Saturday, November 21, 2026
Deborah Horan
- It’s 1956. Israel border police enforcing a curfew in the Arab village of Kufr Kassem, north of Tel Aviv, stop trucks full of workers coming back from the fields. The passengers are forced out, lined up on the side of the road — and shot.
When they have finished, 50 Arab men, women and teenagers lay dead.
Next, the scene switches to the trial of the policemen involved in the massacre. The viewer watches a black and white image of the judge ruling on the case of Colonel Isscah Shadmi, the officer accused of ordering the killings.
Shadmi is found guilty — and ordered to pay a symbolic fine of one shekel. Outside the courthouse, smiling colleagues congratulate him.
The event, re-created using footage from a Syrian dramatisation of the massacre and old Israeli newsreels of the subsequent trial, is one of the most searing sequences in Rebirth, a 22-week documentary that has become one of the highest rated shows on Israeli television.
The series, shown on the government-owned Channel One since December, takes a hard look at Israel’s past. And its portrayals of the bad as well as the good have forced many Israelis to confront some of the most sensitive issues facing the nation as they prepare to celebrate 50 years of independence.
“The series is throwing up all kinds of questions that Israelis don’t usually ask themselves and usually try their best to avoid,” said Leslie Susser, a top commentator on Israel’s domestic political scene with the Jerusalem Report, a bi-monthly news magazine.
“In a very provocative way the series is saying is that Israel wasn’t always in the right, that there are two sides to the story and both of them have a certain amount of historical validity,” said Susser. “Therefore it’s causing a certain amount of discomfort.”
Most of all, it has underscored the deep political schism that rends Israeli society today, a schism that some observers here say goes long way toward explaining why few here feel like celebrating the country’s half-century.
“There is a sense either of despair or at least a lack of knowledge about where the country is going,” said Chemi Shalev, a columnist for the Hebrew daily Ma’ariv. “For part of the population, the faltering peace process is responsible for that.
“But among others, there is a sense that the Israeli people are not longer a united people,” he added. “They are a patchwork of people who are not sure they have anything really in common and not sure that they want to be together.”
The shows’ creators say they wanted to present a comprehensive account of Israel’s tumultuous history without glossing over the blemishes.
“Our aim was to present history as it is,” said Gidon Drori, the veteran Israeli director who produced the series. “We used to glorify ourselves and our past. Nowadays, I think that is anachronistic. It doesn’t accomplish anything.”
The series begins with the then illegal immigration of European Holocaust survivors in the years before the state was created in 1948 and ends with the assassination of prime minister Yitzhak Rabin in 1995 by Yigal Amir, an extremist Jew.
The episode entitled ‘The Opsimist’, a play on the words ‘pessimist’ and ‘optimist’ coined by Israeli-Arab writer Emil Habibi to capture the emotional schizophrenia felt by his people, chronicles the often unpleasant experiences of Israel’s Arab minority.
Besides the massacre at Kufr Kassem, the film interviews Mohammed Darwish, an Israeli-Arab poet known for his strong anti-Israeli sentiment.
Others take on sacred glories of the past or expose social problems seething beneath the fabric of Israeli society.
One episode called ‘The Second Israel’ focuses on discrimination against Israel’s Sephardic Jewish minority. Another takes on the myth of David Ben-Gurion, Israel’s first prime minister. Yet another debunks the reported glory of the 1973 Yom Kippur War.
The most controversial one, aired on Apr. 5, is called ‘Biladi Biladi’, a refrain that means “my country, my country” in Arabic and which has been adopted by Palestinians as their national anthem. It chronicles Israel’s fight against the Palestine Liberation Organisation in the 1970s.
Many of the series’ critics objected to the timing of documentaries that open old wounds at a time when they say Israel should be basking its achievements.
“I don’t object to the series,” said Yisrael Harel, a leader of Israel’s settler movement and a columnist for the Hebrew daily newspaper Ha’aretz. “But do we have to do it on the night of the golden wedding celebration?”
Others take it a step further. “The problem with Tkuma is that it is fraud,” said David Bedein, a settler who lives in the West Bank settlement of Efrat and runs a Canadian-funded media organisation called Israel Resource.
“It’s one thing to present a left-wing view (and) some of the great myths need to be exploded,” Bedein said. “But this is fraud”.
Bedein was particularly upset by the inclusion of Darwish in the Opsimist without narration explaining to the viewer that the poet was once an avid supporter of Hitler. He says the film ‘Say Yes to the Old Man’ wrongly suggests that Ben Gurion wanted to move Palestinian refugees to Argentina as a permanent solution to their plight. And he maintains that only men were killed during the Kufr Kassem massacre.
Supporters of the series as well as other observers say that attitude stems from a reluctance to confront a sometimes ugly past.
“There are people who think that the 50th should be marked by the original Zionist myths and not by latter-day knowledge of what went on during the 50 years of the state,” said Shalev.
The show’s creators say they hope the series will generate a healthy debate. They say Israel is strong enough to confront the skeletons of the past. “I think those people who are unable, still unable, to confront history as it was with its unsympathetic aspects do not feel self confident,” says Drori.
Already, the series has been sought after by teachers who want to use it to teach recent Israeli history — a subject so sensitive that it is generally not taught in Israeli schools.
Historian Yigal Eilam, one of five historians who worked on the series, says he hopes the series will lead to a deeper understanding of Israel’s past that can help it confront the future.
“I view the series as a kind of a turning point, not in terms of people changing their minds, but in starting a discussion,” Eilam said. “The whole debate now… will revolve around issues that were put forth in this series… and this is important.”
— The preceding item is part of a series of articles produced by IPS ahead of the 50th anniversary of the founding of the state of Israel, to be commemorated there over several days from April 30.