Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

LABOUR-LATIN AMERICA: Part-time Work No Solution to Unemployment

Zoraida Portillo

LIMA, Aug 21 1997 (IPS) - Increasing numbers of workers in latin America have part-time jobs, which is no solution to the regional unemployment problem and will not raise living standards, according to the International Labour Organization (ILO).

Almost everywhere in Latin America there is a trend toward greater liberalization of the labor market and this has meant the gradual replacement of permanent, full-time workers with temporary part-time ones. Also, there has been a resurgence in home-based occupations as well as piece work in factories, says the ILO.

In Argentina, for example, part-time positions increased from 10 percent to 16 percent of the total number of jobs available between 1982 and 1995. In the Brazilian city of Sao Paulo, part-time employment increased from 20 percent in 1987 to 39 percent in 1994. Mexico and Chile also exhibited significant increases.

In other countries such as Peru, Bolivia and Ecuador, part-time labor is used chiefly by sales and manufacturing companies, but it is impossible to measure the increase since statistics are diluted by micro-enterprise and underground business, the ILo says.

Part-time employment has been a growing trend in the United States and Europe and some 20 million North American workers – 18 percent of the total labor force – are believed currently to be working part-time schedules.

Some analysts believe that the use of part-time labor in Latin America will result in increased employment. Many members of the business community are convinced that part-time employment will reduce labor costs and unemployed workers view part-time employment as a source of hope since it has become virtually impossible to secure full-time employment.

Maritza Villalobos, a 27 year old Peruvian secretary, illustrates the trend. “I got tired of looking for a good job. I need to work. What difference does it make if I put in five hours a day and they pay me part-time. At least I have an assured income”.

Nevertheless, “the numbers” do not justify the optimism expressed by those who favor part-time employment. A study conducted by the ILO in a number of developed countries revealed that part-time employment is not an efficient means of reducing unemployment.

Optimism was indeed justified by the spectacular growth of employment opportunities in the United States and Europe when part- time employment first became popular in the 1980’s. Now that initial euphoria has passed, however, latest data reveals that part-time employment scarcely produced an increase of 0.2 to 0.4 percent over previous employment levels.

The ILO has issued several documents showing that new jobs that have been created as a result of part-time employment have been “scarce, menial, and unstable.”

In a study of labor market politics in highly developed countries, Daniel Martinez, a regional ILO consultant, wonders if optimism is justified in the view of a labor format that creates precarious employment while eroding widely recognized labor rights.

Martinez says “the increasing number of part-time workers in private industry raises doubts concerning the level of qualification that these workers can attain, as well as doubts concerning part-time workers productive potential.

Martinez went on to say that “due to the nature of the relationship between management and part-time workers, private employers could stop investing in worker training altogether.

If this comes to pass, mid and large-sized industries might settle for a reduced number of highly qualified and productive workers on the one hand, and on the other hand would employ a great number of transient part-time workers with lower levels of qualification and productivity”.

According to Martinez “employers think it is a good deal to hire part-time workers.”

Esteban Hinostroza, manager of a Lima business consultancy, says that employers like part-time workers not only because they reduce labor costs through low salaries and minimal benefits “but because they believe part-time workers make them more competitive”.

Hinostroza notes that “these employers are partially right if we examine the North American experience wherein the impact of part-time workers has been positive on the economy”.

Nevertheless, Hinostroza adds that many businesses have witnessed lower productivity because their part-time workers have been unable to create productive teams, an organizational trait that typifies full-time workers.

Hinostroza adds: “If we consider things from the worker’s vantage, disadvantages are tremendous since part-time workers enjoy practically none of the benefits given to full-time employees. Furthermore, their job training opportunities are notably fewer”.

Part-time employment in Latin America is conceptually different from part-time employment in developed countries where the definition of “part-time” means a work week of fewer than 20 hours.

Hinostroza emphasizes the fact that “in Latin American countries, part-time workers may include anyone working fewer than 35 hours per week”.

In provincial cities — which are usually less developed than capital cities — part-time labor is very popular.

Many discrepancies exist in the current Latin American labor market.

Studies conducted by the ILO and other labor organizations show that throughout Latin America, more women than men are employed part-time. Furthermore, while women are forced to accept part-time work in 62 percent of cases, men accept part-time work involuntarily in only 55 percent of cases.

Women who do work part-time enjoy – on average – greater recompense than men. They also perform tasks that require greater training and work for more highly respected enterprises.

Part-time male workers, on the other hand, come from low-income homes and are virtually unskilled. Nevertheless, both male and female part-time workers are especially vulnerable since labor safeguards continue to decline when part-time employees work fewer hours.

Whereas 47 percent of all part-time Latin American workers who labor are employed for less than 35 hours per week have no benefits, 63 percent of those who work fewer than 20 hours per week have no benefits.

Part-time women workers are the most disadvantaged since they have no rights to maternity leave nor pre-natal or post-opration medical care.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags