Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-HEALTH: Challenges to Ban on Hazardous Chemicals/REPEATING

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Jun 5 1998 (IPS) - The international effort to eliminate the worldwide production and use of highly toxic chemicals that travel over long distances is in danger of stalling in lengthy negotiations that could take years, environmentalists say.

Representatives of more than 100 countries are scheduled to meet at the end of this month in Montreal, Canada to begin formal negotiations on a U.N. treaty aimed at phasing out worldwide use and production of “persistent organic pollutants (POPs).”

Many obstacles stand in the way of producing and implementing such a treaty – which would be the first attempt to control these kinds of synthetic chemicals on a global basis, say U.S. officials and environmental groups.

They maintain that developing countries do not have the legal structures in place, nor economic resources, for dealing with chemical regulation. Also alternatives to the harmful chemicals, used in public health programmes to eradicate disease-carrying mosquitoes in developing nations, are very expensive.

“We have to go into this with a sense of realism,” says Lynn Goldman, a medical doctor and assistant administrator at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. “We don’t know how this will work in a global context when the (industrialised countries) will be sitting around the table with developing countries that are using technologies for generating energy and waste disposal that we used 30 years ago.”

Many developing countries lack the legal capacity to protect people from chemicals, adds Jack Weinberg, director of the POPs Team at Greenpeace International. “These negotiations, though, hopefully will be a stepping stone toward giving these nations the help they need to deal with these chemicals.”

The chemicals up for scrutiny in Montreal are the so-called “dirty-dozen – aldrin, chlordane, DDT, dieldrin, dioxins, endrin, furans, heptachlor, hexachlorobenzene, mirex, PCBs and toxaphene. Environmental groups, including the Pesticide Action Network, are pushing to add more to this list.

Some of these chemicals are pesticides and industrial products. Others are the chemical byproducts of manufacturing processes. These include dioxins and furans which are created during incineration or through the production of chlorine.

Scientists, studying wildlife and humans, have linked POPS to immune system and neurological defects, reproductive abnormalities, low sperm counts, and cancer. These chemicals are of global concern because they have the ability to travel by wind and water.

POPs are labelled “persistent” as it is decades before they break down. They also “bio-accumulate” – when consumed, they are not excreted but build up in fatty tissue. Therefore many animals, including those high up in the food chain, retain heavy doses of the chemicals.

In 1995, in order to address these health and environmental threats, about 100 countries agreed to negotiate a global treaty to reduce and eliminate the “dirty dozen.” The formal negotiations beginning with the conference in Montreal are expected to be completed by the year 2000.

Attempts to eliminate POPs on a global scale face a number of obstacles. While many industrialised countries want to develop timetables to phase out and eliminate these chemicals, developing nations will probably have different implementation requirements since they do not have parallel regulatory and waste management systems for dealing with hazardous chemicals, says the EPA’s Goldman.

“Hopefully at the end of the conference we will end up with methods to achieve elimination of POPs, when possible,” says Weinberg. “But we know that implementation of the treaty will vary in different regions in the world in part because of what kind of waste management infrastructure they have.”

As countries ban the use and production of some POPs, governments also need to develop plans to safely dispose of old stocks of these chemicals that will remain sitting in warehouses and on store shelves throughout the world, says Goldman.

Since there have been reports of industrialised countries dumping such banned stock-piled chemicals in developing countries, Goldman says there must be coordinated efforts to link the POPs treaty with the Basel Convention, which prohibits industrialised countries from dumping their hazardous waste in developing countries.

Another challenge lies with chemicals used in developing countries to control insects and other pests. A few of the POPs, notably DDT, are still used in developing countries to control mosquitoes responsible for the disease malaria. And dieldrin has been used to prevent the spread of locusts in Africa.

Yet, many of the chemical pesticide alternatives to DDT are very expensive and therefore not always a realistic solution. A more practical approach, says Goldman, would be to address other ways of eliminating malaria.

“Mexico has used a public health strategy of eradicating malaria in large parts of the country in order to cut down on the need to use DDT,” says Goldman. “Over the last fifteen years Mexico has gone from having a very extensive problem with Malaria throughout the country to having a few only isolated patches that continue to have problems with the disease.”

This strategy has become part of negotiations between Canada, Mexico and the United States to begin to eliminate the use and production of some POPs, including DDT, PCBs and chlordane, Goldman adds.

Under the North American Commission on Environmental Cooperation – a body set up under the NAFTA, the free trade agreement for the region, – these nations have already taken steps to strictly manage some of these chemicals.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags