Saturday, November 21, 2026
Dipankar De Sarkar
- A suggestion by a family planning expert to implant contraceptive devices in some pre-teen British girls “as a social policy” has sparked a furious row over the issue of health inequalities in this country.
At the centre of the storm was John Guillebaud, professor of reproductive health and director of the Margaret Pyke Family Planning Centre in London.
Speaking last week at a conference on contraception in the 21st century, Guillebaud said that a new Dutch device – a tiny rod which is implanted in the arm – called Implanon, could help “at- risk” teenagers avoid pregnancy although it did have side effects. He suggested, the hormonal implants could be fitted into girls around the time they are given their compulsory German measles injections at school.
“In the future, as a social policy, when you have an area with a huge rate of teenage pregnancies you could go into a school – obviously with the consent of the parents – and fit this device so that everybody would start out not being able to have a baby,” Guillebaud said.
“It could be fitted into girls once they have had their firstmenstrual period, but before they had experienced sex – for instance at the time when they were having their Rubella (German measles) jabs.”
With Britain having the highest levels of teenage pregnancies in Europe – every year, 8,000 more babies are born to girls under 16 years of age – his remarks caused heated debate.
But health experts appeared to pay more attention to the issue of promoscuity and sex, than the economic realities of teenage pregnancy. For example, the anti-abortion group, Life, demanded Guillebaud’s arrest on the grounds that he was “aiding and abetting under-age sex, which is an unlawful activity.”
Other social organisations, however, said that promiscuity was not the issue. More important, they said, was the fact that under- age pregnancy was related directly to poverty.
Recommending contraception for 12 or 13-year-olds in the poorer parts of Britain was tantamount to advocating a freeze on the numbers of the “underclass,” said one social worker.
Guillebaud strongly denied the charge and told a newspaper interviewer: “Now you are getting into eugenics. I am not suggesting that at all. I just think that every baby should be born by choice, not chance.
“I want to make it easy for these people we are describing not to have unplanned pregnancies. This is not a Big Brother thing. It is to help them implement what most of them really want; to turn their thinking in sober moments into reality when they are passionate at 4 a.m.”
Whatever the intention behind his remarks, however, there remained no doubt there were social implications behind the ‘sex story’ that has made headlines in Britain.
Long before Guillebaud’s comments, British health minister Tessa Jowell had gone on record that “Teenage conceptions tend to be both a symptom and a cause of social inequality. They can become a cycle of deprivation.”
Recent figures from the Office of National Statistics (ONS) showed that girls living in local authority rented accommodation were more than three times likely to become a teenage mother than girls living in owner-occupied accommodation.
If the girls’ fathers were absent from their households or if the girls had three or more siblings – both common conditions of poverty – they were also at greater risk of becoming teenage mothers. Studies on geographical variation also showed that rates of teenage conception tended to be higher in poorer northern areas of England and lower in the more prosperous south.
This link between poverty, geographic regions and teenage pregnancy is also recognised in a government green paper on health, which says “…the incidence (of teenage conceptions) is not spread evenly across the country, so setting a national target in this area might be less relevant for some localities.
“For others it will be a high priority and they will want to target this problem locally.”
ONS statistics also showed that teenage pregnancy was lower (11 per 1,000 girls aged 15-19 years) in local authority areas described as ‘most prosperous’ than in areas characterised by ‘ports and industries’ (43 per 1,000), ‘manufacturing’, ‘coalfields,’ and ‘mixed economies.’
The same pattern was seen for the under-16s’ birth rates in 1994-96.
Most experts agreed that teenage pregnancy was not be desirable – often the girl’s body is not ready for conception, and childbirth too often leads to an interruption in education, thereby locking the girl in a cycle of joblessness and poverty.
“People on low incomes or reliant on state benefits are more likely to be lone parents,” according to a recent study, commissioned by the government, of health inequalities in Britain. “Lone mothers may go without food because of lack of money, and some have nutritionally deficient diets. Caring for young children in disadvantaged circumstances, particularly as a lone mother, carries with it an increased risk of poor mental health.”
In addition, many of the children themselves grew up to be teenage mothers – another indicator of the cyclical nature of poverty, the report said.
One such woman, Jill Porter, a journalist from the north of England, said both her mother and one of her sisters gave birth when they were in their teens. The result – in the case of the sister – was far from happy.
“The baby was born when she was 17. She broke out of her education and never went back. She lived in a council flat (a government allocated accommodation for people on low incomes) and had problems with bringin up the child,” Porter said.
“She was a single mother, had no education and the only work she could get was manual work. Finally my parents had to bring up the child,” she added.
Health Experts, social workers, Guillebaud’s critics and ordinary women such as Porter agreed that the key to bringing down the rate of teenage pregnancy was making sex education and contraception more accessible to teenagers.
Certainly, statistics backed up the need for more access. According to a study of 53 countries by the Alan Guttmacher Institute, Britain led the world in the numbers of unmarried teenage mothers.
And, according to the Home Office, the number of cases of babies being abandoned by their mothers has tripled in the last decade. NSO statistics showed under-age pregnancy jumped 11 percent in the provinces of England and Wales between 1996 and 1997.
At the same time, half of all Britons with HIV – the virus that causes AIDS – are under the age of 25 years.
Despite this, the left-leaning thinktank Fabian Society says, only 70 percent of all schools provide sex education. By law, however, all schools are required to teach sex education.
“As adults we often forget how difficult it is for young people to ask for sex advice and contraception,” said Alison Hadley of the Brook Advisory Centres, which offer free and confidential advise on sex and contraception to young people.
A study released by the organisation this week showed that young people shied away from sex advise, fearing they may be belittled, appear stupid or be made to feel “like a slag.” Even dealing with the receptionist was viwed as a major hurdle.