Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Climate Treaty Won’t Hurt U.S. Economy

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Mar 5 1998 (IPS) - Senior White House economic advisers, ignoring the outcry from industry over any implementation of international global warming treaty, have declared it would have only a “modest” impact on the U.S. economy.

“Our overall conclusion is that the economic impact of the Protocol will be modest,” says Janet Yellen who chairs the Council of Economic Advisers to President Bill Clinton. “We can work to avert the grave dangers of climate change, while at the same time maintaining the strength of the economy.”

Yellen testified Wednesday before the House Commerce Committee, the first official economic analysis of the historic agreement to fight global warming signed by 159 nations in Kyoto, Japan in December. The treaty calls for reducing “greenhouse gas” emissions, which are produced mostly from burning fossil fuels such as oil, by an average of five percent below what they were in 1990.

If left unchecked, the gases could trigger changes in the atmosphere, a significant rise in world sea levels, and more unpredictable and possibly violent weather patterns, according to most scientists.

The accord has been strongly criticized by most industries and members of Congress who believe it could cripple the U.S. economy.

Critics say the Kyoto treaty requires the United States, one of the largest emitters of greenhouse gases, to make greater sacrifices than other countries – especially developing countries. As a result, the Clinton administration has agreed not to submit the agreement to Congress for approval until it wins participation by developing countries.

The administration admits that implementing the Kyoto protocol in the United States would cause some sectors to expand and others to contract. But, while stressing its preference for market-based policies to avert climate change – such as the use of tradable emission permits – the White House contends that the agreement would not harm the economy overall.

Yellen forecasts that the agreement would result in, at most, modest price hikes for gasoline and other fuels as the United States plays its part in cutting greenhouse gas emissions. Those increases, however, could be offset completely by lower electricity bills if Congress passes laws to allow utility companies to compete by trading emissions permits.

Yellen acknowledged in her testimony that determining the economic impact of the agreement through the use of economic models is a complex imperfect process. But she projects a net increase in national annual energy costs of between 7-12 billion dollars by the year 2012 – the deadline set in Kyoto for industrialised countries to achieve sharp cuts in emissions.

For U.S. consumers, that could increase gasoline prices by four to six cents a gallon, as well as comparable increases of three to five percent for electricity, fuel oil and natural gas, according to White House experts.

Industry officials believe price hikes will be much higher (up to one dollar more per gallon) and maintain it would be disastrous for the economy and unfair to consumers. Still, most U.S. motorists say they are willing to pay more for gasoline and other oil products to reduce global warming, according to a survey by the Pew Research Center for People and the Press.

In a phone survey, 73 percent of 1200 respondents said they would be willing to pay about five cents more per gallon of gas for their automobiles, and 60 percent said they would be willing to pay as much as 25 cents more per gallon. One gallon – about four litres – of gasoline at the pump currently costs around USD 1.30.

Last month the administration’s economic advisers also concluded that there is little evidence to support treaty opponents who say the Kyoto agreement would drive U.S. industry overseas. They reason that energy costs, which would be affected by the deal, generally comprise a small fraction of total manufacturing expenses.

A handful of economists, strongly backed by industry, have been critical of the Kyoto accord and dispute the White House projections.

“It strikes me that the increase in prices are impossibly low,” said David Montgomery, vice president of Charles River Associates, a conservative economic consulting firm. He said the administration’s predictions “shows a great deal of optimism” on what it can accomplish in negotiations with developing countries over the next few years.

Industry has been trying to thwart the Kyoto agreement on the basis that reducing greenhouse gas emissions would harm the economy. Before negotiations began in Japan, a coalition of oil, coal, and gas industries launched a 13 million dollar mass media campaign against the treaty – charging that it was economically unfair to the United States.

Meanwhile, most economists have called for international control to prevent global warming. More than 2,000 economists, including several Nobel Prize laureates, asserted in 1997 that such controls would not be harmful to the economy and “may in fact improve” economic activity. They say measures which slow climate change would be economically sound because the potential costs of inaction would be too great.

The reason for the discrepancies between economists is because industry-backed analysts wrongly have assumed worst case scenarios and incorporated them into their economic models, say senior economists at the World Resources Institute, a Washington think tank.

“The economic debate has turned into a war of the economic models,” according to Robert Repetto, a senior economist with the Institute. “However, we need to be careful about jumping to conclusions before the assumptions behind the models used in determining the economic impact of climate changes policy are carefully examined.”

If, for example, the economic model assumes that reductions in fossil fuel consumption will lessen environmental damages and decrease air pollution, then the economic outcome is more optimistic. If the model assumes that non-fossil fuel energy alternatives will not become available in the future at a competitive price, the economic prediction will become more pessimistic.

The economic model used by the White House is “pretty middle of the road,” says Duncan Austin, another senior economist with World Resources Institute.

It assumes that the economy will respond efficiently to reducing carbon emissions and that countries – including developing countries – will work together toward implementing the Kyoto protocol by trading emission permits.

“This is optimistic and encouraging,” says Austin, “but if the treaty faces any obstructions from developing countries or Congress on the assumptions built into the White House’s economic model, prices in the United States could be expected to rise.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags