Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: World Bank Health Projects Poisonous, Report Says

WASHINGTON, Jun 29 1999 (IPS) - The World Bank is poisoning developing countries with some of the very projects designed to aid their health services, critics charge.

At issue is medical waste incineration, which is falling into disfavour in rich countries where it is seen as a leading source of dioxin, mercury and other pollution.

Dioxin is at the centre of Belgium’s food safety fears and its presence in animal feed there earlier this month sparked one of the most sensational – and costliest – international controversies over food contamination.

The World Bank is promoting incineration as a way to get rid of potentially infectious hospital garbage.

That is “dangerous medicine”, say the Washington-based Multinationals Resource Centre (MRC) and Health Care Without Harm, an international coalition of medical, public-health, and social experts.

The groups, in a new report, provide an inventory of 30 incineration projects backed by the World Bank and its private- sector affiliate, the International Finance Corporation.

Official documents show that the agencies are helping to build incinerators in Algeria, Argentina, Brazil, Comoros, Dominican Republic, Egypt, India, Indonesia, Kenya, Lebanon, Malawi, Mexico, Nigeria, Senegal, South Africa, Sri Lanka, Turkey, Vietnam, Western Samoa and Zimbabwe.

Promoting medical waste incineration in those countries when the technology is under fire in the West “perpetuates a double standard in which Northern citizens are afforded a higher degree of environmental and public health protection than Third World citizens,” the report declares.

That charge evokes scandals from recent decades, involving exports to the Third World of hazardous chemical fertilisers, tainted baby formula, birth-control drugs and other products deemed unfit for use in wealthy nations.

“This is a clear case of environmental racism,” says Multinationals Resource Centre Director Ann Leonard, a veteran campaigner on health and ecological issues.

The report acknowledges recent Bank efforts to study the problem and invite public comment on draft agency guidelines but says these fail to “reflect the significant threats of large- scale incinerators.”

Medical waste incineration produces cancer-causing dioxin, which is also tied to birth defects and damage to the immune system, increasing a person’s vulnerability to infections of all sorts.

Dioxin is released when waste containing chlorine – most notably polyvinyl chloride, better known as PVC plastic – is burned.

Medical waste also contains mercury, which is used in thermometers, blood-pressure devices, and batteries – and which cannot be destroyed by incineration.

The heavy metal, spewed from incinerators onto the surrounding land and water, attacks the central nervous system and causes brain, kidney and lung damage in humans and their foetuses.

Incinerators have seen their heyday in the wealthy world and suppliers of the technology in turn have had to seek out new markets in poor countries, according to the critics.

“As the dangers of medical waste incineration and the availability of alternatives has become widely known, incineration is fast becoming obsolete in industrialised countries,” their report says.

In the United States, the number of hospital incinerators in use has fallen to fewer than 2,500 – from 4,500 in 1990. In 1997 alone, US hospitals opened 1,500 alternative treatment facilities, it adds.

These include chemical disinfection, the use of microwaves to boil microbes, and large autoclaves – which kill infectious agents with high-pressure steam. Smaller versions have long been used to sterilise hospital equipment worldwide.

“While none of the alternative technologies are totally risk- free, they can be combined with an effective programme of waste reduction and segregation to reduce the environmental impacts and the financial costs of medical waste disposal,” the report states.

Hospitals can reduce their ‘waste stream’ by separating what they throw away just as households weed out goods that can be recycled.

Health centres in the West also are re-learning the lost art of re-using items such as bed pans, linens, and ‘sharps containers’ in which used needles and blades are deposited.

Such measures require relatively small investments in sterilisation equipment to “increase the use and safety of reusable materials,” the report says.

Such investments, it argues, “will address many of the problems with the unregulated scavenging and reuse of medical supplies which occurs in many Third World countries.”

Bank officials have summarised the agency’s central dilemma in dealing with waste management as “dioxins versus scavengers.”

Many hospitals in developing countries dump their waste in municipal landfills. These are easily reached by rag-pickers, who retrieve anything that can be used or sold at tremendous risk of infection.

Some Bank officials themselves doubt that incinerators are the right solution.

Agency staffers have argued for some of the same alternatives described in the report – but their suggestions appear to have been overlooked even as the Bank officially suspended its support for incinerators to review scientific data on their suitability.

Officials in the Bank’s South Asia department recommended in a January 1996 report that the lender drop its reliance on “imported high-technology incinerators that are expensive to purchase and difficult to maintain.”

Yet, “just three months later, the Bank approved a health sector project in the same country – India – which included plans for hundreds of incinerators,” the report says.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags