Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

MEXICO-MEDIA: Journalists Spurn Govt Awards

MEXICO, Jun 10 1998 (IPS) - The Mexican government’s 20-year practice of awarding a prizes to national journalists lost its lustre this year when some of the winners refused to accept their awards.

More journalists die violently in Latin America annually than in any other region of the world and Mexican reporters have not been spared from the grim list of statistics. Also, newspaper distribution in Mexico is monopolized by a union that is close to the governing Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI), and journalists are usually required by authorities to reveal their sources.

Still the government awarded the first of its annual prizes to journalists, worth 17,000 dollars, in the 1970’s when the media was under official censorship and journalists often were persecuted by authorities. Since then the practcice has been increasingly criticized for interfering with the independence of journalists vis-a-vis the government.

Last week president Ernesto Zedillo presented the 1997-1998 series if prizes for “Journalism and Information” and stressed the advances made in Mexico of freedom of the press and democracy.

“Mexico is a country where the freedom to express ideas is not restricted, much less persecuted,” he said.

His words fell in deaf ears when the newspaper ‘Reforma,’ one of whose reporters won an award for “best investigative article” refused the prize “as a way of strengthening our editorial independence.”

In similar vein, Julio Scherer, a prestigious journalist who is considered to be one of the ‘fathers’ of investigative reporting in Mexico, rejected the award the jury gave him for “lifetime achievements.”

For 20 years, Scherer was director of the opposition magazine Proceso, which constantly was under official pressure and the target of threats and criticism by the government.

In past years, other journalists critical of the government also have rejected their awards. This year’s jury, presided over by Jacobo Zabludovsky – a former news anchor for the news group Televisa and one of the symbols of the past – close relationship between the government and the media gave a posthumous award to Nobel Laureate for Literature, Octavio Paz.

Of the 10 members of the jury who are appointed by the government four are or were part of Televisa, three began their careers there, and one is a member of the cultural magazine Nexos. There was little surprise in media circles when the jury decided to honor the international network ECO owned by Televisa in the category for best news show. In the category of caricature, the award went to a contributor of the newspaper “Novedades”, also owned by Televisa.

The magazine Nexos won the prize for cultural publication.

Journalists from the newspaper La Jornada, El Economista, and the magazine Siempre won the categories for reporting, feature writing and best interview.

“What is valuable about the National Journalism and Information Awards is the financial aspect, not the meaning,” as they are “totally discredited,” said Victor Roura, a columnist for the newspaper El Financiero.

The international association “Journalists Without Borders” said that there was now a greater openness in the Mexican media, but asserted there still were conditions that prevented journalists from exercising their craft freely.

The organization, which boasts a membership of 1,200 journalists from all over the world, has placed Mexico on a list of 14 countries where conditions for freedom of the press are “particularly bad.”

Most journalists in Mexico, however, acknowledge that there have been advances toward greater freedom of expression compared to 30 or 40 years ago, when to criticizing the government was virtually impossible..

The relationship between the media and the government reached a point in 1963 in which the owners and concessionaires of 455 radio and television stations massively affiliated with the PRI.

Data from the Latin America Federation of the Press indicates that in the past 27 years, about 90 journalists have been assassinated in Mexico, the highest number for a Latin American country.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags