Friday, November 20, 2026
Maria Isabel Garcia
- Relations between Ercilia and her employer are less cordial than they used to be now that Colombia’s Constitutional Court has established a 10-hour working day for domestics.
The Court ruled recently that, should they work more than 10 hours daily, household employees such as domestics, chauffeurs and gardeners are to receive overtime pay to be calculated at 125 percent their hourly wage for extra work done during the day and 135 percent at night.
Such jobs are usually paid at the minimum wage, which is about 150 dollars a month.
Ercilia, who is 45 years of age, has been cleaning and cooking for Marina, a 32-year-old economist and banking executive, for the past three years. She is also the nanny of Carolina, Marina’s seven-year-old daughter.
Both considered the relationship mutually beneficial “until they began to report on the Court’s decision and make a huge song and dance about it on radio and television,” Marina told IPS.
For Marina, finding Ercilia had been a stroke of luck. “I had recently separated from Carolina’s father, and if it weren’t for her, I would not have been able to devote myself to my job at the bank, which for me was a huge challenge,” she said.
Landing a job was also important to Ercilia. “I have to send money each month to my mother, who is raising my 14-year-old son, and I have to say that Marina treats me like family,” she says.
Now, however, the two women disagree on the overtime issue.
Marina feels that when a maid lives with the family it is very hard to calculate the extra hours she works. “This can be measured in a factory on the basis of one’s productivity,” she says, “but in a house it’s difficult to know when the maid takes breaks or watches television, or even when she takes a nap.”
Ercilia, on the other hand, sees payment for overtime as fair. “Sometimes, when there are parties or meetings, I work all night long, and no matter what happens, I have to wake up at five a.m. to prepare breakfast and get Carolina ready to take her to her school bus,” she says.
Public reactions to the new ten-hour workday for domestics, carried on national radio stations, have been varied.
Proponents of the new law say it is justified because domestic work has many intangibles, is repetitive and unpleasant. Those against have two main arguments. Some argue that domestic work cannot be measured using the same criteria as other formal labour, and it is difficult to set limits. Others say the Court’s decision is discriminatory.
“With the economic situation as difficult as it is, I am going to have to fire my maid, because I cannot pay her salary,” said one man who phoned in to a radio programme. He added that in his house the maid “is even given permission to study”.
Labour lawyer Carmen Helena Garcez told IPS that the Court did not apply the principle of equality in its decision and that the workday for domestic employees should actually be eight hours.
Although Colombia’s government has made recent moves to regulate the work of domestic employees in the South American country, some maids still work in slavery-like conditions. “The ‘girls’ are often forced to submit to the sexual advances of the boss or his sons,” said Garcez.
In 1985, a law was passed requiring all domestics to join the social security system. It also allowed their employers to retain up to 25 percent of their wages for food and housing. But it was only in 1995 that domestics earned the right to severance pay – equivalent to one month’s salary per year worked.
They also have a right to 15 days vacation each year but not to the annual bonus equivalent to one month’s salary that other workers receive in two instalments in June and December.
According to labour lawyer Garcez, domestics are discriminated against in other ways, such as the fact that although many of them are under the age of 18, their employers rarely observe the regulations that apply to working minors.
Under the code for working children, boys and girls aged 12 to 14 years should not work more than four hours a day and 24 hours per week. For children between the ages of 14 and 16, the limits are six hours per day and 36 per week.
For children below the age of 18 to be hired, they must have written permission granted by their parents before a special office of the Labour Ministry. If they are under 16, permission is also needed from the Ombudsman for Minors.
Women’s rights organisations see the Court’s decision as generally positive, though they feel it is not enough. Teresa Martinez, the administrative coordinator of one such organisation, the Working Women’s House, said domestic work must be socially recognized, so that it is seen as an economic contribution to society.
The Court’s decision coincided with an announcement that the unemployment rate for June was the highest in a decade – 15.8 percent or just over one million people. According to the National Statistics Department, women are harder hit by joblessness (18 percent versus 11.3 percent for men).
The worst affected are girls aged 15 to 19 (41.9 percent). This is the age group to which most domestics belong, which could mean that upholding the Court’s decision will depend largely on the law of supply and demand.