Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

POPULATION-BARBADOS: When AIDS is Used as a Murder Weapon

Cara Mason

BRIDGETOWN, Feb 4 1998 (IPS) - Twenty-five-year old Monica Lynch says if she has AIDS she will sue.

The mother of a four year old boy is living in fear that she might have contracted the deadly disease from her boyfriend of six months.

It all started when the couple fell in love. For the first four months they used condoms during intercourse. But then he convinced her that there was no need to continue to have protected sex and she should trust him. So in the last two months of their six-month affair, they engaged in unprotected sex.

Outside the bedroom, however, the relationship was failing. He became abusive and demanding, she says. She told him it was over. His parting shot? He told her he was carrying the virus that causes the Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS).

She confirmed the devastating news by telephoning his doctor — a name and number her former boyfriend gladly gave her.

The doctor, however, respecting patient confidentiality, would only tell her that her former boyfriend was his patient. He did, however, advise her to be tested for the virus.

So far, she has tested negative. But the doctor, who requested anonymity, says it is too soon to be absolutely sure she is not infected and another test has to be done.

It will be a few more weeks or months before Lynch (not her real name) knows for sure whether or not she has the virus. But if she is infected, she says she will not take it lying down. She has pledged to sue her former lover for deliberately misleading her and, perhaps, costing her her life.

Police say they could file grievous bodily harm charges against her former boyfriend.

But lawyers say it will be a tough test case to bring before the courts. They say the law is not clear-cut on whether or not criminal charges can be filed. If, indeed, she files a complaint with the police, they would have to prove grievous bodily harm was committed. That is where it gets tricky, lawyers say.

The fact that her boyfriend knew he had the disease and did not inform her before they engaged in unprotected sex would be a key factor in proving intent, officials say. “However, it can still end up being a battle” says one lawyer.

Deputy Director of Public Prosecutions, Olton Springer says at present there is no specific law under which a person can be charged for knowingly infecting another with HIV.

“In order to bring an action in this case it would probably have to be brought under the Offences Against the Person Act and the offender could possibly be charged with causing serious bodily harm to the infected party with intent,” he says.

He noted, however, that such a case would prove very difficult to substantiate given the nature of evidence that the prosecutor would have to present to the court.

“The prosecutor would have to prove that the person knew they were infected and that they knowingly, deliberately, with malice and aforethought infected the complainant or was reckless as to whether the person would be infected as a result of their actions,” he adds.

In addition, Springer says the complainant would also have to prove that he or she was not carrying the virus prior to sexual contact with the infected person.

One lawyer, who requested anonymity given the sensitive nature of the issue, says if the woman tests positive for HIV, she would be better off going after the man in a civil suit. There, she could seek monetary damages for intentional harm.

“The fact that her ex-boyfriend knew he was infected and withheld that information from her could be deemed reckless and that makes him liable,” he says.

In a case last summer on the Greek island of Cyprus, a court found a fisherman guilty of knowingly infecting his British partner with the AIDS virus. He faces a maximum of two years in jail and a 2,000-dollar fine.

“A sick person has a legal obligation to avoid any action likely to transmit such a dangerous disease,” said Judge Antonis Liatsos at the time.

His ruling came under a 50-year-old British colonial law dealing with the spread of venereal and other diseases — a law that was dormant until its applicability was tested with this case in the Greek courts.

In Antigua, the Ministry of Health is reportedly investigating reports that at least five infected persons there knowingly spread the disease among predominately teenaged girls.

In Trinidad and Tobago two years ago a Swiss tourist was deported after confessing to having had sexual relations with at least 15 men in one month. Prior to her deportation she told immigration and health officials that she had informed her partners of her condition before engaging in intercourse.

Meanwhile, in Barbados more people are being tested for the HIV virus and the number of tests done for all of 1997 is expected to be twice that of the previous year.

“There is an increase in the number of people seeking to assess their status,” says Chief Medical Officer Dr. Elizabeth Ferdinand.

The number of reported cases of AIDS since 1984, when the disease was first detected here now stands at 820. Of that number 689 have died.

The latest figures show that 90 percent of the individuals contracted the virus through heterosexual contact while only five percent became infected as a result of homosexual or bisexual contact and another five percent in other ways.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags