Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-FINANCE: NGOs Seek Global Environmental Standards

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Apr 24 1998 (IPS) - Non-governmental Organisations (NGOs) are calling for world-wide agreement on common environmental standards for government-supported export finance agencies – support more than 400 billion dollars of foreign investments and exports.

These agencies provide domestic companies with loans, insurance, and other financial assistance in order to promote investments overseas. But, because many of these export-import banks and investment insurance agencies – located mostly in industrialised countries – lack environmental or social guidelines, they have become involved in destructive projects in developing countries, say the NGOs. The projects include the Three Gorges Dam in China and the Grasberg Mine in New Guinea.

“More than 70 billion dollars a year (from these agencies) goes to projects in developing countries that often have significant adverse environmental and social impacts,” says a statement by more than 140 non-governmental organisations from 42 countries.

The NGOs call to action went out Friday to finance ministers of the world’s wealthiest countries who will be participating in the annual ministerial meeting for the Organisation of Economic Cooperation and Development held in Paris, April 27 and 28.

Environmental groups, including Friends of the Earth in Brazil and Japan, the Cameroon-based Center for Environment and Development and the Washington-based Environmental Defense Fund, also criticise the agencies for not making public, details of the projects they support.

“The public wants to know what their agencies are funding,” Doug Norlen, a policy analyst at the Pacific Environment and Resource Center, told IPS. “Once these projects are held up to the light of day, people will demand reforms for these agencies. Transparency is key.”

U.S. environmentalists already have helped improve environmental standards of the U.S. Export-Import Bank and the Overseas private Investment Corporation (OPIC).

After prompting by environmental groups, President Bill Clinton recently promoted new guidelines that forbade that agency from backing large dams, projects in national parks or protected areas, and projects in primary tropical forests. The standards also required it to track and report on greenhouse gas emissions from the power projects it supports.

Even before the new standards, pressure from environmentalists in 1995 caused the investment agency to cancel a 100 million dollars political risk insurance policy it was providing to a New Orleans-based mining company, Freeport McMoRan Copper and Gold, on the grounds that the project was associated with human rights and ecological abuses.

The insurance policy – which was reinstated and then dropped by Freeport – covered the company’s operations at the Grasberg Mine – one of the world’s largest – in the Indonesian province of Irian Jaya. Environmentalists say the mine continues to dump 120,000 metric tons of toxic waste into the rivers in the tropical rainforests.

The environmental guidelines of the U.S. Export-Import Bank similarly prohibited the bank from providing support for China’s Three Gorges Dam project. Environmental and social guidelines for World Bank supported projects also prohibited funding for Three Gorges, on the grounds that it would flood large areas and displace more than a million people.

Other export agencies, however, in Canada, France, Germany, Japan, and Switzerland – which are not constrained by environmental policies – have shown interest in the Three Gorges project. The German Hermes Guarantee organisation, for example, approved 800 million dollars in loan guarantees for the project.

Therefore, any agency that attempts to set social and environmental standards is penalized as other countries’ companies are enabled to invest in projects, say the NGOs.

Because of OPIC’s and the U.S. Export-Import Bank’s guidelines U.S. corporations are at a competitive disadvantage. US-based Caterpillar Inc., for example, who would have benefited from U.S. Export-Import Bank loans to China to purchase Caterpillar earthmoving equipment for the Three Gorges Dam, lobbied congress to scrap the Bank’s environmental guidelines.

In order to eliminate this competitive disadvantage to U.S. corporations while keeping environmental guidelines, organisations and some industries are calling for all G-7 and OECD countries – which include Japan, the European Union, and the United States – to adopt common environmental standards for all nations’ export finance agencies.

Groups also say common standards would eliminate “double standards.” Currently, taxpayers in Europe are supporting international financial institutions, such as the World Bank that has environmental guidelines, while they also support export credit agencies which promote environmentally unsound projects and investments, says Bruce Rich, senior attorney with the Environmental Defense Fund.

“The lack of minimal standards of transparency, and of (common) environmental and social policies for publicly supported export credit and investment insurance agencies has resulted in a double standard,”adds a statement by the NGOs. “These agencies are supporting projects and investments that would be unacceptable to publicly- financed multilateral development banks and bilateral aid agencies.”

Levelling the playing field on environmental guidelines, however, has been an up-hill battle.

Finance ministers from Germany have been opposed to setting common standards through the OECD saying it would restrict their right to independently decide on investments based on their own guidelines. And the French ministers have said they do not want to examine environmental concerns in evaluating export credits.

In response, U.S. environmental groups and powerful industry and trade groups, including the National Association of Manufacturers and the National Foreign Trade Council, have acknowledged their common interest on this issue and are considering urging U.S. officials to prioritize common standards at this year’s G7 Summit this May in Birmingham, United Kingdom.

“Although we still have an enormous task ahead,” says the Environmental Defense Fund’s Rich, “we have catalyzed the first steps toward common global environmental standards. Achieving our goal could influence hundreds of billions of dollars a year in private investments around the world.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags