Headlines

ARTS-ENTERTAINMENT – 1.

Sarah A. Smith

LONDON, Aug 11 1998 (IPS) - The work of early 20th-century novelist Marguerite Radclyffe Hallthe lesbian icon once labelled as a “grossly immoral woman” remained as controversial after her in death as they had been during her life.

Radclyffe Hall, born in 1883, and achieved notoriety in 1928 with her “The Well of Lonelioness,” the first book to go on sale in Britain dealing frankly with lesbianism. That same year a British court found the book to be obscene and it remained banned long after Hall died in 1943.

Britain’s Home Office (equivalent to the Ministry of the Interior) – added another layer to to the controversy when it decided that some of the documents relating to the 1928 obscenity trial constituted a ‘threat to national security’.

Diana Souhami, Hall’s most recent biographer, only discovered her subject’s new status in January this year when she went to read documents concerning the suppression of Hall’s pioneering lesbian novel which had been locked away for 70 years.

Souhami hoped to find details of how law makers and enforcers had connived against Hall and her allegedly “disgusting” book. Some new material was found, but Souhami found that many files were empty and marked ‘Retained by the Home Office’.

Shocked by the prolonging of what Hall herself had termed a “conspiracy of silence”, Souhami pleaded for a review, but was told that the decision to hold back some of the papers was “in the interests of national security.”

The documents would be considered again for release in 2007, the Home Office ruled, but Souhami took the matter to Home Secretary Jack Straw himself and finally gained access to the records in their entirety.

The suppressed papers added “more pieces to the jigsaw” and also revealed the extent to which the government had gone to stop publication of The Well of Loneliness, Souhami said.

This included the issuing of warrants requiring the Post Office to intercept mail addressed to the book’s Paris publisher, plans to indict London publisher Jonathan Cape and distributor Leopold Hill, and efforts to circumnavigating of the Chairman of the Board of Customs, who refused to take part in the case against the book.

Souhami described her reaction to the Home Office’s delayed release of the documents as “one of astonishment.”

“I thought it was grotesque. I couldn’t see how national security could be compromised. It was just a case of residual embarrassment at what a Home Secretary can do, the modus operandi of government,” she said. “The papers themselves didn’t change anything of the pattern which I already knew was there – there was no revelation which warranted the withholding.”

Souhami blamed an over-zealous bureaucracy for the delay, rather than a need for secrecy.

Andrew Ecclestone of the Campaign for Freedom of Information, who advised Souhami in her attempts to get the papers’ released says that a percentage of documents are always retained, and would not be unusual in this kind of case.

Even lobbying at ministerial level by no means guarantees access to such papers in Britain. Souhami succeeded, Ecclestone suggests, because the potential for embarrassment was greater if Jack Straw withheld the papers than if he released them.

Souhami’s biography, The Trials of Radclyffe Hall (Weidenfeld & Nicolson) published last month undoubtedly is enriched by the trial papers, which suggest that it was not just Hall’s ideas about sexuality that were on trial, it was the whole country’s.

“The florid language that they used, ‘filthy, disgusting, morally corrupt, corrupting the morals of the young’, they really went to town on the prose!” said Souhami.

For her “the most pernicious thing was the defeat of any kind of discussion. The worst of English censorship was the silence – you don’t mention it, you just hope it will go away. It’s actually a very invidious sort of repression and oppression.”

Souhami observed “I think it was Janet Flanner who said that in many ways ‘The Well’ really is a rather naive book and that it could, and should have, paved the way for others, but censorship ensured there wouldn’t be any others.”

Ironically, it also ensured huge sales for the book which continued to be printed in Paris and was a great success in the United States, where a trial for obscenity failed. Now The Well enjoys cult status and ranks eleventh in publisher Virago’s Modern Classics best-sellers’ list.

But it is for its sexual innovation, rather than its scandal, that ‘The Well’ is valued, even if, as Souhami admits, it is a politically ambivalent work.

Hall can be praised “for standing up and writing that book and not compromising”. But, she added, “I also think she did a great disservice because, in terms of putting forward a lesbian identity, most lesbians don’t want to be identified with her version – it makes you curl in your boots.

“But I think that the embarrassment that it’s possible to feel about her account is as nothing compared to the homophobia and the malice it unleashed in the ruling class.”

Souhami thinks that Hall must have had a fair idea of what she was letting herself in for. But she also wonders “as you find with a lot of courageous people, could Hall have behaved any differently? She was so appalling herself…”

In The Trials of Radcliffe Hall, Souhami gives a thorough account of quite how appalling Hall could be, drawing on Hall’s own papers, and the letters and diaries of the author and her three great loves – society beauty Mabel Batten, Navy Admiral’s wife Lady Una Troubridge, and Russian emigre Evguenia Souline.

Far from living the largely monastic life of the heroine of The Well of Loneliness, Stephen Gordon, Hall was something of a rake.

She used sex as a weapon, first against her much-hated mother – her early lovers seem to have been chosen from among her mother’s relatives – and then as a brand of possession. She once wrote in a panic to the unfortunate Souline: “You belong to me, and don’t you forget it. ? No one but me has the right to touch you. I took your virginity, do you hear?”

Souhami writes about Hall with a wry detachment, sardonically noting that the stylish lesbians Hall knew included Tallulah Bankhead, Colette, Romaine Brooks, and Natalie Barney, none of whom fitted Hall’s definition of “some of the most persecuted and misunderstood people in the world”.

One senses a restrained mockery in her approach, an antidote to Hall’s extraordinarily inflated idea of her own importance as an “artistic brain-worker” and member of the moneyed elite. But the battle Hall fought – for the recognition and acceptance of lesbians – goes on.

The campaigning lesbian and gay rights group Stonewall say lesbians suffer discrimination in terms of parenting and partnership rights, while the law has still not acknowledged lesbian sex.

Meanwhile the popular media continue to treat lesbianism as a source of moral outrage. In 1928 it was a Sunday Express editorial which sparked the case against ‘The Well,’ with its demand that “The book must at once be withdrawn”.

Today The Daily Mail has taken on the role of moral arbiter. On Jul. 31 they spread the news of the separation of a lesbian couple and their children (produced by DIY artificial insemination) across the front page, under the headline ‘A Mockery of Motherhood’.

Inside an editorial accused the women of indulging in a “selfishly irresponsible stunt” but made no mention of the number of heterosexual “stunts” which end in family breakdown.

In Britain today, silence still afflicts most lesbians in public life and elsewhere, in all but the artistic world. The first openly lesbian British MP ‘came out’ only last year.

And for all the gains that have been made, Diana Souhami has a last, cautionary word: “It could always slip back? prejudice stills lurks”.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags