Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

RIGHTS-MEXICO: Gov’t and Church Iron Out Differences over Chiapas

Felipe Vazquez

MEXICO CITY, Jun 17 1998 (IPS) - Recent friction between the Mexican government and the Catholic Church over the conflict in the southern state of Chiapas was caused by a “progressive” wing of the Church and has been overcome, according to high-level ecclesiastical authorities.

After an audience with President Ernesto Zedillo to discuss the situation in Chiapas and present the new council of the presidency of the Mexican Episcopal Conference (CEM), the president and secretary-general of CEM, Luis Morales and Abelardo Alvarado, said discrepancies over Chiapas had been worked out.

Both Church and government have been involved in peace negotiations in the state of Chiapas since the conflict broke out on Jan. 1, 1994, with the first public appearance of the Zapatista National Liberation Army (EZLN).

But relations between the government and the Church became strained in the past few months due to the activities of Bishop Samuel Ruiz in Chiapas, who for two years headed the National Intermediation Commission (CONAI), a body created to act as a peace-broker between the EZLN and the government.

Ruiz announced the break-up of CONAI on Jun. 7, accusing the government of religious persecution – a claim later refuted by the Church hierarchy itself.

Bishops Ruiz and Felipe Arismendi in Chiapas protested accusations launched by Zedillo on his latest visit to the conflict-ridden state against unspecified “theologians of violence.”

On Jun. 10, army troops were sent in to “dismantle” the community of El Bosque, one of the 32 “autonomous” municipalities set up by followers of the Zapatista guerrillas in Chiapas. In a clash between army troops and local residents, one police officer and eight civilians were killed, and 58 people were arrested, accused of attacking the more than 1,000 soldiers who participated in the operation.

According to unofficial sources, more than 300 people have been killed in Chiapas since conflict first broke out between the Zapatistas and government troops in early 1994 in the state located on the border with Guatemala.

Some 45 indigenous people, mainly women and children displaced by the violence in Chiapas, were massacred by machetes and expanding bullets in December by supposed supporters of the ruling Institutional Revolutionary Party.

The Zapatistas are demanding justice, democracy and respect for the rights of the indigenous peoples of Chiapas, who are a majority in Mexico’s poorest state.

Last week, Zedillo justified incursions by police and army troops into areas under Zapatista influence, arguing that “peace is only possible with respect for the law.” The government maintains that the autonomous communities set up in Chiapas are illegal.

Bishop Ruiz, accused of favouring the guerrillas on the one hand while promoted as a candidate for the Nobel Peace Prize on the other, said the government was persecuting the Church in Chiapas and that authorities had given up on “the route of dialogue.”

Opposition political parties like the centre-left Party of the Democratic Revolution – in power in Mexico City – human rights groups and “progressive” sectors of the Catholic Church accuse the government of seeking to reactivate the war by violating the armed truce established by a law passed by Congress in 1995.

But Morales, the president of CEM, said the differences between the government and the Church had disappeared with the dissolution of CONAI and Ruiz’ withdrawal as peace negotiator.

“The friction mainly rested with Ruiz and his diocese,” he said. “But if recent events created tension with the Church or with any portion of it, that tension has been overcome…(and) we have returned to the relationship that should exist – cordial, respectful, while free on both sides.”

Morales stressed that the discrepancies were between the government and the bishops of Chiapas, who belong to a progressive minority within the Church, rather than the conservative majority.

Cardinal Norberto Rivera emphatically denied in his last sermon delivered in the Mexico City cathedral that religious persecution existed in Mexico.

Under-secretary of religious affairs of the secretariat of the interior, Guillermo Jimenez, said there was a frank and cordial understanding between the Catholic Church and the government in Mexico.

Morales said the Commission for Peace and Reconciliation in Chiapas, created by CEM in 1994, would continue working towards peace, and that nine bishops were planning an Aug. 10-12 visit to the state.

Bishop Felipe Arismendi said the bishops would meet with high- level army officers and EZLN leaders to pave the way for a renewal of the peace talks, which were suspended in 1996.

But Cardinal Rivera said only the local residents of Chiapas were in a position to work their problems out, and maintained that there was no need for “international intervention” or even mediation at a national level.

Church-state relations in Mexico are generally broken down into three main periods: the late 19th century, when then-president Benito Juarez pushed through reforms which separated church and state; the 1920s, when church groups rose up in arms against further government reforms; and the administration of Carlos Salinas (1988-94), which once again broadened the Church’s role.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags