Friday, November 20, 2026
Anil Netto
- Malaysia is standing firm on its decision to shut its doors on illegal immigrants and human rights activists are raising questions about how some of them have been treated at holding camps and hastily deported.
The Malaysian government says all those being deported are illegal immigrants, many of them Indonesians crossing the Strait of Malacca aboard boats to flee the economic woes of home.
In the wake of bloody riots that broke out at the detention Semenyih detention camp Thursday, officials say deportations will continue in order to discourage more illegals from trying to find work in Malaysia. The deportations, a massive sea and air operation in the Malacca Strait and round-ups of illegals in the country are signs of a clampdown on foreign workers and illegal immigrants by Malaysia, itself faced with growing unemployment and dislocation due to a crippling economic crisis.
It also underlines how the economic dislocation underway in South-east Asia is spilling over national borders and may well strain otherwise neighbourly ties.
Inspector General of Police Abdul Rahim Noor said all illegal immigrants held at detention camps here, estimated at 9,000, would be sent back by Sunday. “We will proceed with our deportation plans to ensure that camps are not overcrowded and also to prevent the camps from being put in any critical situation,” he said.
In the government’s zeal to close its borders and ship home illegals, however, activists say the rights of some groups may have been violated. For instance, the activist group Aliran said that 290 Acehnese refugees were believed to be at the Semenyih detention camp some 40 km from the capital Kuala Lumpur. That was where hundreds of Indonesians, hours before they were to be deported on Mar. 26, rioted in disturbances that led to the death of eight immigrants and a Malaysian policeman.
Aliran said the most of those people from Aceh in northern Sumatra had fled to Malaysia many years ago, in search of political sanctuary when conflict between the Indonesian military and separatist fighters erupted in Aceh province in the early 1990s.
“These Acehnese are refugees who have sought political asylum in Malaysia. They are not illegal immigrants,” said Aliran secretary Dr Francis Loh.
Unlike illegal Indonesian immigrants who are now being rounded up and deported to Indonesia, the Acehnese face real danger to their lives upon their return, he said. “They risk imprisonment, torture and perhaps execution for their past political activities,” Loh added.
The United Nations has also expressed concern over conditions in detention camps since the riots. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees has requested access to the Semenyih camp. Human Rights Watch Asia has also asked Malaysia to stop deporting Indonesians and to hand over the camps to the UNHCR.
But Malaysian Foreign Minister Abdullah Badawi said: “There is no need for us to hand over the detention camps to the UNHCR as we are not repatriating refugees.”
He said these illegal immigrants were not in the same category as the Vietnamese ‘boat people’ of the 1970s who were fleeing war and political persecution – and many of whom Malaysia had hosted as a first asylum camp. Thus, Malaysia would not stop repatriating illegals since they are not refugees, he added. “They did not enter our country seeking asylum but came in illegally to seek employment.”
Human rights workers say they are worried by other aspects of the government’s crackdown on illegal workers, including the use of the Internal Security Act (ISA) against those suspected to have connived with illegal immigration syndicates or helped illegal workers enter Malaysia.
To them, the ISA’s role in the crackdown shows how the unjust law should be scrapped. Several Malaysians have already been detailed without trial for “harbouring, protecting and abetting in bringing illegals” from Indonesia. Some officials have even suggested that illegal immigrants be whipped.
“We reiterate our utmost opposition to flogging as a form of punishment,” said Elizabeth Wong, coordinator of the human rights group Suaram.
Malaysia’s enforcement of a tough policy against illegal workers shows how its treatment of foreign workers has changed in just a matter of months given the country’s economic downturn.
There are 2 to 3 million foreign workers in Malaysia, of which only 1.2 million are registered as legal. Of the legal workers, about 750,000 are Indonesians and 300,000 are Bangladeshis, the rest being mainly Filipinos, Thais and Pakistanis. More than 30 percent work in factories, 27 percent in plantations, 20 percent in construction and 12 percent as domestic workers.
The economic slowdown, however, has led to many lay-offs in the construction and services sectors. Some 200,000 workers in these sectors will be sent home when their work permits exercise expire in the middle of the year. The government will repatriate these workers, many of whom were legalised during an amnesty programme last year, beginning Aug. 15.
Though illegal workers have for years toiled on Malaysian construction sites and plantations, officials closed their eyes because they provided needed labour to keep the economy going at a time when locals shunned such jobs. Now these workers have become unwanted baggage that, Malaysian officials say, must be dealt with swiftly for fear of causing social tensions, taxing social services and seeing rising crime rates.
The government has also been coming down hard on groups like foreign workers suffering from sexually transmitted diseases and infectious illnesses like hepatitis and tuberculosis. In Penang, the state immigration department said it will be deporting 70 such workers. The department is also carrying out raids to nab foreign domestic workers here illegally.
Meantime, officials are bracing themselves for another exodus from Indonesia in April, when another round of price hikes is expected with the lifting of more price subsidies.
In February alone, police intercepted more than 300 boat landings and nearly 4,000 illegal immigrants from Indonesia. Many of them landed on the Malaysian coastline along the peninsula’s west coast states of Selangor, Negri Sembilan and Johor.
Needless to say, the tide of illegal immigrants threatens to strain ties with Indonesia. “ASEAN (Association of South-east Asian Nations) can no longer say that the affairs of its neighbours are internal affairs, especially since the Indonesian crisis has clearly affected the other countries in the region,” Wong said.