Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, North America

SCIENCE-RIGHTS: New Seed Technology Threatens Farmers

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Mar 31 1998 (IPS) - New agro-technology that genetically- disables a seed’s capacity to germinate could threaten the livlihood of traditional farmers, mainly in developing countries, say researchers.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and a large American cotton seed company, have patented a jointly-developed technique that enables seed companies to switch a plant’s reproductive processes on and off. This means that if farmers attempt to replant harvested seed, it would be sterile.

Now the concern among farmers is that they will have to spend much more of their money to make annual seed purchases instead of saving seed and depending upon their own plant breeding skills as they have done for centuries.

“It’s terribly dangerous,” says Hope Shand, research director of the North-American based Rural Advancement Foundation International (RAFI). “Half the world’s farmers are poor and depend upon saved seed and their own breeding skills because they can’t afford to buy seed every growing season. Yet, poor farmers grow 15 to 20 percent of the world’s food and they directly feed at least 1.4 billion people – 100 million in Latin America, 300 million in Africa, and one billion in Asia.

“It is a crime that U.S. tax payer’s money went towards developing this new technology.”

Mississippi-based Delta and Pine Land, the largest cotton seed corporation in the United States, argues that this new technology – which may be applicable to all crops in the future – will lead to more research on staple foods grown in developing countries that have been difficult to turn into hybrid seeds, such as rice and wheat.

“The patent has the prospect of opening significant worldwide seed markets to (biologically engineered) crops, in which seed currently is saved and used in the next season,” according to a statement by Delta and Pine Land.

Currently, private companies are discouraged from investing in crops that are not easily ‘hybridised’, such as wheat and rice. Hybrid seeds, such as corn, are attractive to corporations because they yield a higher profit as they do not reproduce themselves and farmers have to buy new supplies every year.

While farmers have been unable to save hybrid seeds, they have continued to save seeds from traditional non-hybridised crops. But that may all change with this new patented technology.

Crops that are difficult to hybridise – generally ignored by multinational seed corporations because of the low profit potential – now may get more attention.

So far, only tobacco seeds have responded to the new technique, but Delta and Pine Land plans to apply this technology to rice, wheat, sorghum and soybeans after the year 2000, primarily targeting markets in developing countries.

USDA spokesman Michael Ruff acknowledges the downside for farmers as they may be forced to pay more for seed stocks every year but says it is too early to tell if this new technology will be positive or negative for farmers. “It’s really all speculation,” he told IPS. “Until further research is done, we really won’t know if this new technology can even be applied to other crops.”

But he admits that, if the new technique can be applied to crops such as wheat and rice, private companies will be encouraged to invest in crops typically unable to hybridise, so that they could make higher profits on crops that must be purchased each year.

Delta and Pine Land maintain that the new research interest in the “forgotten” crops will lead to a choice of more higher- yielding plant varieties for farmers and, therefore, result in greater global food security. But farmers and seed researchers have strong doubts about this “miracle” technology.

“This is the neutron bomb of agriculture,” says Camila Montecinos, an agronomist with the Chilean-based Center for Education and Technology, who is calling for a global boycott of the new technology. “This is an immoral technique that robs farming communities of their age-old right to save seed and their role as plant breeders.”

Non-governmental organisations fear that public sector plant breeders wanting access to patented seeds will be forced to adopt the new technology as a licensing requirement, for example. As better off farmers would be forced to pay for the new seed technology, their poorer neighbours would no longer be able to exchange breeding material with their fellow farmers, as has been done traditionally.

Neth Dano, director of the Philippines-based SEARICE, an organisation that works with farmers in South-east Asia, says poor farmers traditionally select the best seeds every year by crossing commercial varieties with other rice strains and over time this locally-adapted rice molds itself to the farm’s distinct ecosystem.

“This new technology could put an end to all this and increase crop uniformity and vulnerability. Far from improving plant breeding, the new technology could drive hundreds of millions of farmers out of plant breeding and, since no one else will breed for their needs, out of agriculture altogether,” she says.

Researchers also worry that even if farmers do not buy the new seed, if nearby fields are planted with this new seed technology they could find that the following season some of their seeds will be sterile, adds Montecinos.

“Crops geneticists who have studied the patent say it is likely that pollen from crops carrying the new trait will infect the fields of farmers who either reject or can’t afford the technology. When farmers reach into their bins to sow seed the following season they could discover – too late – that some of their seed is sterile.”

If true, she says, this could lead to huge losses in crop yields and irregular harvests for several years and a general decline in food security for the poorest farm communities.

“Governments should make this technology illegal,” she adds.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags