Economy & Trade, Environment, Europe, Headlines

GLOBAL WARMING: European Union ‘Good Guys’ Not So Good

Dipankar De Sarkar

LONDON, Dec 8 1997 (IPS) - The European Union has been made out to be the ‘good guys’ at the Kyoto Climate Summit. But there’s more to their position than meets the eye.

And the key to understanding that lies in a concept known as the ‘bubble,’ say climate change experts here. The European Union (EU) proposal is for all industrialised countries to cut emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), methane and nitrous oxide by 7.5 percent on 1990 levels by 2005 and by 15 percent by 2010.

Though better than most offers from the principal polluter nations, and much better than the U.S. position, it still falls short of NGO wishes, who want faster action and deeper cuts. The World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF), for instance, calls for a 20 percent cut in industrialised countries’ CO2 emissions by 2005 with more cuts by 2010.

But there is a catch with the EU position: it advocates a flat rate cut in greenhouse gas across the developed world, yet within its 15 nation membership it plans the kind of flexibility and quota-swopping that it wants to deny the rest of the world.

At home within the 15 EU states, the bloc plans differentiated cuts that could allow some poorer nations like Portugal and Spain to actually increase emissions — the balance being made up across the EU by countries like Britain and Germany that have the capacity to cut more than the EU would require.

These differentiated targets help the EU as a whole to create a so-called ‘bubble’ of emissions quota totals in which the total adds up to the required, even if the some of the individual nations are hiking their emissions.

Britain all but shut down its coal industry to silence powerful miners’ unions in the 1980s, drawing instead from its plentiful gas reserves; Germany dealt with the problem of former East German heavy industry inherited after reunification by closing it down.

The result was a substantial, statistical drop in CO2 emissions that have nothing to do with environment policy, but which are being used, years later, to balance emissions increases elsewhere in the EU.

The bubbles is being seized upon by other nations as the source of a loophole to circumvent the problems of emissions cuts, which were originally intended to be both fixed and across the board, but under pressure from western industrial lobby groups, are slowly proving to be neither.

“Agreed reductions must not be offset by allowing loopholes which under the headline of flexibility are being considered as part of the final agreement,” the WWF said in a statement issued this week.

“If utilised, these loopholes could effectively cause an increase in emissions from industrialised countries instead of reductions and thus undermine the entire protocol.”

Japan is looking for partners in another giant bubble, of two or three groups of nations — one suggestion is the EU plus a part of OPEC, the U.S. and Russia.

As with Germany, Russian emissions have fallen dramatically as the end of state subsidies have closed factories across the Federation. Russia is said to be touting for U.S. partnership in a bubble that could allow the U.S. to emit already abated emissions from Russia for a given price.

“This is a type of ‘hot air’ emissions trading. Russia would be selling emission reductions that had not resulted from efforts to protect the climate while the purchaser would avoid having to take actions at home,” the WWF said.

If agreed, any emissions trading regime would most likely grant Russia a quota far in excess of what it needs, and trading would allow emissions to increase.

There is another dispute over EU policy, this time over negotiations on ‘sinks’ — any process, activity or mechanism which removes a harmful gas from the atmosphere. These include forests, which absorb CO2.

According to the WWF, confrontation is mounting within the EU over what is called the ‘net approach’, which refers to setting targets on greenhouse gas emissions minus the amount absorbed by ‘sinks’, such as forests. Leading scientists warn against using the net approach fearing that sinks cannot be quantified accurately.

As far as figures go, the EU’s 15 member-states discharge less CO2 into the air than the United States. And, unlike the United States, the emissions are declining. In 1994, the EU discharged 3,103 million tonnes of CO2 — marginally down from the 3,155 million tonnes discharged in 1990. This is projected to fall further.

The U.S. produced 5,105 million tonnes of CO2 in 1995 — a five percent increase over its 1990 level of 4,870 million tonnes. The discharge is expected to rise by another 13 percent in the year 2000 and by 23 percent in 2010.

Another way of calculating how poorly or well a country or a grouping is doing is to measure CO2 emissions and primary energy production for every 1,000 dollars of gross domestic product (GDP) produced.

By this wealth-indexed figure, the lower the number, the better it is from the environmental point of view — a low number means that fewer CO2 emissions are produced(or less energy is used) for a unit of wealth created.

According to data compiled by WWF’s British section, the U.S. emits 0.80 tonnes of CO2 and 0.31 tonnes of primary energy for every 1,000 dollars the country’s economy generates. In comparison, the EU’s figure for primary energy production is 0.15 tonnes. There are no GDP-indexed figures for EU CO2 emission.

Within the EU, figures vary widely. Germany is the highest CO2 polluter, having discharged 1,026 million tonnes in 1990 and 908 million tonnes in 1995. The next worst offender is Britain, which emitted 611 million tonnes in 1990 and 581 million tonnes in 1995.

Third in line is France, but unlike Germany and Britain, French emissions are on the increase with figures of 378 million tonnes for 1990 and 385 million tonnes for 1995.

At the other end of the scale is tiny Luxembourg, whose 13.8 million tonnes in 1995 represented an 18.7 percent decline from the 1990-level of 16.2 million tonnes. And in the middle are industrialising Greece, Portugal and Spain.

Portugal alone discharged 49.69 million tonnes of CO2 in 1995 — an increase of 8.09 percent of the 45.97 million tonnes it released in 1990.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags