Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America

DEVELOPMENT: Water Looms as Major Source of Conflict Next Century

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Mar 11 1998 (IPS) - Fresh water is becoming increasingly scarce throughout the world and disputes over access to water supplies could increase dramatically next century, say conflict analysts in Washington.

The problem particularly affects developing countries in such areas as the Okavango River in Southern Africa to the Ganges, running through India and Bangladesh, where urbanisation, rising populations, and economic growth has put unprecedented demand on water supplies and fueled international argument.

The more than one billion people in the world who do not have access to safe drinking water are mostly poor, living in developing countries. As the average amount of water available per person decreases worldwide, defending water resources has become one the most pressing environmental issues to emerge as national- security concerns around the globe, say the experts.

In an attempt to anticipate conflict problems over water rights, economists, members of non-governmental organisations, policy makers, corporate executives, and international bankers and lawyers met at American University’s Washington College of Law to discuss how to avoid such conflicts in developing countries.

More than 85 percent of fresh water in the world is transboundary water – or water that is shared between two or more countries, according to Atif Kubursi, an economics professor who is an expert on water conflicts in the Middle East.

While developing countries were more likely to be dependent on transboundary water than industrialised countries, Ashok Swain, a peace and conflict resolution professor in Sweden, said they were less likely to have international joint commissions manage the shared water resources.

Water problems remained acute in the Middle East, West Asia and parts of Africa, particularly the Sudano-Sahelian belt and Southern Africa, panelists agreed. These locations experience high evaporation rates, high levels of expected future water demands, and potential transboundary water conflicts.

“Water scarcity is at the root of problems in the Middle East,” said Kabursi.

In the Gaza Strip, for example, strict quotas regulating Palestinian water consumption, population pressures, and severe water contamination made water scarcity conflicts inevitable, he said. As matters worsened, the Palestinian authority would find itself incapable of dealing with problems and maintaining peace until a resolution was reached about water problems.

Kabursi emphasized the importance of first defining the property rights of the interested parties before beginning the process of joint management of a water resource – such as a river or aquifer. Most importantly, he said is the concept of an equitable water management system.

“It is not an equitable sustainable system when some countries divert water to make the deserts bloom while other are dying of thirst.”

He argued that a water pricing system that reflected the water scarcity problems would spark conservation efforts. As water has become more expensive in Singapore, there has been an increase in water-saving devices such as low-flow toilets and efficient washing machines.

Laurence Boisson de Chazournes, the senior counsel for the World Bank’s Environment and International Law Unit also discussed the possibility of trading oil and gas for water.

In other regions, there is peace in times of good rains and dispute in times of drought.

In Southern India, two Southern Indian states, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu share and depend on the Cauvery River. Failed monsoons in 1995 and 1996 ignited old debates between the two states and intensified when many farmers in the area were displaced. As crops withered tempers became inflamed and threats of violence transformed into aggressive protests which ended in some deaths, according to panelists at the conference.

Who owns which sources of water can be argued in many regions and experts expressed concern over the relationship between food security and water resources. “The relationship between water and food is the crux of the water problem,” said Sharif Elmusa, a senior researcher with the Washington-based Institute of Palestine Studies.

Most of the world’s water still goes for irrigation. The expanding demand for water is beyond the sustainable yield of aquifers in many countries, and draining some of the world’s major rivers dry before they reach the sea, according to Lester Brown, president and founder of the Washington-based World Watch Institute, an environmental think-tank.

“As the demand for water for irrigation and for industrial and residential uses continues to expand, the competition between countryside and city for available water supplies intensifies,” he says. “In some parts of the world, meeting growing urban needs is possible only by diverting water from irrigation.”

In Southern Africa, for example, Namibia wants water from the Okavango River for its cities, but people in neighboring Botswana fear that will not leave enough for communities in the their delta wetlands – a prime source of tourist revenue.

The increasing role played by the private sector in management of the natural resource is further complicating water disputes, said panelists at the conference.

Benefits of privatising water management systems that were once run by governments include an increased rate of efficiency and higher standards of service, said Scott Mcleod, a manager with the International Fiance Corporation, the private lending arm of the World Bank. He added that corporations are better able to mobilize funds for capital investment and also eliminate budgetary burdens that limit government spending on such management systems.

But Mcleod admitted that progress had been limited due to lack of competition and declared a “handful of French and British firms and their subsidiaries dominate the world’s private water management systems.”

Even if there was no monopoly, there were those who still had doubts on the benefits of privatisation. While acknowledging that the governments in the past have not solved the problem of bringing water to the poor and marginalised people of society and that corporation do bring certain advantages, others are cautious in embracing privatisation.

“How can corporations – who are essentially focused on profits – ensure that their efforts will spark water conservation and bring this much needed natural resource to the poor,” said David Hunter, Vice President of the Washington-based Center for International Environmental Law.

“There is nothing inherent in privatisation that would solve the main problem of conserving this precious natural resource and ensuring that the poor gain access to water, especially when the regulatory agencies of many developing countries lack experienced staff and resources.”

Hunter, and other participants, wondered how privatisation would bring water to the millions of poor landless people in Brazil or Manila, for example, who do not officially own the land they are living or farming on.

“If the government won’t let corporations hook up water pipes or wells on land occupied by landless peasants because they don’t want to give them a claim to the land, how could privatisation ensure universal access to much needed water for the poorest of the poor in developing countries,” said Hunter.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags