Friday, November 20, 2026
Abid Aslam
- Private investors are not the solution to the world’s financial problems and, nearly two years since the onset of the global crisis, remain part of the problem, says the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
The Fund, in a forthcoming report, argues that ways must be found to make it harder for private creditors to pull out of troubled countries. Commercial players also must be made to share the costs of international bailout packages in crisis-stricken economies.
“Involving the private sector in forestalling and resolving crises remains among the most difficult challenges” facing the international financial system, the IMF report says.
An advance version of the document was released to journalists Thursday, ahead of this month’s IMF-World Bank ‘spring meetings’ here. The report adds to the ongoing debate over what to do about the ‘global financial architecture’ – or rules and institutions governing international finance.
Noting that “there is no silver bullet,” the report weighs a number of options.
Some of these – including greater dialogue between governments and their foreign creditors – are broadly consistent with what private financiers themselves have recommended.
Other ideas, however, have rankled private lenders. These include proposals to rewrite the terms of bond contracts to make it harder for individual investors to sue government borrowers and make it easier for troubled states to reschedule their private debts.
The IMF traditionally has required borrowing governments to keep up payments on their sovereign bonds. That was before it had to commit tens of billions of dollars to international bailouts.
Now Fund officials, along with the United States and other leading Fund shareholders, are demanding that some countries reduce or delay bond repayments in much the same way as corporations do when they face financial difficulty.
The Fund recently forced Ukraine to refinance its bonds in return for new IMF loans.
Wealthy nations, acting under the aegis of the Paris Club of government creditors, say they will restructure their loans to Pakistan only if the cash-strapped country persuades private holders of government bonds to make similar concessions.
The IMF is pushing similar action on some 700 million dollars in Romanian debt falling due by the end of June. Future candidates for this kind of conditionality are understood to include Russia and Ecuador.
Commercial lenders bitterly oppose those moves and argue they have suffered enough since July 1997, when Thailand fell to investor panic.
The Institute of International Finance, an association of some 300 leading international banks and finance companies, estimates potential losses at 240 billion dollars for equity investors, 60 billion dollars for international banks, and 50 billion dollars for bond holders and other private foreign creditors.
According to the IMF, however, private financiers have failed to acknowledge a partial recovery since last year – to say nothing of the large gains they enjoyed in previous years.
Furthermore, many countries and companies “in the face of a total loss of access to international capital markets, have had to repay their medium- and long-term debts ahead of final maturity” because creditors decided to exercise the right to withdraw their cash early.
The IMF estimates that the exercise of these ‘put options’, as the right to withdraw is called, will cost borrowers in the developing world’s ’emerging markets’ some 32 billion dollars in 1999-2000.
Despite invective hurled at private investors by public officials and commentators resentful of having to assemble taxpayer-financed international bailouts, “satisfactory, practicable methods of better involving the private sector have proved elusive,” the Fund says.
Rather, “it has become increasingly apparent that there are no simple or easily available solutions that can ensure that private creditors, in the aggregate, will participate fully in the resolution of financial crises.”
For its part, the private-sector Institute dismisses as “misguided” the notion that its members should be made to take part in bailouts.
Lenders not only will oppose any such attempt but likely will shun countries at precisely the time when their need for access to capital markets is greatest, says Institute Managing Director Charles Dallara.
In an open letter to finance ministers and central bank governors scheduled to participate in the World Bank-IMF meetings, the financiers’ association argues that it is up to individual countries to build better ties with their foreign creditors.
“Ninety percent of the flows (of capital to emerging markets) are coming from the private sector,” notes Institute director and Citigroup Vice Chairman William Rhodes. “It is impossible for the public sector to solve this on their own.”
Above all, however, private lenders insist that they be left alone to decide for themselves whether, when and how to help.
“The best path to attaining private sector participation …involves a case-by-case approach and should be based on intensified dialogue and voluntary approaches which take advantage of the dynamics of the marketplace,” argues Institute director and HSBC Holdings Chairman John Bond.