cross the May 31 bridge when we come to it.” Refugee lawyers in Hong Kong said that after that date boat people would be treated on a case by case basis — which would likely mean a long drawn-out process.

In March the Hong Kong government budgeted 20 million U.S. dollars for the upkeep of boat people after the handover, a recognition that the camps will not be cleared by then.

Voluntary repatriations with financial aid from the UNHCR began in 1989. The first forced repatriation flights left Hong Kong the next year, amid a chorus of international condemnation. Since then, more than 300 flights have brought more than 57,000 asylum seekers in Hong Kong back to Vietnam.

The Hong Kong government is now working on a bilateral accord with Hanoi that would end Hong Kong’s 20-year status as a port of first asylum. It would allow Hong Kong to repatriate all illegal Vietnamese entrants immediately on arrival — just like other illegal immigrants who sneak into its territory.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags