Saturday, November 21, 2026
Murtaza Mandli
- Computer users searching for information about South Asia among the Internet’s many “chat rooms” are often surprised to receive racist or nationalistic responses.
Indeed, South Asian children who have been spared the racial animosities that have beset their home countries are the ones participating in the new hate messages.
Take the case of one pro-Indian chat line where users share sentiments like, “Pakistanis are all terrorists.”
Or a Pakistani response on the same line: “Indians would rather starve their cows than eat them as we do here.”
The growth of such invective among South Asians raised in the United States is fuelling worries that another generation is now being exposed to the sort of Hindu-Muslim rivalry that has not declined after nearly 50 years of Indian and Pakistani independence.
“It is understandable that people from India or Pakistan have this ‘fake’ fear of each other and fabricate stereotypes,” argues Professor Mohammad Alim of the University of Massachusetts.
“But when one looks at children of adults who have emigrated, there is a difference.”
Much of the racial hatred is handed down by parents, Alim contends. “But unlike back in their home countries, the children believe that to be Indian or Pakistani or Bengali is to have this hatred,” he says.
“These hatreds and stereotypes evolve to a national or religious identity for the children.”
One news group started by a user seeking information about the philosophical tenets of Hinduism and Islam became the site of Internet warfare when many adults wrote back racial slurs toward one or the other religion.
One user responded, “There is no spiritual aspect to Islam. Hinduism is very spiritual and that is why we are peaceful, whereas the other side is very violent.”
Another replied, “Why do you want to know so much about two contradicting religions? There is only one right path to follow, and that is towards one God.”
When one member on an international chat line asked others to stop “talking trash and get along”, one pro-Indian replied that he did not want to “get along” with Pakistanis or Muslims, because his identity as an Indian meant that he had to hate them. Some users simply responded, “Kill them all,” when writing about either Pakistanis or Indians.
“The hatred that exists between Pakistan and India in the physical sense is inherent on the Internet,” Alim says. But he adds that there is a crucial difference: “People who converse on the Internet do not see or hear the person that they are talking to” — a privacy which may contribute to the higher level of hostility they feel free to express.
According to numbers provided by America Online (AOL), the Internet community is growing by millions of users each year.
But the Internet, originally developed by the U.S. military to ensure safe data transfer in case of a nuclear war, offers not only information, pictures, and video on every possible subject, but missives from hate groups like the White Aryan Resistance and Ku Klux Klan.
“The Internet has so much to offer, such as a closer community of world states and people, but with that (possibility) comes the bad apples,” says Brian Pendergast, Vice-President of Information Technology at VNU, a worldwide Dutch publishing corporation.
Hatred and stereotypes exist outside the Internet, he says, but “on the Net, people have transformed those stereotypes to actually stand for the way people are. These hate groups tap into that and use it for their advantage.”
Yet he doubts that the problem is very severe, claiming that much of the invective comes from children who don’t know any better. “At the present time, the Internet is the wild West,” Pendergast says. “But I believe that in the near future, legislation will be created to control subject matter on the Internet.”
According to AOL rules for using the chat lines, there is to be no use of profanity or rudeness. On AOL, a member of a chat room can contact the Webmaster, essentially a communications monitor, and file a complaint.
Webmasters can block access to the chat room or the entire service and have the group’s members discontinued from AOL. But nothing can stop the guilty parties from simply trying to spread their messages again on a different chat line.