Saturday, November 21, 2026
Carol Martindale
- Government officials in this small eastern Caribbean island need to answer one important question at this time, and that is, where are they going to put more crimnals?
That problem has emerged because the island’s lone Glendairy prison is literally bursting at the seams and there is just nowhere to house additional inmates.
Built to accommodate 350 men, the prison now has a population of 760, while the female section onstructed to house 25 is now five over that limit.
Attorney General David Simmons is so concerned about this situation that he recently commissioned a study to explore alternatives to imprisonment in Barbados.
“There are 350 cells for male prisoners and today there are 760 inmates. In that sort of milieu it is virtually impossible to pursue, far less achieve, any of the traditional objectives of punishment like reform and rehabilitation. Imprisonment has een a common penalty for at least 200 years but today the very institution of imprisonment is being called into question,” says Simmons.
He says the reliance on incarceration is also not reducing crime rates. That is why government is now looking at other ways of punishing wrongdoers, he adds. To that end a committee has been set up to look at alternatives to imprisonment and a first report has been tabled in Parliament.
The report suggests that community-based sentencing be considered “if only for the reason that such alternatives for imprisonment are far more cost-effective and cost-efficient”.
“The prisons are overcrowded and the economic cost of imprisonment is high,” says the report which noted that inmates incarcerated for non-violent offences make up more than 50 percnt of the current prison population.
One way around this is to allow those found guilty of petty offences to be given alternative sentencing. These could range from cleaning police officers’ boots, bus terminals ad hospital wards to serving in arious capacities in government institutions.
Among those who have already been given these alternative sentences are three teenagers. Emerson Gaskin, 18, who was charged with having a ratchet knife in his possession and was told to report for one week of voluntary duty with the National Conservation Commission (NCC) which is responsible for the beautification of the island’s beaches, parks and other tourists attractions.
His special assignment was to clean up the east coast
The second youngster, 17 year old Junior Taylor, a baker was charged with unlawfully wounding a colleague by hitting him in the face with a baking tin.
The Magistrate gave him a choice — three months in prison or one week at the Sanitation Service Authority. He chose the latter.
Stephen Wharton, was found guilty of using indecent language, resisting arrest and assaulting two police officers. He was ordered to give one week of assistance to the National Cultural Foundation (NCF).
“I am happy that some magistrates are creatively making use of non- custodial sentences even before we put all the structures in place,” says Simmons.
And ordinary Barbadians seem to support Simmons. “They (offenders) should be made to do community work because too many of them are getting fat off tax-payers money and they should be made to work real hard,” says one observer