Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

AUSTRALIA: After Alienating Asia, Canberra Riles South Pacific

Kalinga Seneviratne

SYDNEY, Jul 30 1997 (IPS) - After offending Asia by letting a race debate get out of hand, the Australian government is in the midst of another ugly crisis in foreign relations, this time souring its ties with South Pacific countries.

In the past few weeks, the government of Prime Minister John Howard has come under a barrage of criticism from Pacific Island leaders who say Australia holds racist, patronising views toward them.

The row began soon after the first-ever meeting of economic ministers of the South Pacific Forum (SPF) in Cairns ended on July 17, one that was hosted by the Australian government to promote economic liberalisation and free trade in the region.

But much of its gains have been eroded by the furore over a confidential briefing paper prepared for the SPF meeting, which contained critical and offensive views of South Pacific nations.

Left behind at the meeting and then published in the media, the paper on the South Pacific countries was prepared for Australian ministers by the government’s Office of National Assessment, and marked ‘For Australian Eyes Only’.

It called many Pacific island leaders corrupt or drunkards, said countries like Nauru and Cook Islands are on the brink of economic collapse and accused many governments of being unwilling to undertake economic reforms. Mounting economic problems, it concluded, threaten Australia’s regional interests.

The paper said Solomon Islands Prime Minister Soloman Mamaloni was an obstacle to responsible government because he came to power with the help of Malaysian logging interests. His finance miniser, Michael Maina, was called ‘Mister Ten Percent’ for allegedly taking bribes from Malaysian logging firms.

Former Papua New Guinea Prime Minsister Julius Chan was attacked as being hostile to Australia and for pursuing closer links with Malaysia to reduce PNG’s dependence on Australian aid. It called his deputy, Chris Haiveta, an “ambitious and self- confident man” who is “combative” toward Australia and is Chan’s “lickspittle” for supporting his look-to-Asia policy.

As for Nauru, which recently took Australia to the World Court to seek damages for environmental damage caused by Australian mining activities there, the paper said it was “looking down the barrel of being an impoverished and desperate entity unable to sustain its sovereignty”.

Analysts say the disclosure of the paper has severely eroded Australia’s standing in the region, and undercuts its efforts to take a leading role in the development of the South Pacific.

Pacific leaders are outraged by the paper’s contents. Fijian premier Sitiveni Rabuka called it a “show of disrespect” for the Pacific people. A spokesman for Solomon Islands’ Mamaloni said it “makes South Pacific countries suspicious of what Australia gets up to”.

“The document sounded as though it was heavily laced with rumour and scuttlebutt, rather than an attempt to provide sound analytical advice,” said Nauru President Kinza Clodumar.

Acting President Ruben Zackhiras of the Marshall Islands, current SPF chair, accused Canberra of allowing senior officials to give vent to “prejudice and intolerance”. He said: “The disclosure has created shock and dismay among Forum countries and has damaged Australia’s standing in the Forum community.”

Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer issued a statement assuring Pacific leaders the report did not reflect “the views or attitudes of the Australian government nor Australian government policy toward Pacific island countries”. He told diplomatic missions in the region to explain Australia’s side.

But critics say the report adds more fire to perceptions about Australia’s racist attitude. Former foreign minister Gareth Evans, now acting opposition leader, called the document an “ill- conceived, patronising, arrogant, contemptuous piece of work that should never have been written”.

“We’ve alienated people right around Asia with the Hanson phenomenon and the govenrment’s inability to deal sensibly with that. We’ve now alienated the entire South Pacific,” he said.

Evans was referring to independent legislator Pauline Hanson, whose remarks seeking a stop to Asian immigration had ignited a race debate. The Howard government drew flak for not quickly and categorically objecting to her views.

Even New Zealand, Australia’s closest friend in the region, was offended by the South Pacific paper, which accused it of eroding Canberra’s attempts to urge island governments to introduce economic reforms.

The paper called New Zealand treasurer Winston Peters a “loose cannon”, an opportunist with a reputation for erratic behaviour and a drunkard who enjoys late hours in nightclubs.

Since he is the first senior New Zealand minister of indigenous Maori descent, this adds fuel to accusations that the report has racist connotations. Peters dismissed the report as “merely the opinion of an ignorant bureaucrat”.

Fiji’s finance minister Berenado Vunibobo, who the report said had a mercurial temper, said Pacific island leaders “will be more hesitant about talking to Australia about their problems in the future”.

Vunibobo has criticised Australian advice to the islands to cut back on public spending and lift tariff protection, arguing these would have a “dehumanising” effect. Unlike Australia and New Zealand, countries like Fiji do not have the social welfare net to soften the impact of lay-offs that reforms lead to.

The confidential report reflects views within the bureaucracy that foreign aid could be used to pressure Pacific islands to change economic policies, said Liam Phelan, campaign coordinator of AIDWATCH, the watchdog of Australia’s aid programme.

“For some time, the Australian government has been quite clearly pushing the free trade formula to the South Pacific, irrespective of the fact of whether it’s going to benefit them,” he said in an interview.

And while Australia has been pushing the idea of good governance on Pacific island economies, it has been changing the definition of this concept to suit its aims.

“Good governance traditionally has been the rule of law, democracy, respect for human rights,” Phelan said. “But what is being preached to South Pacific countries is private sector-led growth, freer or efficient trading structures. Democracy, rule of law, human rights become secondary.”

How Canberra develops such policies may be gleaned from a comment by Kenneth Trezise, former speechwriter and media advisor to PNG’s Chan, who said the report had been prepared by those who “exist in an isolated world of their own, mainly having no contact with people whose views and feelings they are supposed to assess”.

“A greater tragedy is the Australian failure to understand other attitudes, other sensitivities and other priorities,” he said in a letter published by the ‘Sydney Morning Herald’. “Australia deserves its reputation as an enclave of sermonising white racists in a coloured ocean.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags