Friday, November 20, 2026
Farah Khan
- In South Africa, the cardboard currency is thriving. At most traffic lights, beggars stand with cardboard signs, their desperation scrawled roughly on the flattened boxes that tell their stories.
“Six children to feed. No job for two years. Please help,” is a common refrain. A grey-haired old man goes for a more whimsical variant which reads “Go ahead. Make my day. Gimme a few coins.”
Not every beggar is a job seeker but the growing presence of the cardboard currency is testimony to an unemployment rate that is plumbing new depths every month as many companies go to the wall.
In the past five years, South Africa has rapidly reduced tariffs and cut subsidies to win a place at the global trading table. It has won international business acclaim for doing so and some new foreign investment, both direct and indirect, but still suffers from the plight of “jobless growth”.
In the past four years, globalisation has brought a grim reaper in its wake. Economists estimate that the South African economy has shed between 400,000 and 500,000 jobs.
Government has a creative industrial policy to encourage investment in the country’s poorest regions, but on global trips to tap investors, President Thabo Mbeki and his emissaries have heard complaints about the country’s new labour laws.
The labour market has been an arena of rapid change for South African workers. It has also been an arena of the greatest contestation as employers and the political parties close to business have lobbied hard against the changes.
South African workers have won world-class rights to belong to trade unions, bargain collectively and to enjoy decent working conditions.
Women, for example, now have four months maternity leave and they can breastfeed their babies at work. Fathers also receive paternity leave.
Two further pieces of legislation will be ratified later this year that will shake up the labour market. They provide for skill development at work and for affirmative action, necessaries in a country where more than nine in 10 South African managers are white, while eight in 10 are male.
Employers and potential investors do not dispute that the new labour laws are necessary to address an apartheid legacy. But they complain that the plethora of laws is making it too expensive to hire labour and that the laws are too difficult to administer. The laws, it is suggested, have thus become a disincentive to investment.
On the flanks, the members of the cardboard generation are also getting restive. Many of their signs attest to the fact that these are people who want to work but cannot find jobs.
Unconfirmed reports say there are 9.5-million South Africans in this predicament. Now they’re organising themselves into an unemployed movement and rightly, or wrongly, they blame trade unions for their predicament.
Corley Mashego, the leader of the ‘Malamulela Movement’ that has 50,000-unemployed graduate, says “We want an environment favourable to job creation and a flexible labour market.”
That this call for “labour flexibility” should come from its left and from its right has posed the ruling African National Congress (ANC) with a conundrum.
It’s further complicated by the fact that the Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) – which has 1.8-million members – is the ANC’s alliance partner and helped secure its massive victory in last month’s election.
Cosatu, which is the country’s largest trade union federation, is weary of any talk of labour flexibility. “Business,” declares Cosatu leader Zwelinzima Vavi “wants to go back to apartheid in the workplace. Centralised bargaining will be smashed and industrial unions weakened. Gains made by women will be weakened and related rights undermined.”
Trade unions are concerned that foreign investors want an unfettered labour market like those of the Asian Tiger economies. They are squaring up for a fight that will place the question of labour rights at the top of the South African political agenda.
Still, government announced last week that its review of the labour law process would continue. By mid-August, it will decide which sections of the laws will be changed. A key change will be to exempt businesses that employ fewer than 10 workers and to amend retrenchment and dismissal provisions.
“The balance has to be struck between employment and security and the ability to hire and fire at will,” says Labour Minister Membathisi Mdladlana, adding, “when you’re talking about human beings, you must be humane”.
Government is also happy that an International Labour Organisation (ILO) study of the South African labour market is flexible. Four in 10 workers are now so-called atypical workers who are employed on short-term contracts or as casual workers.
It also found that employers had notched up an eight in ten- success rate when they applied for exemptions from the labour laws.
Mbeki also extensively quoted the report in his first state of the nation address two weeks ago – indicating that government is not planning a major clampdown on labour rights. Instead, the president is pressing for an Accord for Employment and Growth to be reached between government, business and labour in which they hammer out a mutually acceptable wage, price and interest rate policy.
Again, the president faces flak from all quarters. Trade unions balk at such an Accord because it has entailed wage restraint in a country where it has been tried, while business wants central bank independence in the setting of interest rates and inflation policy.
Like all developing countries in a new global order, South Africa must walk a tightrope of competing interests in which the most powerful voices bay loudest for the changes they want.
It’s not clear whether the new government will heed the cardboard cries of those who populate the intersections of South African cities.
In his first address to parliament as South African president, following his election on June 2, Mbeki said, “The challenge is to build a caring society with a good quality of life. The society we seek to replace is built on the law of the jungle.”
“The weakest become the landless, the unemployed, the uneducated, the surplus people. Among these are those in the cities and towns who have lost all hope and all self-worth,” he said.