Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, North America, Population

INDIGENOUS-RIGHTS: Native Canadians Fight for Tax Privileges

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Jun 25 1998 (IPS) - Tension is rising between between Canadian authorities and the country’s indigenous peoples over the loss by natives of the right not to pay sales taxes.

A landmark couirt case on June 18 stripped Native Canadians of their 235-year-old privilege to buy goods in non-native stores without paying sales taxes. Now, the Quebec provincial government wants to force reserves to charge sales taxes to non-natives on all purchases made in stores in the native reserves.

The move threatens the trade of tax-free liquor and cigarettes on native reserves. It’s one of the few ways that indigenous communities in the reserves can make money in Canada and provides a livlihood for thousands of Canadian aboriginals.

The dispute is causing turmoil on native reserves in the Montreal area. The three reserves in the region were the site of road blockades and armed standoffs that were quelled by the Canadian army in 1990.

“We, the Mohawks of Kahnawake (just south of Montreal), have been denied accessibility to our traditional lands and resources on which you, the Canadians and Quebecers, have grown fat and lazy, ” says Chief Joe Norton in a letter to Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chretien.

The Mohawks have threatened to levy tolls on the St. Lawrence Seaway shipping canal, which crosses their territory. They may also begin charging tolls on railway and highway traffic crossing the reserves.

In 1990, the Mohawks at Kahnawake blocked the Mercier Bridge, a major link between downtown Montreal and the city’s suburbs as one end of the bridge is on Mohawk territory. Now moderates on the Kahnawake reserve council are trying to prevent the tax dispute from escalating into a similar standoff.

“We don’t want another 1990,” says council member Don Patrick Martin. “People can be assured that the roads will not be blocked.”

However, he notes that the Mohawks may still charge road tolls, either directly to motorists, or to the government of Quebec for the use of Mohawk lands. There are no other toll roads in Quebec and the Mohawks also are considering charging the giant Hydro Quebec electricity monopoly a fee for allowing its lines and towers to be built on native territory.

“What the government is trying to do is impose its jurisdiction on aboriginal communities, and it’s a roundabout way to do it,” said Ghislain Picard, Quebec vice-president of the Assembly of First Nations.

Political observers say there is some doubt that moderate native leaders, who make up the majorities on Montreal-area band councils, can continue to control the situation. Elections for the councils will be held later this summer, and some of the leaders of the 1990 crisis, including Oka chief Jerry Pelletier, are trying to make political comebacks.

The armed Mohawk warrior societies, which have been underground since the 1990 stand-offs, could re-assert their power on reserves, observers believe. Already, there have been signs that the crisis may come to a head this summer, when the Seaway and the roads through the region are busiest.

Traditionalist Mohawks, who have refused to accept the rule of the government-sanctioned band councils, say they support any move to levy tolls on native land.

“As far as the traditional people are concerned, we’ve always been sovereign,” says Karohiahtente, spokeswoman for the Mohawk Nation. “The people have always been and will be opposed to any form of taxation.”

Band councillor Davis Rice, a hereditary chief whose political support encompasses traditional Mohawks and those who are represented by the band councils, say he, too, supports blockades and toll booths. “We were here first and for too long we haven’t collected on rents. Now they are past due and it’s time to pay,” he says.

The Montreal-area crisis comes at the same time Canadian natives lost a major tax case in the Supreme Court of Canada. Last week the Union of New Brunswick Indians, which represents 9,500 status natives who live on reserves, lost their tax appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada. The government of New Brunswick had asked the court to end the practice of natives refusing to pay taxes on goods purchased off their reserves.

Until that decision, natives had been able to show their government treaty cards to claim tax exemption in the nine Canadian provinces that have sales taxes. The Supreme Court decision is applicable across Canada.

Native communities argue that a clause in the 1763 Royal Proclamation that served as the first constitution of the British colonies in Canada allows them not to pay taxes.

The proclamation says tax exemptions exist for “the personal property of an Indian or band situated on a reserve.” The Supreme Court’s decision interprets “situated” as referring to the people involved, not the goods. In its 5-2 ruling, the Court states that cancellation of the tax-free status actually will help the economy of the impoverished native reserves.

“First, it provides an incentive for Indians to establish their own retail outlets on reserves and gives a competitive edge to reserve businesses, thereby increasing economic activity and employment,” Judge Beverley McLachlin wrote in the court’s majority decision.

But Judge Ian Binnie, in a minority report, said the sparsely populated, isolated reserves likely will never have the large department stores, car dealerships and other businesses that natives use off their territories.

“Given the realities of reserve life in that province, particularly the lack of on-reserve shopping facilities, restricting the tax exemption means for all practical purposes that no tax exemption is available,” Justice Binnie wrote.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags