Friday, November 20, 2026
Danielle Knight
- Demonstrators sprayed in the eyes with liquid pepper while protesting the logging of redwood trees in northern California appear to have been the victims of a new police ‘zero tolerance’ toward environmental activism.
“While it is not as bad for U.S. environmentalists as it is in other countries, clearly this incident is part of a scary trend toward escalated human rights abuses of environmentalists here and abroad,” says Celia Alario, a campaigner with Rainforest Action Network (RAN).
Worldwide, from the Ogoni in Nigeria, to the U’wa in Colombia, to environmentalists in Northern California, people have to fight for their right to protect the environment. The Washington-based Sierra Club, and other organisations now say they increasingly find themselves participating in an entirely new arena – the struggle for human rights.
“In many countries the Sierra Club finds that environmentally concerned citizens are not only increasingly threatened by their own governments, but also by multinational corporations,” says Stephen Mills, a campaigner with the Sierra Club.”
And human rights groups are also becoming increasingly involved with environmental debates. Amnesty International, the human rights watchdog, for example, came out publically against the pepper-spraying incident calling it “inhuman and degrading treatment of such deliberateness and severity that it is tantamount to torture.”
In the case of the Californian redwoods “police are suppressing our rights, while protecting the interests of Charles Hurwitz [the head of Maxxam corporation],” adds Randall Hayes, the director of RAN, a California-based environmental group.
Demonstrators were trying to draw public attention to a “Headwaters Deal,” which is a forest management plan designed by California-based Pacific Lumber – a subsidiary of Maxxam corporation – which owns the land, and Democratic Senator Diane Feinstein. Environmentalists say that while Feinstein is protecting 7,500 acres of Headwaters Forest located in Northern California, she is allowing the logging of old growth redwoods – some which date back 2,000 years – in the remaining 50,000 acres.
While local police, not Pacific Lumber, administered the spraying, the company nevertheless supported the officers actions. “We don’t influence the police, but I don’t think the whole story was told, I mean these people were once in our office for three hours – disrupting our work,” Mary Bullwinkel, a Pacific Lumber spokeswoman told IPS.
Environmentalists, however, feel the company’s work is worth disrupting.
“The Headwaters Forest deal is not about environmental protection,” says Hayes. The plan, if approved, will circumvent the endangered species act, exempting the company, from the species-by species lawsuits necessary to stop destructive logging, say environmentalists.
The redwood groves, one of the last unprotected redwood areas in the world, include the habitat of two endangered species – Coho salmon and the marbled murrelet bird.
“In Maxxam’s drive for quick profit places not only the ancient redwoods at risk, but other endangered species as well,” Paul Mason, director of the California-based Environmental Protection Information Center (EPIC), an advocacy group involved with the Headwaters dispute.
Maxxam, which has been criticized for its environmental abuses in Ecuador, considers the Headwaters Deal to be a fair compromise. “We are doing everything we can to implement this agreement,” Bob Irelan, Maxxam spokesman told IPS.
Once a small family owned business, Pacific Lumber of California was taken over in 1986 by Maxxam, the Texas corporate conglomerate owned by Charles Hurwitz. Environmentalists say he bought Pacific Lumber in an effort to pay back a debt to the federal government.
In the Savings and Loan turmoil of the late 1980s and early ’90s, Hurwitz ended up owing U.S. taxpayers 1.6 billion dollars. Federal regulators are trying to get him to pay 250 million as his personal share.
If the Headwaters Deal is signed by President Bill Clinton, Maxxam will receive 380 million dollars – 250 million from the Federal government and 130 from California, in exchange for 7,500 acres of old-growth forest.
The other 50,000 acres of the redwood land that Maxxam owns, however, will be open for clear-cutting.
Environmentalists say the deal pays Hurwitz an exorbitant sum of money which has not been supported by independent appraisals. “Four of the six ancient groves receive no permanent protection and company documents show they continue to plan on logging them,” says Pope. The deal also exempts protection of fish and wildlife on the rest of the Pacific Lumber forests for the next 50- 65 years, say groups.
For all these reasons, environmentalists are calling on Clinton to veto the legislation. “The Headwaters deal and the legislation now on President Clinton’s desk is a sweet deal for Charles Hurwitz, but it’s a bad deal for Headwaters Forest and the redwood region,” says Carl Pope, the president of the Washington-based Sierra Club, the nation’s largest environmental group.
“The deal may save some beautiful forest, but unless the government takes a tougher line with Maxxam, it also could turn hundreds of thousands of acres into a sacrifice zone for the further enrichment of Charles Hurwitz,” he says. “We shouldn’t have to make that trade-off to preserve some of the world’s last ancient redwoods.”
A group of protestors – mostly young women – made up of supporters of Earthfirst!, a direct action group, and EPIC, decided to demonstrate at Pacific Lumber and Senators’ offices. After locking arms and sitting down in Senator Frank Riggs office, the Humboldt Country Sheriff Department told them to leave.
“When we refused to go, one officer pulled back our eyelids, while another put pepper spray in our eyes,” Lisa Sanderson-Fox told IPS. “The pain was awful. I was screaming and couldn’t see what was happening to the other people because my eyes were burning.”
While, Feinstein came out against the sprayings, Riggs called the act “an appropriate use of force.”
Video footage of the incident show that the spray was clearly abusive as it was not used to protect officers or others but was applied in a calculated and deliberate way “as to inflict pain as a way of gaining compliance in cases of demonstrators who posed no threat,” said Amnesty.
The rights group pointed out that there have been several dozen deaths of people in the United States after being sprayed with pepper spray in recent years. Amnesty and others are calling for a full independent inquiry into police action in the above cases, including a review of police policies on use of the spray.
Still determined to protest the Headwaters Deal after the pepper spray incident, Sanderson-Fox maintains, “We have both the right and a responsibility to take action when the environment is threatened by corporations.”