Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

RIGHTS: New Venezuelan Law to Limit Classification of Documents

Jose Zambrano

CARACAS, Jul 6 1998 (IPS) - It is Jan. 22, 1958. Venezuela’s elite army unit surrounds the cadets in the Military Academy, who have risen up in arms. But after a brief siege, the battalion turns its weapons away to train them against the dictator, who flees hours later, on Jan. 23, 1958.

Forty years later, journalist Eleazar Diaz Rangel is investigating who issued the orders and the list of officers heading the battalion which made that decisive move, in order to write the history of the civic-military uprising that overthrew General Marcos Perez Jimenez.

“None of the documents I was looking for appeared, in spite of the interest of the Defence Ministry and the officers it commissioned to help me,” Diaz Rangel told IPS.

“No one knows what could have happened to that material,” says Diaz Rangel, former president of the Latin American Federation of Reporters and former director of the school of Social Communication at the Central University of Venezuela, the country’s leading centre of higher learning.

Diaz Rangel’s experience is just one example of the desert run into by researchers seeking official information in Venezuela, from the simplest procedures to secrets of military history. But that situation could change with a draft law currently being discussed in parliament.

The draft Organic Law of Access to Public Administration Information and Regulation of State Secrecy is the direct product of Diaz Rangel’s inconclusive research into military events which were secret 40 years ago, and whose status no one is sure of today.

“A certain culture of the Venezuelan public administration, marked by disorder, has taken refuge in saying ‘no’, rather than information being the norm and secrets the exception,” socialist Deputy Luis Esculpi, president of the Defense Commission and chief sponsor of the draft law, told IPS.

The result is that researchers and others seeking information continuously run into labels such as “you cannot review this document” or “you cannot have access to this information,” commented Esculpi, who added that the classification was rarely justified, but rather a subterfuge used to cover up corrupt practices.

Prompted by Diaz Rangel’s fruitless search, the Commission launched a study of the laws regulating classification of public documents and access to information on the public administration in some 15 countries, until coming up with its own draft law “which in first place guarantees that citizen right.”

The bill, which has been discussed by both houses of Congress and reportedly has the backing of the entire spectrum of political forces, stipulates that public entities are under obligation to make the documents in their charge available to anyone who solicits information.

The draft law also details the exceptions: access to all information on the private and domestic lives of persons is to be restricted, as well as to documents protected by commercial and industrial secrecy.

The deliberations of the Council of Ministers, documents whose public scrutiny could endanger national security, and any other aspect of security and defence classified by the president and the relevant minister will also remain classified.

“Secret-confidential information” will only be declassified after 10 years, and “secret-reserved information” in 20 years. Declassification of the latter can be postponed for 10 years on orders by the president.

Citizens, meanwhile, will be able to take recourse to the principle of habeas corpus if they consider that their right to access to information has been violated, or their right to privacy breached by submission of information to public scrutiny.

“A first result of this law would be to bring order to the archives of the public administration. We are not worried about a big additional cost, because the infrastructure for organising the service already exists,” said Esculpi. Moreover, “there will be greater care in the handling of documents.”

For the common citizen, organisations of civil society, researchers and “journalists in particular, the possible field of research will be expanded,” said Diaz Rangel, who added that “editors and press associations should take more interest in the draft law.”

Human rights activists in Venezuela may not yet have comprehended the significance of the draft law. “The violation of other rights is so great that this one can be considered secondary,” a spokesman for the human rights group Provea told IPS.

As an example of situations that could be investigated under the new law, Diaz Rangel cited a recent declaration by former defence minister Vice-Admiral Radames Munoz, who said that “behind each weapons contract lies a parliamentarian.”

Another example are two engineering studies, classified according to no one knows what criteria, one in favour of and the other against the designation of several installations as passenger terminals by the city government of Caracas.

“If the proposed law were in effect, all you would have to do is solicit the reports and enable the public and experts to become familiar with them through debate in the media,” said Diaz Rangel.

Perhaps it will never be known how the officers of the ‘Bolivar’ battalion decided to turn their guns away from the cadets and towards the dictatorship on Jan. 22, 1958. But the average Venezuelan will be able to find out the guarantees offered by the terminal where they will board a bus to head to another city.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags