Friday, November 20, 2026
Abid Aslam
- A wave of protests accompanying the summit here between U.S. President Bill Clinton and Chinese President Jiang Zemin has underscored the growing opposition to Washington’s ‘constructive engagement’ with Beijing.
While the two leaders met inside the White House Wednesday at the mid-point of Jiang’s eight-day U.S. state visit, human rights activists gathered across the street to berate Beijing’s human rights record and what they deem Washington’s weak response.
Senator Paul Wellstone of Minnesota – one of several Democrats objecting to Clinton’s China policy – called on the president to demand the release of political prisoners and international supervision of China’s prisons. “We are for constructive engagement, but we are not for destructive engagement,” he declared.
In recent weeks, Clinton and Secretary of State Madeleine Albright have offered repeated assurances that the administration would press Jiang and his entourage of 80 on human rights. Activists and U.S. legislators, however, are voicing outrage at what they see as the overwhelming influence of business interests over the ongoing process of bringing Sino-U.S. relations to what Jiang calls “a new stage”.
That dissatisfaction was summarised Wednesday by protestors’ placards, which read, “Washington Weakness plus Beijing Tyranny plus Greed equals Contemptible Engagement.”
Chinese dissidents in exile here reject the impression – spread by pundits and the press – that they favour isolating China.
“In principle, I do not oppose the United States’ comprehensive engagement policy towards China. Yet, the practice of that policy has undermined human rights,” Tong Yi, a former assistant to imprisoned dissident Wei Jingsheng, said Tuesday.
Tong noted that Beijing sent Wei, a leader of China’s Democracy Wall movement of 1979, back to prison in 1994, the same year that Clinton agreed to sever any link between China’s human rights record and the granting of U.S. most-favoured-nation (MFN) trading status.
Among other prominent dissidents incarcerated after Clinton dropped human rights from the MFN criteria was Wang Dan, a student protest leader at Tiananmen Square. Wang continues to serve an 11- year prison sentence.
“The Chinese government has taken advantage of this engagement policy to boost its economy, on which its total legitimacy lies,” Tong argued.
As a presidential candidate in 1991, Clinton branded China’s leaders the “butchers of Beijing” and attacked incumbent George Bush for seeking to rebuild relations after the Tiananmen Square killings in June 1989.
Clinton’s 1994 about-face followed a series of Chinese trade missions which spent billions of dollars on contracts for U.S. exports to China. In turn, many U.S. firms which had been awarded Chinese contracts lobbied heavily to obtain MFN status for Beijing.
This time around, Jiang is seeking permanent MFN status, which would cancel the annual review currently required for its renewal. Beijing last week sent a new buying mission, led by vice trade minister Sun Zhenyu, to spend some four billion dollars on goods manufactured in the United States – including 30 Boeing jets worth an estimated 2 billion dollars.
In addition, Beijing wants to join the World Trade Organisation (WTO) but with more time to reduce tariffs and expose its markets fully to foreign competition. Washington has argued that, given China’s tremendous economic growth and nearly 50-billion-dollar-a- year trade surplus with the United States, Beijing should be regarded within a short time frame as an industrialised country by the trade body.
Jiang’s visit also includes meetings with leading U.S. business executives. He is to ring the opening bell at the New York Stock Exchange Friday. That night, the U.S.-China Business Council, a key lobbying group for corporations with ambitions in China’s market of 1.2 billion consumers, will host a dinner for Jiang at New York’s prestigious Waldorf-Astoria Hotel.
For their part, U.S. companies want greater access to the world’s fastest-growing economy. Japan was the first nation to restore full ties with Beijing following Tiananmen; French, Canadian, and Russian companies have won an estimated 12 billion dollars in contracts to aid China’s bid to dam the Yangtze river. U.S. sanctions imposed after the 1989 clampdown have hindered government attempts to support home-based firms’ business dealings with Beijing.
The corporations have argued that lifting those sanctions will help reduce the U.S. trade deficit with China – and that expanded trade ties with Beijing will push China along the road to a free- market economy and greater political freedom.
“If Beijing perceives that the Clinton administration is disinterested (sic) in pushing forward on an affirmative China policy, including granting China permanent (MFN) status in conjunction with its accesstion to the WTO, then China’s willingness to undertake painful but essential economic reforms may erode,” Kimberly Silver of the U.S.-China Business Council warned in a recent article.
Others are unswayed. “Let the supporters of constructive engagement visit Wei Jingsheng in prison and ask him how selling more Big Macs in China will help him win his freedom,” Senator Russell Feingold, Democrat of Wisconsin, suggested Wednesday.
Given the high commercial stakes involved, however, the talks will likely show that “trade trumps torture every time in this administration,” William Schulz, executive director of Amnesty International USA, said Tuesday.