Friday, November 20, 2026
Abid Aslam
- The International Monetary Fund, scorned by some and saluted by others for policing member states’ economies, is placing itself under surveillance.
Outside experts are to grade the IMF on the way it monitors and guides its members’ macro-economic policies, the Fund said Tuesday. The announcement follows heavy criticism the agency failed to foresee major economic upheavals – including the Asian crisis, which broke one year ago Thursday, when Thailand gave up a long and expensive defence of its beleaguered currency, the baht.
This is the second time in the IMF’s 52-year history that it is opening its operations to external evaluation. The Washington institution has been famously chided by Jeffrey Sachs, director of the Harvard Institute for International Development, as being “more secretive than the CIA,” or U.S. Central Intelligence Agency.
A three-member team is to assess the effectiveness of IMF surveillance of macroeconomic, structural, and financial “weaknesses and imbalances…that are an obstacle to achieving sustainable non-inflationary economic growth and external viability,” according to the Fund.
Leading the team is John Crow, former governor of the Bank of Canada. Other members are Ricardo Arriazu, a professor of macroeconomics and monetary theory at Argentina’s Universidad Catolica, and Niels Thygesen, professor of economics at the University of Copenhagen, Denmark. They are to begin work in July and complete their evaluation by June 1999, according to an IMF statement.
Markets and member states alike assailed the IMF for failing to anticipate the Mexican peso crisis of 1994-95 as well as Asia’s now year-long financial crisis.
IMF officials insisted they had warned the Thai government of impending disaster early in 1997 and faulted Bangkok for not heeding their advice. However, the agency betrayed no concern about the state of Thai economic policy-making in public statements and surveillance reports released mere weeks before the baht’s July collapse began to reverberate throughout the region.
In the past year, the Fund has admitted to underestimating the severity of Asia’s woes and their effect on other regions, and also has been off the mark in predicting which countries would be hardest hit.
Last December, for example, it expected Thailand to fare worst in 1998. It projected zero economic growth there and growth of two percent in Indonesia and 2.5 percent in South Korea. By April, it said Indonesia actually would suffer a decline of five percent, followed by 3.1 percent in Thailand and 0.8 percent in South Korea. This month, as analysts tallied the economic cost of Indonesia’s political turmoil, the officials here said the country’s economy likely would slide by more than ten percent.
Projections of global growth – actually upgraded even as Asian economies were in free-fall last October – also have been revised downward.
The agency released in March summary findings of its first external evaluation, which focussed on the Enhanced Structural Adjustment Facility (ESAF), through which concessional loans are made to the poorest countries so their governments can make debt repayments while following the Fund’s instructions for economic restructuring.
A team led by former Ghanaian finance minister Kwesi Botchwey found that the Fund’s approach to restructuring – often described by critics and observers alike as ‘one size fits all’ – has been blind to specific borrowing countries’ needs and the plight of the poor. Recommendations included offering governments a choice between standard structural adjustment programmes and “alternative paths,” Botchwey said.
Analysts and activists welcomed the ESAF study as a long- overdue first chance for outsiders – albeit only four hand-picked consultants – to open the IMF’s closely guarded files.
Veteran observers, however, noted the agency had delayed the study until after it won approval, in October 1996, to make ESAF permanent. This freed the agency from periodically having to ask member states to fund the scheme. Instead, the facility will fund itself “in perpetuity” from loan repayments, according to an official document.
Political analysts also said the IMF had agreed to conduct outside reviews in hopes these would mollify member states seeking to open the agency to regular, independent auditing.
A British parliamentary committee recommended last year that an independent evaluation unit be set up to assess the Fund’s work. Five years earlier, the U.S. Congress called for an audit department at the IMF “that would include poverty and environmental experts, to review systematically the policy prescriptions recommended and required by the Fund.”
Member states’ lawmakers cannot direct the IMF to do anything, however, so the Freedom Support Act of 1992 requires the U.S. representative at the IMF to promote the issue “regularly and vigorously.” Washington’s envoy to the IMF’s executive board also is required by law to use both “voice and vote” in signalling opposition to loans for countries running afoul of human rights and environmental norms.
The requirements have been honoured mainly in the breach, according to senior officials including Karin Lissakers, the IMF’s U.S. executive director. Earlier this year, Lissakers told a Congressional committee she seldom had voted against proposals she was mandated to oppose. But she argued this was not because U.S. officials ignored the law, but because the IMF board tends to avoid votes in favour of consensus on major decisions.
Legislators noted that her explanation appeared to be at odds with statements by senior U.S. Treasury Department and IMF officials, who were seeking increased U.S. funding for the IMF. Those officials had argued that it was in the national interest to bolster the Fund because Washington enjoys what amounts to veto power over major decisions. To be enacted by the IMF, many proposals must garner an 85-percent majority in the executive board. The United States, the Fund’s largest shareholder, holds 18 percent of all votes.