Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

RIGHTS: Chiapas Provides Test Case for Indigenous Autonomy

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, Jan 26 1998 (IPS) - The demand for autonomy by indigenous people all over the world, and international debate on the subject for the past 10 years, form the key elements in the current conflict in the southern Mexican state of Chiapas.

While the government here questions the way in which indigenous rights are being interpreted, and warns about the “Balkanization” of the country, in Chiapas dozens of communities – most of them sympathetic to the Zapatista guerrillas – have been exercising their rights for some time.

Local indigenous officials issue public documents which are acknowledged only within the community, justice is administered under customary law, decisions are made by consensus in assemblies and government officials must ask for permission before they are allowed into indigenous areas.

This obviously aroused the enmity of some government officials and representatives of autonomous communities were among the victims massacre of Indians last month that has been linked to groups of the Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI), belonged to autonomous communities.

After the Dec. 27 massacre, the issue of territorial and legal autonomy of ethnic groups became front-page news once again. It is over this issue that the peace talks between the government of President Ernesto Zedillo and the Zapatista guerrillas has remained stalled since 1996.

Two years ago, official delegates signed an agreement with the armed group which guarantees levels of autonomy for the ethnic groups. However, when the document was translated by negotiators in the Congress into a draft proposal for constitutional reform, the government vetoed it.

As in other parts of the world, government authorities, jurists, politicians and all types of social science professionals are discussing the validity and scope of indigenous autonomy. Some fear a division of the country, while others argue that it is a right intrinsic to all peoples with different cultures. In 1989, the International Labor Organization approved Convention 169, which guarantees the right to culture and territory of all indigenous groups.

Ratified by 10 countries, including Mexico, the Convention is today one of the documents used by indigenous organizations throughout the continent to support their demands for autonomy for their communities. In addition, it serves as a framework for the discussions begun in 1986 at the United Nations Organization aimed at producing a universal declaration on the rights of indigenous peoples.

Experts like Jose de Val, director of the Inter-American Indigenous Institute of the Organization of American States, believes that is improbable that the declaration will actually be issued, as the issue of self-determination always causes reticence among governments.

In Mexico, where the indigenous population is estimated in 12 million, the Zedillo government argues that indigenous peoples are not different.

“Indigenous peoples should have exactly the same rights as all Mexicans, and it would be a mistake to think that their problems will be resolved by establishing a distinction in our Constitution, treating them as if they weren’t equal,” Zedillo has stated.

Supported by opposition parties, part of civil society and several intellectuals, the commanders of the Zapatista guerrillas have accused the government of ignoring the signed agreement.

The government responds that this is false, and that its only interest is to redefine the issue of autonomy in order to prevent the division of the country. While both sides trade accusations, dozens of communities in Chiapas are exercising their autonomy effectively, despite the massive presence of the army and the constant threat of paramilitary groups.

In the autonomous municipalities, such as Ernesto Che Guevara, United by Our Strength and Land, and Freedom, no one can enter without identification.

In Chiapas, these manifestations of autonomy are remarkable, as they occur in the context of the tensions between the guerrillas and the government. However, in many other indigenous communities throughout the country, it is being exercised de facto without being questioned by any authority, according to opposition politicians.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags