Friday, November 20, 2026
Anil Netto
- Malaysia’s aggressive advertisement campaign promises that this once-booming economy will soon bounce back, but things are bound to get worse first before they get any better.
And as the effects of Asia’s nearly year-long economic slowdown continues, the country’s workforce will be among those that will get the brunt of the blows.
Thousands of workers have already been thrown out of work as businesses struggle to stay afloat during the economic crisis. By year’s end, about half a million workers will have lost their jobs.
Human Resources Minister Lim Ah Lek has angrily challenged this estimate. He said recently that retrenchments from January to May 9 this year stood at 28,890 — and about 10 percent of those were foreign personnel.
Still, the government has admitted an expected unemployment rise from last year’s 2.5 percent to four to five percent by end- 1998.
Rajasekaran, who is secretary-general of the Malaysian Trades Union Congress, stands by his estimate. He says the government unemployment total refers only to layoffs as notified by employers to the ministry. “It does not include voluntary retrenchment schemes or unreported retrenchments,” he said.
“Integral to finding solutions to job losses is the question of numbers,” argued Rajasekaran. “The government has yet to publicly put forward any forecast on the number of retrenchments caused by the crisis.”
Indeed, many firms have resorted to shorter working hours, some even forcing their staff to take unpaid leave. But these apparently do not figure in the official retrenchment figures, which also excludes casual contract workers and temporary staff who have been terminated.
Rajasekaran says he based his estimate of 500,000 workers joining the ranks of the unemployed by end-1998 on the government’s own forecast of a slowdown in economic growth from nearly eight percent in 1997 to two to three percent for this year.
The outlook, in fact, could be gloomier: the government has been way off the mark in its previous estimates for 1998 — and it could be wrong again.
Recently, Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Anwar Ibrahim announced recently: “The economic problems may make it no longer possible for the country to sustain a surplus or balanced budget”. Last year, Malaysia posted a budget surplus of 1.55 billion dollars.
These days, the plunge in the stock market has hurt many Malaysians, who have seen the value of their share investments cut by up to 50 percent over the last year. With inflation creeping upward — partly due to the weaker ringgit making imports more expensive — Malaysians have been forced to tighten their belts.
This cautious approach to consumer spending has hurt businesses, many of which have reported large drops in sales. Rajasekaran calculates that manufacturers will lay off about 115,000 workers while hotels, restaurants, wholesalers and retailers will shed a further 200,000 workers.
Many developers have also delayed ongoing projects. Contractors are letting thousands of workers go as the drone of bulldozers at construction sites dies down. According to Rajasekaran, some 150,000 building site workers would lose their jobs by year’s end.
The labour leader’s lay-offs estimate includes legal migrant workers, many of whose work permits will not be renewed upon expiry. Staring at a bleak future are some 300,000 such workers, mostly Indonesians, toiling in the construction industry.
Economic forecasts from the Zurich-based Institute of International Finance (IIF), a global association of financial institutions, has depressed Malaysians some more.
Unlike the International Monetary Fund, which feels the worst of the Asian crisis may be over, IIF research head Gregory Fager has suggested that a chain reaction of adverse economic events is only just beginning to unfold in the region.
The depth of the recession indicated in IIF’s predictions has shocked many analysts. The institute warned of a real GDP contraction of 12.5 to 15 percent for Indonesia this year, seven percent in Thailand, five percent in South Korea and two percent in Malaysia.
“At best, there will be zero growth” for Malaysia, says Subramaniam Pillay, a lecturer in international finance.
Still, he believes the Malaysian economy can absorb the shock of a small recession. “The economy could even contract by one to two percent but I don’t think it will lead to massive retrenchments,” he added.
Subramaniam says factories had previously requested their existing staff to work “fantastic hours of overtime” due to the acute labour shortage in recent years. Now that orders have dropped, management can trim overtime costs without resorting to laying off workers, he points out.
To be sure, despite a slump in business, some companies are reluctant to lay off skilled staff, who were in short supply when the economy was booming.
Faced with declining sales, car assembler Tan Chong Motor Assemblies, for instance, has found temporary jobs for 120 of its workers and is looking for placements for other staff while the plant planned on a three-month shutdown last week.
Workers who are required to work during the temporary closure will be paid the full salary while those not working will receive 75 percent of their pay.
The company is the second firm to offer such a scheme. It drew praise from Lim, who noted: “Do not take the easy way out by retrenching the staff, because at the end of the day it is the company which suffers through loss of skilled manpower.”
But trade unions want more. Rajasekaran proposes that the government set up a social safety net, which would include paying retrenchment benefits to workers who have lost their jobs.
Meantime, economists and labour leaders worry that political turmoil in neighbouring Indonesia could scare away investors from Asia, prolonging the crisis. Conceded Subramaniam: “We are too near Indonesia. At this point, there are so many uncertainties.”