Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

US-DEVELOPMENT: Deregulation Hits Consumers

Reese Erlich

SAN FRANCISCO, Jul 22 1997 (IPS) - California is moving forward with the de-regulation of electric utilities but already consumers are beginning to discover that promised benefits may not be any bargain.

On Jan. 1 1998, residential customers are scheduled to receive a 10 percent reduction in the price of electricity but, under the terms of a bond measure just passed by the Californian state legislature, they face hefty new charges – mostly to pay off the costs of nuclear power plants. Consumer interest groups say the net reduction over 10 years will only be about one and-a-half to two percent.

“The consumers will get nothing out of deregulation,” says Harry Snyder of Consumers Union, a watchdog group that publishes Consumer Reports Magazine.

Supporters of deregulation, however, argue that consumers will eventually get lower rates due to competition among suppliers. “We think it’s going to lower the electric costs for everybody,” says Glenn Scheerin, chair of the Energy Committee of the California Manufacturers Association.

The same energy companies pushing for deregulation in the United States also strongly support privatization of state-owned electric companies in Europe and the developing world.

For example, in June the Portland-based Pacificorp announced plans to buy a recently privatized British utility for an estimated 5.8 billion dollars in cash. Argentina privatized 1.5 billion dollars worth of its electric power industry, selling off assets to such companies as Duke Power Co. of North Carolina and Entergy of Louisiana.

The same free market ideology that promotes privatization of government-owned utilities abroad provides the impetus for deregulation inside the United States. In theory, private power companies competing against one another will provide better service at lower rates. The reality, as Californians are discovering, can be different.

Since the early 1980s, large manufacturers in California have complained about their high utility rates. Glenn Scheerin, who is also an executive with the box manufacturer Inland Paper Corp., says California industrial rates can be twice as high as those in neighboring Arizona and Nevada.

“If you are competing with someone who is shipping in products from an adjacent state, you are at a competitive disadvantage,” he says.

Large-scale manufacturers and utility companies lobbied for years before the califponian government finally agreed in 1996 to deregulate electricity. The plan, which backers see as a model for other states, will be phased in over a four-year period.

By the year 2001, existing electric utilities will be broken into three parts: generation, transmission and distribution. Only the power transmitting companies – those that own substations and power lines – will remain regulated.

Under the scheme, power generating companies will produce electricity and sell it to independent distributors, some having nothing more than offices and telephones, who then resell the power to customers. Large industrial users will benefit immediately, saving as much as 30-40 percent, because they can negotiate discounts for deals involving volume.

But residential customers don’t have that bargaining power. The electricity distributors will be using telemarketing and junk mailings to convince customers that their plans are the best. But as has been discovered with long-distance telephone sales pitches, consumers have trouble sorting out the real costs of any given plan.

Actual savings will vary by only a few dollars each month because residential users will be locked into paying surcharges under the deregulation law. For example, the law provides that customers – not the utility companies – must pay 28 billion dollars in debts, mostly stemming from building and maintaining costly nuclear power plants. Such debts are called “stranded assets.”

In mid-July the state legislature approved a bond measure that allows utilities to immediately get 7-9 billion dollars to pay for stranded assets and also to buy back their own stock. Rate payers will be paying back the interest and principle on those bonds for the next 10 years!

Harry Snyder of Consumers Union calls this “complete hypocrisy,” noting that the government frequently refuses to pass laws to protect consumers rights because such regulation “would interfere with free enterprise.”

“When the utilities and manufactures come to the legislature, they (legislators) will do anything to help,” says Snyder, “and do it in the name of free enterprise.”

The process of deregulation also calls into question the whole future of renewable energy. Solar, wind, geothermal and other alternative energy sources are currently subsidized by rate payers. During the transition period to full deregulation, renewables will continue to receive 540 million dollars in subsidies.

Given current technology, however, renewable energy is quite expensive. For example, solar power in Sacramento – an area with highly developed solar facilities – costs eight times as much to produce as electricity from natural gas or coal-fired plants.

“How can renewables compete?” asked Gary Gerber, owner of Sun, Light and Power Co., a Berkeley company selling solar products. He argues that society has a collective interest in nurturing pollution-free power production and should continue subsidies.

While California has set up the basic framework for deregulation, many details remain to be worked out. Groups such as the Consumers Union and TURN (The Utility Reform Network) continue to lobby for greater consumer and environmental protection.

The slick advertising brochures are starting to appear in the mail as the January 1 date for deregulation approches. Californians, however, remain leery of assurances that the consumers will benefit.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags