Saturday, November 21, 2026
Johanna Son
- South-east Asia stands tall in its handling of the Indochinese refugee crisis of two decades ago, but parts of Asia today continue to be troubled by the displacement of people due to war.
From Afghanistan to Burma, Sri Lanka and Cambodia, where political tensions are simmering once again, Asia is far from solving its refugee problems.
That, experts and activists say, is why the region should not become complacent and must work to strengthen its national and international mechanisms for handling and protecting refugees.
“Strengthening the refugee protection regime in Asia is the first priority,” United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees Sadako Ogata said Wednesday, after receiving her award from the Manila-based Ramon Magsaysay Foundation.
Ogata is the 1997 awardee for international understanding by the foundation, whose recognition is often called Asia’s version of the Nobel prizes.
“The principle of asylum, even temporary, should be reaffirmed in the region since on too many occasions refugees are prevented from seeking safety, are detained or forcibly returned,” she said.
Ogata called on several Asian countries to overcome their reluctance to sign a 1951 convention spelling out standards on the protection and treatment of refugees, and its 1967 protocol.
Japan, South Korea, China, Cambodia, the Philippines, Papua New Guinea, Australia and New Zealand are signatories, but “the Indian subcontinent and most ASEAN (Association of the South-east Asian Nations) have not yet done so”, she explained.
Yet it is Asia, whose cooperation in the Indochinese crisis holds lessons for other conflict-torn parts of the world, that has gained “considerable experience in the determination of refugee status”, she said.
South-east Asia is at peace and enjoys growing affluence. But “if we wish to prevent humanitarian crises in the future, we must pay due attention to the lessons learned”, Ogata explained.
Steven Muncy, executive director of Community and Family Services International, says Asia learned from the Indochinese refugee crisis when its attitude turned from “fear to 10 years of burden-sharing, to cooperation” in handling the human tide.
More than a million people from Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos fled their homelands after communist victories in the region in the mid- seventies, escaping in rickety boats to the shores of neighbouring South-east Asian countries. Subsequently, some countries began pushing off overloaded boats to discourage arrivals by ‘boat people’.
But they agreed at an international conference in 1979 to serve as countries of first asylum and some put up refugee camps. In 1989 a second conference produced a Comprehensive Plan of Action (CPA) that recognised that most of the people fleeing Indochina were no longer political refugees but economic migrants escaping poverty, and thus moved to screen new arrivals.
The programme ended in 1996 and nearly all refugee centres have been shut down. “Much has been done, but much more needs to be done,” Muncy said at the discussion after Ogata’s remarks.
Today, the UNHCR office has programmes to assist 7.9 million refugees, returnees and internally displaced people in Asia. That figure is just a little below Africa’s 8.09 million refugees. In total, it attends to nearly 23 million refugees and uprooted people worldwide.
Afghanistan, plagued by civil conflict, has 1.2 million refugees in Pakistan and 1.4 million in Iran. Burmese Muslims have fled into Bangladesh and are being repatriated. Sri Lanka continues to be wracked by a separatist insurgency.
Efforts are underway to have nearly 1,600 Vietnamese asylum seekers in the Philippines, who have been found ineligible for resettlement in the west, return voluntarily to Vietnam.
Indochina has quietened down in recent years as its countries have mended fences with other South-east Asian nations, but Ogata says the situation remains “fragile”.
“The refugee issue in Indochina is virtually over, though we can’t say it’s over for good,” she said. After Cambodian co- premier Hun Sen ousted his fellow prime minister Prince Norodom Ranariddh in 1997, some 60,000 Cambodians fled across the border to Thailand to escape fighting.
The continued possibility of conflict, and the need for states to take greater responsibility for their refugee citizens, is why Asian governments should be urged to become “more responsible and sensitive to basic human rights of people” and to be the needed legal mechanisms in place.
In fact, Asia’s experience with CPA may come in handy in other refugee situations today, at a time when there is a growing mixture of people fleeing persecution and war, and those seeking better lives by using the window of political asylum.
This was evident in the exodus of Indochinese during the eighties. Ogata conceded the CPA could be a “model” for other countries and regions that are faced with an influx of asylum seekers that may include economic migrants — and thus need to distinguish between the two types.
This week, the Italian government said it would apply humanitarian criteria in dealing with groups of Kurds who arrived in the country recently, and have them go through an asylum- screening procedure. The UNHCR has welcomed Italy’s policy.
In the end, Ogata said the more essential solution to the refugee issues lies in tackling the root conflicts that send people fleeing, either within countries or to other nations. “No international committee can replace good governments,” she added.
Ogata sought a more active strategy for preventing and dealing with humanitarian crises on a regional level, calling the CPA an example of a region-led initiative that worked. Likewise, many movements of people are taking place within than among regions.
Narcisa Escaler, deputy director general of the International Organisation of Migration, says that when refugee crises break out, humanitarian action can “help states fulfill their responsibilities to people within their jurisdiction — but it cannot replace them”.