Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour, North America

CANADA-RIGHTS: Companies Fare Poorly on Workers’pRights

Aaron Freeman

OTTAWA, Jul 23 1997 (IPS) - Echoes of recent allegations of U.S. companies running “sweatshops” in Latin America and Asia can now be heard in Canada where most firms operating abroad have a poor record in addressing the rights of their foreign workers, according to business study published here.

Worse still, Canadian firms appear content to sit back and do nothing until their malpractices are discovered, the report says.

“Commerce With Conscience?”, published by the Canadian Lawyers Association for International Human Rights in collaboration with the Montreal-based International Centre for Human Rights and Democratic Development (ICHRDD) found that more than three- quarters of firms surveyed either have no human rights code of conduct for their international operations or refused to respond to requests for information.

The study surveyed 98 largest Canadian companies with operations abroad. Among the findings:

– Only 21 of the 43 companies that responded to requests for information said they had codes of conduct governing their human rights practices internationally. Just six of these had policies on dealing with oppressive regimes and the same number had some form of independent monitoring in place – regarded by human rights workers as crucial to ensuring a code’s effectiveness.

– While six companies said it followed policies allowing the four main labour rights – the right to organize, no discrimination in the work place, elimination of child labour and no forced labour – only one (Ontario Hydro) was willing to provide a written copy of its code. Two others that claimed to cover these rights provided codes that, in fact, did not refer to these basic standards.

“Canadian businesses have failed to introduce policies that ensure that their activities are human rights-sensitive,” says the author of the report, Craig Forcese. “If businesses aren’t putting their principles down on paper, they can’t ensure that they are putting them in place on the factory floor.”

Well-known companies that boast they have codes include the Hudson’s Bay Co. and the mining giants Inco Ltd. of Toronto and Cambior Inc. of Montreal. Several Canadiuan subsidiaries of U.S. firms also declared they had codes , including Longueuil, Pratt and Whitney Canada and Apple >Canada.

Other companies, however, showed indifference to human rights codes of conduct, Forcese says.

One clothing retailer, Reitmans of Montreal, maintained that it was too difficult to evaluate suppliers as regards the rights of their workers. Reitman’s President Jeremy Reitman says that the company’s human rights practices abroad “is not an issue we’ve addressed.”

Other firms stated they simply abided by the laws of the host country in which they operated. The Manager of Invester Relations of TVX Gold, Ed. Baer, says that while the company has no code, good human rights practices are “a way of life.”

David Irwin, manager of marketing of Toronto-based Irwin Toy – one of the companies that failed to respond to the survey – told IPS that the company did indeed have a code governing overseas human rights practices, including policies on “no child labour.” When asked to send a copy of the code to IPS, a company official faxed a note stating the firm “has not maintained formal policies and procedures on human rights.”

Like the United States, the issue of human rights in business practices has gained importance in recent years as a growing number of Canadian companies have established operations abroad. The Canadian government has decreased its profile on international human rights issues, opting for a policy of “constructive engagement” while business leaders agree that voluntary codes are better than government regulations in such areas as human rights, environmental and labour standards.

But human rights groups worry that companies setting up shop in the Third World countries are taking advantage of low wage and workplace standards. Activists have recently targeted companies such as Nike, The Gap and Starbucks, using consumer pressure to force these firms to develop codes governing their human rights standards and those of their sub-contractors.

ICHRDD hopes the study will prompt Canadian companies to address the impact of their operations on human rights conditions abroad. “We hope this study will stimulate Canadian companies to adopt effective codes dealing with the fundamental rights of their workers everywhere in the world, including independent control mechanisms to ensure the codes are respected,” says ICHRDD President Warren Allmand.

But Canadian Apparel Federation Director Stephen Beatty defended his industry’s human rights policies saying “80 percent of U.S. apparel companies have codes. There are fewer in Canada because Canadian companies are entering international trade for the first time.”

Such responses worry the author of “Commerce With Conscience?”

“The response by the business community has been defensive, not pro-active,”Forcese says. “The message this sends is that companies will sit back and wait for their practices to come to light before acting on human rights matters.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags