Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

POPULATION: In Defence of Immigration

Patrick Smikle

HOLLYWOOD, FLORIDA, Dec 30 1997 (IPS) - In the debate which has raged in the United States over the past three years, those in support of immigration have largely been on the defensive in the face of a lobbying onslaught by conservative groups and the anti- immigration posture of the Republican controlled Congress.

In recent months however, pro-immigration forces seem finally to have found their footing and their voices. And some of these voices have been influential spokespersons.

“Immigration has been a rich, even miraculous, source of American pluralism and renewal, bringing to our shores ambitious and creative men and women from more than 170 countries,” declared James O Freedman in a recent speech.

Observers of, and participants in the immigration debate are accustomed to hearing these kinds of statements from the pro- immigrant groups such as the Florida Immigration Advocacy Centre, not from one of this country’s most respected intellectuals and the President of Dartmouth College, one of its most prestigious academic institutions.

Freedman’s speech to the National Press Club in Washington was not about immigration. It was about the role and the importance of intellectuals in American society. He framed the speech in the context of four books, one of which was Oscar Handlin’s 1951, The Uprooted .

He said Handlin noted how immigrants, in seeking opportunity, had contributed to the creation of American culture. “An economy already growing, they stimulated to yet more rapid growth. Into a culture never uniform, they introduced a multitude of diversities.”

Handlin, Freedman said, had noted also that “each new generation of immigrants has typically been branded as worse and more problematic than earlier generations, slower to learn English, more insular in its consciousness of group identity, lazier or less ambitious, more likely to be public charges.”

He laments that “in recent years, the political rhetoric concerning immigrants has again turned nativist and intolerant.” He noted that… “Legislation reducing the eligibility of certain immigrants to welfare benefits has demonstrated an alarming measure of unfounded suspicion. The harsh tone of the rhetoric and the punitive character of the legislation have suggested a lack of generosity and hospitality; indeed, a scapegoating that threatens to undermine an historic national interest.

“We need to continue to welcome new generations of immigrants to our society and to ensure that we nurture their talents to the fullest,” he said.

Similar sentiments have been expressed by Robert Giulliani. His authority however, was not intellectuals like Handlin, but his own experience as two term Mayor of New York City, which he says is the most diverse city in the world, with “more people from a broader cross section of the entire world than any other city.”

Against this background, and with 113,000 immigrants coming to New York every year, Giulliani has taken positions on the immigration issue which set him apart from and often at odds with the leadership of the Republican Party of which he is a prominent member.

He has filed suit to overturn provisions of the welfare reform law which blocks welfare benefits to legal immigrants. He has also gone to court to prevent the Republican Congress from revoking an Executive Order by his Democratic predecessor, Ed Koch, which protected illegal immigrants registering their children in government schools, seeking health services or reporting crimes, from being turned in to the Immigration and Naturalisation Service (INS).

But does not such an order encourage illegal immigration? asks a member of the audience. Giulliani’s response is that the Federal Government, the Congress and the INS have gotten their priorities wrong. With an estimated 400,000 illegal immigrants in New York, he says, to do anything to discourage this large group from sending their children to school, seeking necessary health care or reporting criminal activity to the police, would be courting disaster for all the residents of the city.

In any event, he says, the INS is so slow to deport illegal immigrants that reporting these people would be a token exercise which would only create additional problems for the City. To underscore this point he notes that there are currently some 5,000 illegal immigrants, who have committed crimes, awaiting deporting.

The INS should concentrate its efforts on deporting these people, he says. Is the Mayor in favour of legal immigration? His answer is an emphatic yes.

“One of the things that immigration does is it gives you a sense of perspective,” he says. “By and large the most patriotic people that we have in our city are the people who are new. I think most of the people who come to America from foreign countries come to America to work.

“They work in higher percentages. They seek welfare in smaller percentages. They are at the core of a lot of the revitalised industries in the city. They are a good example to everybody else.” He notes the view of some anti-immigrant groups that for the foreseeable future the US should admit as immigrants only those who are middle class, highly educated, or wealthy.

“That would be a terrible mistake because one of the things that add to the economy of our country is that poor people who do come, have more desire to work hard and move the whole American dream. It would be a terrible mistake if we deprived ourselves of that human renewal that I think has been critical to the United States.”

And Giulliani is prepared to commit resources to this vision of what immigration can do for the United States and in particular for New York City. One of the major projects of his second term is a 12 million-dollar city agency with six offices to assist immigrants at every stage of the naturalisation process.

Both Freedman and Giulliani cite famous US Presidents as sources of inspiration for their views. Freedman says that when President Franklin D. Roosevelt, in 1938 addressed the ‘Daughters of the American Revolution” as “My fellow immigrants,” he was acknowledging the positive role of immigration in the development of American society.

Giulliani’s source is President Abraham Lincoln, one of the founders of the Republican Party, whose opposition to slavery and often declared opinions in favour of equality, the Mayor says, inform the view of an America for equality for immigrants and non- immigrants alike.

Counter-lobbying efforts have seen Congress amending in some cases, and in others delaying implementation of some of the more egregious aspects of new immigration and welfare legislation. Some sources here attribute this less strident posture on the part of the Republicans to the fact that 1998 is a Congressional election year.

They say that with ever increasing numbers of immigrants becoming naturalised American citizens, there is fear in Republican circles of an electoral backlash, especially in states like Florida where the Hispanic community comprises a significant voting bloc.

Others say public positions taken by persons as influential as Freedman and Giulliani have played no small part in this softening of anti-immigrant positions.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags