Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-US: Senate Approves Nuclear Dump Near Mexican Border

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Sep 2 1998 (IPS) - The U.S. Senate Wednesday passed a bill allowing two states to send radioactive waste to a proposed dump near the Mexico-U.S border, despite strong opposition from Mexican officials, environmentalists and people living near the intended site.

The senators voted 78-15 to approve the Texas-Maine-Vermont Compact, under which Texas would accept radioactive waste from the states of Vermont and Maine. Both states would pay 25 million dollars each toward the development of the site.

Having already passed through the House of Representatives, the Compact needs only to be approved by President Bill Clinton to become law.

The controversy surrounding the Compact revolves around the site chosen by Texan officials to receive the waste. It is located at the western end of the state in the small town Sierra Blanca, 30 kms from the Mexican border. It is also situated in one of the economically poorest regions of the country.

Civil rights groups and Mexican-American organisations have charged supporters of the Compact with racism because two-thirds of the residents of the town are of Mexican origin.

“Approving the Texas-Maine-Vermont Compact is approving racism. The White House should stand up and veto this Compact,” Senator Paul D. Wellstone, a Democrat from Minnesota, said this week. “Too often, waste sites are selected through the path of least political resistance; too often, the communities selected are low-income, minority communities. It is a grave injustice.”

Environmental groups warn that the area around the site is not a safe place to store radioactive waste because it is prone to earthquakes and is situated over an aquifer – a scarce resource in Sierra Blanca’s dry desert climate.

Texas Senators and Texas Governor George W. Bush – the former U.S. President’s son – strongly supported the inter-state agreement saying it would bring jobs and income to the area. On the other hand, the Compact has been denounced by the Mexican Congress, whose Permanent Commission voted unanimously against the proposed dump earlier this year.

“The border does not distinguish between the water in the wells between the United States and Mexico,” Hector Murguia, a Mexican Senator from Ciudad Juarez, said on a recent visit to Texas. “Who’s going to guarantee that years from now there is not going to be a leak?”

Some Mexican parliamentarians said the dump violated the 1983 La Paz Agreement between Mexico and the United States, which prohibits the siting of such projects within 100 kms from the border. Mexican officials have vowed to fight the deal within the context of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) or an international body such as the Organisation of American States.

Environmentalists and Democratic politicians have charged that Texas officials were racist in choosing Sierra Blanca as the site of the dump. A report on public reactions to nuclear waste, released in 1984 by the Texas Low Level Nuclear Waste Disposal Authority, found that poor minority communities were the least informed of all segments of the population and the least likely to pose a strong opposition to the dump.

“The Texas, Maine, Vermont Compact will unfairly dump nuclear waste on a community that was targeted because it was poor, largely Hispanic, and had little formal education,” said Congresswoman Norma Chavez. “The Texas Nuclear Authority location was founded on the principles of environmental racism.”

Chavez, Wellstone, and civil rights and environmental organisations are urging President Bill Clinton to veto the senate’s decision because it contradicts the President’s 1994 Executive Order on Federal Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority and Low Income Populations.

This order requires the government to ensure that people of colour and low-income communities are not disproportionately burdened by environmental hazards.

“Radioactive waste is not the only thing that will be dumped in a giant hole dug in Sierra Blanca,” said Erin Rogers, director of the Sierra Blanca Legal Defense Fund, “democracy and civil rights will also be buried in this nuclear graveyard.”

Vermont’s senators said they had to send their waste away because their state’s geological conditions prevented the storage of waste there. They chose Texas because other nuclear waste facilities around the country would not enter permanent storage agreements with Vermont.

Those arguments hardly satisfy Bill Addington, a store owner in Sierra Blanca.

“We have geologically unfavorable conditions in Sierra Blanca too,” said Addington. “The proposed nuclear dump is located over an aquifer and a fault line. More than 60 earthquakes with magnitudes of over three on the Richter scale have occurred within 200 miles of the town within the last 70 years.”

He charged that Vermont and Maine were just “looking for the cheapest way out”.

Texas Senators have argued that the site is safe and that the type of radioactive waste to be stored in Sierra Blanca is low- level or that most of it is just gloves and boots used in medical facilities. Yet, documents from Vermont and Maine indicate that most of the waste headed for Texas is from nuclear reactors. All but the spent fuel rods of nuclear power plants are considered low- level.

Wellstone, Chavez and other democratic politicians opposing the Compact blamed the large utility industries for using political campaign contributions to influence congress.

“I’ll tell you why I’m one of the only congressmen from Texas to speak out against the agreement,” said Representative Lon Burnam of Dallas. “Because I do not accept campaign contributions from the utilities industry. They own this agreement because they want to shift liability from private industry to the taxpayers of Texas.”

Sierra Blanca is already home to one of the largest sewage sludge dumps in the country. Since 1992, three trainloads a week of New York City sludge have been dumped on a 36,400-hectare ranch just outside of town.

Based on the average composition of the sludge according to figures provided by the New York Department of Environmental Quality, Addington calculated that over one year, Merco Joint Venture Company, the waste corporation running the operation, deposits thousands of pounds of arsenic, copper and lead on that tract of land.

While a few residents of Sierra Blanca support that dump because it provides some jobs, many complain of the smell and the resulting decrease in housing values.

“First sludge now nuclear waste,” said Maria Mendez, another resident of Sierra Blanca. “I think we were chosen because we don’t have any political clout. Our home has been taken over as the nation’s dumping ground.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags