Saturday, November 21, 2026
Trevor Allen
- If many Barbadians have their way, in another two years the island’s Constitution could look entirely different from the way it does now.
To begin with, the section which allows debtors to spend time in jail would definitely be thrown out.
This section of the Constitution came up for discussion when it became public knowledge that in just two weeks between 20 and 50 men were sentenced for up to 42 days in jail for failing to comply with Court orders to pay money for maintenance of their children or for commercial debts.
Their arrears ranged from 150 to 750 dollars.
The Debtors Act, which came into force on Nov. 3, 1879 provides for maximum prison sentences of six weeks for those who fail to comply with a Court order issued under the Maintenance Act and Petty Debt Act.
But David Comissiong, attorney-at-law says this law constitutes “unnecessary criminalisation” of Barbadians. “Prison should be reserved for genuine criminals, Comissiong says. “Imrisonment is wrong. It stigmatises not only the parent but also the family and by extension the child.”
He has also lashed out at businesses which offer easy hire purchase sales in this eastern Caribbean island where the banking system is extremely liquid and crddit opportunities abound everywhere.
He says these businesses are enticing people with their glitzy dvertising and do not conduct thorough checks before individuals are offered credit. When these clients fail to pay, the business people are then “allowed” to “criminalise” them, when they themselves are guilty of faulty judgment.
The law is something from a Victorian era which has no part in today’s society, says Comissiong.
Instead of imprisonment for failure to pay these small debts, Comissiong suggests that more creative forms of punishment be looked at such as asking the individuals to perform services, from which their earnings could go towards settling those debts.
But debts are not the only things Barbadians want addressed in a revamped Constitution.
At a recent forum held by a coalition of non-governmental organisations to hear the views of the people on the reform of the Constitution several other concerns emerged, ranging from the basic rights of citizens to the right of land ownership.
Among the recommendations were the provision of four new fundamental rights to provide free medical and social care, housing, education and nutrition for Barbadians, who because of poverty, old age or disability cannot provide for themselves.
“The idea is that if the people who are in need cannot get access to these basic necessities, then they can sue the government,” Comissiong explained.
The contributors felt particularly strong about the mattr of racial discrimination. They pointed out that Section 23 of the Constitution rules against racial discrimination but not across the board, in that it prohibits discrimination only by the State. They want a rewritten version to include all private institutions and individuals.
Another area of concern is that of business monopolies. The forum called for the implementation of appropriate laws which can quash monopolies which are so powerful that they constitute a threat to the public interest.
But one of the things that grabbed the attention of many was the fact that these NGOs felt stongly that the powers of the Prime Minister under the Constitution are too extensive.
For example, the Prime Minister is the person who appoints Ministers, Government Senators, members of the Electoral and Boundaries Commission as well as members of the Teaching Services Commission, Public Service Commission, Police Service Commission and ordinary members of the Judicial and Legal Services Commission, Permanent Secretaries and many other key public officers, including the Chief Justice, High Court Judges and Appellate Judges.
Many Barbadians feel that there should be a process of consultation before these appointments are made.
These recommendations on constitutional reform have been sent to a Government-appointed Commission, headed by a senior attorney-at- law, Henry Forde. This body will be reviewing the island’s 31-year old Constitution.
It is hoped that an amended Constitution will be ready for discussion and passage in parliament before 1999 by the government of Prime Minister Owen Arthur, which commands the required two- thirds majority for Constitutional amendments.