Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- U.S. President Bill Clinton meets the leaders of Israel and the Palestinian Authority at the White House this week, but chances are slim for any major breakthrough in the long-stalled Mid East peace process, according to political sources.
Clinton will greet Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Tuesday and then Palestinian President Yasser Arafat on Thursday.
Clinton had hoped the Israeli leader would come prepared to offer a sizable withdrawal from the West Bank and a “time-out” on Israeli settlement activity, but appears doomed to disappointment.
Netanyahu, who finds himself more beholden to hardliners in his depleted Likud coalition as a result of recent defections, is bringing a plan that is so hedged with conditions as to constitute “a virtual non-starter,” in the words of one senior U.S. official.
“This will be a damage-limitation exercise,” says Geoffrey Kemp, a Middle East affairs expert at the Nixon Center for Peace and Freedom.
Other analysts believe Netanyahu may offer a package that would include a modest Israeli pullback and approval for a new industrial centre and an airport in Gaza, as well as several other projects long sought by Arafat, in exchange for Palestinian agreement to go straight to “final status” talks without another Israeli withdrawal, now scheduled for mid-1998.
“This would be a face-saving agreement,” says Mark Rosenblum, president of Americans for Peace Now, who adds Arafat may accept it if he believes the Israeli Labour Party as little chance of taking power over the next year or so. “The question of what happens next week depends very much on Arafat’s assessment of Netanyahu’s political standing.”
Nonetheless, officials are busy lowering expectations for any significant progress to emerge in Washington. They will be helped in that effort by the current preoccupation with the financial crisis in Asia and the latest standoff over weapons inspections between the U.N. Security Council and Iraqi President Saddam Hussein.
Ironically, it was the previous crisis with Iraq, which began in November, which persuaded Washington that the deadlock in the peace process had greatly damaged U.S. standing in the Arab world and undermined its position in the face-off against Saddam.
That assessment prompted the administration to distance itself from Netanyahu, dramatised by Clinton’s decision not to meet with the Israeli leader when he visited here in late November, and stress the need for “bold decisions” and “new urgency” to put the peace process back on track.
So far, Netanyahu has been unresponsive, spurning a deadline set by Secretary of State Madeleine Albright to produce a plan for a “significant and credible” Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank by Dec. 17, and defying the administration’s call for a “time- out” in new settlement construction in the occupied territory.
Likud’s internal political crisis has made it even more difficult for the Israeli premier to make significant compromises next week, even if he wished to do so, analysts believe..
Earlier this month Foreign Minister David Levy, a relative moderate on peace issues, abruptly resigned, reducing Likud’s majority in the Israeli Knesset only 61-59. While Levy’s departure raised questions about the possibility of new elections or the formation of a national unity government with Labour, it also strengthened the influence in the cabinet of anti-Palestinian hawks, such as Infrastructure Minister Ariel Sharon.
In a series of subsequent meetings, Netanyahu’s cabinet formulated the hardline stance he is bringing to Washington. It provides that the next withdrawal of Israeli troops from the West Bank — which was supposed to have taken place last Fall — will be conditional on the Palestinians redressing some 50 “violations” of past agreements by, for example, halving the size of their police force, extraditing three dozen prisoners to Israel, and amending much of their National Covenant.
At the same time, the Israeli Cabinet said that, in any final settlement, it would demand Israeli control of buffer zones on either side of the Wet Bank, Jewish settlements, bypass roads, and the area around Jerusalem — all of which would amount to just about 60 percent of the territory.
Predictably, the Palestinians rejected these conditions and urged Clinton to reject them as well. The Administration should “stand up and tell Netanyahu, ‘Enough,’ because otherwise all that will left of the peace process is memories,” said Saeb Erekat, Arafat’s chief negotiator.
One possibility, according to some observers, is that the U.S. administration will present its own plan. It would include a substantial Israeli withdrawal, a freeze on settlement construction, and the implementation of joint security plans already worked out between Israeli and Palestinian security forces with the help of the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency.
“Although we have seen Clinton shy away for so long from any confrontation with Israel, I don’t think his coming forward with an ‘American Plan’ is outside the realm of possibility,” says Jerome Segal of the Jewish Peace Lobby here.
Given his own political weakness, notes Segal, Netanyahu will find such a plan difficult to reject, particularly if it is coupled with a U.S. threat to walk away from negotiations if it is not accepted.”It’s got to be a great, great worry for (Netanyahu),” says Segal, who adds that he thinks such a step is “possible but not highly likely.”
Kemp, who directed Mid East affairs in the National Security Council under Ronald Reagan, is also sceptical about Clinton’s willingness to take such a decisive stand, particularly with the Israeli political situation so fluid at the moment.
“Privately, the administration would love to see a change of government,” he said, “but most of all, they want to see a strong government because, as we’ve seen in the past, only a strong government in Israel can deliver peace.”
Jim Lobe
- U.S. President Bill Clinton meets the leaders of Israel and the Palestinian Authority at the White House this week, but chances are slim for any major breakthrough in the long-stalled Mid East peace process, according to political sources.
(more…)