Saturday, November 21, 2026
Sarah O'Hara and Dipankar de Sarkar
- Police conduct throughout the long conflict in Northern Ireland has given rise to serious allegations of human rights abuses, encouraged by ‘anti-terrorist’ legislation applied on the British-ruled province, says a U.S. human rights group.
But it also condemned so-called ‘punishment’ attacks on both sides of Northern Ireland’s sectarian divide, the work of banned paramilitary groups enforcing their own system of ‘justice’ through brutal beatings, deliberate cripplings and murders.
In its new report ‘To Serve Without Favor: Policing, Human Rights and Accountability’, released here Wednesday, the New York based Human Rights Watch highlights four areas of policing that raise urgent human rights concern.
Under the emergency laws applied on Northern Ireland by the British government, the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) police force have been given generous powers to stop, question, search, arrest, detain and interrogate persons merely suspected of terrorist activity.
Detainees can be held up to seven days without charge. Intimidation and harassment of detainees and lawyers representing them is commonplace in the holding centres set aside for persons arrested under the emergency legislation, says the group.
“Human Rights Watch charges that the emergency legislation itself gives rise to substantial violations of human rights and urges its repeal,” says the report.
“The government of the United Kingdom must recognise that emergency laws such as those in force in Northern Ireland often serve to sustain political violence by creating an environment in which individual human rights are routinely violated.”
The six counties of Northern Ireland, which have a pro-British Protestant majority, remained under British rule when the rest of the mainly Catholic south won independence after World War I.
Civil rights abuses against the Catholic minority in the North led to conflict and British military deployment on its streets in 1968. More than 3,000 died and 36,000 were injured in the conflict up until ceasefires in 1994.
Human Rights Watch noted that the police focus on political violence had meant that its traditional duties had been neglected, even abandoned in some areas.
In the absence of normal policing, the paramilitaries have set up as “investigator, prosecutor, judge and jury,” sentencing members of their own communities for perceived or actual offences from drug trafficking and public drunkenness to wife beating and car theft.
“Paramilitary punishments take a variety of forms, including murders, crippling shootings, brutal beatings and ‘expulsion orders’ that force an alleged perpetrator to leave a particular city or all of Northern Ireland for a designated period.
Sam Cushnahan, director of Families against Intimidation and Terror pressure group, welcomed the report’s call for an end to punishment beatings by paramilitaries.
“Paramilitaries can’t take the law into their own hands. If they’re caught planting a bomb, the first thing they want to do is put up their hands and say, ‘Oh, I’m caught,’ and they want to go through the democratic process, they want to be taken to court,” he said.
“These are the same people who are carrying out the punishment attacks so they should allow their victims the same rights. We are part of a democracy and democracy should not be abused.”
The paramilitary Provisional Irish Republican Army (IRA), which opposes British rule and seeks the union of the province with the Irish Republic to the south, ended a 17 month ceasefire in February 1996 with a series of massive bombs on the British mainland.
Pro-British Protestant ‘loyalist’ paramilitaries have held their own ceasefire, but turned up the political pressure last year by insisting on carrying out a series of summer marches — celebrations of seventeenth century Protestant victories over Catholic armies — that immediately provoked angry responses from Northern Ireland present-day Catholic community.
Human Rights Watch made particular note of what it said were the failings of policing during the summer 1996 loyalist ‘marching season’ and “the lack of accountability for RUC misconduct contributed to a serious breakdown in the rule of law”.
The RUC said in a prepared statement that their initial response was that several of the report’s recommendations “fail to address the practical alternatives and display a degree of naivete of the very real difficulties in policing a deeply divided community”.
It said it had given “considerable high-level access and cooperation” to the report authors, but “the evidence they were given has not in any way influenced the accuracy or balance of this report”.
Maggie Beirne of the independent Belfast based civil liberties group, Committee on the Administration of Justice, noted that Human Rights Watch was one of the largest civil liberties groups in the world and had a wide experience of policing issues. “One thing they can’t be accused of is naivete,” she told IPS.
Julia Hall, spokeswoman for Human Rights Watch, said the police reaction to the report was disappointing. “They have failed to recognise that the substantive issues (in the report) are meant to… open some space, for constructive dialogue on issues related to police reform.
Hall said that it was not enough for the RUC to see themselves as standing outside an “inter-communal conflict”. The report also addresses “persistent allegations of collusion between members of the security forces in Northern Ireland and (pro-British) loyalist paramilitary groups”.
Hall commented: “The police must take responsibility for its own role in exacerbating that conflict”.
This is not the first time that security forces and the British government have had to face serious allegations of human rights violations in Northern Ireland.
But coming less than a month after the election of a British Labour government pledged to promoting human rights and good governance abroad, it poses a challenge to the new administration to clean up the rights record in its own back yard.
Human Rights Watch urged the lifting of emergency laws in Northern Ireland “that unduly infringe civil liberties and are used by the police to harass and intimidate people”.
But Cushnahan said he was opposed to the section in the report calling for an end to emergency powers. “If there was no terrorism, there would be no need for emergency legislation,” he said.
Detailed suggestions included laws to ensure that detainees are brought before a court within 48 hours; the closure of Northern Ireland’s Castlereagh Holding Centre, criticised by the U.N. Human Rights Committee and the U.N. Committee Against Torture; British compliance with a 1996 European Court of Human Rights ruling that denying suspects the right to silence or prompt access to lawyers violated the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms.
It also urged the British government to establish an independent unit to investigate complaints against police officers and said the RUC should recruit more Catholics, who make up 40 percent of the province’s population. The force itself is 92 percent Protestant, a figure that underpins the widespread view that it is biased.
“The use of plastic bullets should be banned because they have killed fourteen people in Northern Ireland, including seven children, and severely injured hundreds of others,” added the report. “Alternative methods of crowd control should be developed and employed.”
A spokeswoman for the British government in Belfast said Northern Ireland Secretary Marjorie Mowlam, who was in the city Tuesday, had said she had not seen the report and had declined to comment on it.